link
To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Government’s response is to reports from the Auditor General for Scotland that it underspent its budget by almost £350 million in 2014-15. (S4F-03000)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Government’s response is to reports from the Auditor General for Scotland that it underspent its budget by almost £350 million in 2014-15. (S4F-03000)
I welcome the fact that the Auditor General has—yet again—provided an unqualified audit opinion on the Scottish Government’s 2014-15 consolidated accounts. That has been the case in every year of this Administration.
The Deputy First Minister announced the provisional outturn for 2014-15 in June and that position has not changed. The full cash underspend for 2014-15 is being carried forward into the current financial year, 2015-16. The Government’s approach represents and will continue to represent sensible budgeting, reflecting fluctuations in cost and demand across the spending review period, and will ensure that there is no loss of spending power in Scotland.
link
In June 2009, the finance secretary announced an underspend of £31 million and said:
“Long gone are the days when hundreds of millions of pounds of Government money would be underspent each year, doing nothing to help communities across the country.”
What will those communities make of an underspend that is more than 10 times the amount in 2009?
It might be worth just giving a little bit more context and detail here—otherwise known as facts. [Interruption.]
Order.
Of the figure that Murdo Fraser cites, it is worth pointing out that about £150 million is what is called non-cash. That means that it cannot be spent on services—it can never be spent on services—because it represents differences in accounting estimates, for example in depreciation of assets.
The rest of the underspend comes about because the Government has to manage its budget within a context of, first, not legally being able to overspend and, secondly, not being able to borrow. We have to manage our budget through the year to make sure that we do not overshoot it. However, every single penny of the underspend that is capable of being spent is transferred into the next year and spent on public services. Not a penny of it—[Interruption.]
Order.
My Deputy First Minister is shouting that the Conservatives are fiscally illiterate. I could not possibly comment.
Not a single penny is lost to the public purse.
The final point that I want to make might be of particular interest to Murdo Fraser, because the amount that we underspent and can spend, and therefore carry forward, is 0.7 per cent of our fiscal departmental expenditure limit budget. The UK Government’s underspend—when we take out spending in devolved Administrations—amounts to 1.2 per cent of its fiscal budget, which means that the Scottish Government is much better at managing its money than Murdo Fraser’s Westminster colleagues.
Now that the First Minister has outed the Deputy First Minister, I remind him that he should not be making comments from a sedentary position.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.