To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-03004)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kezia Dugdale Lab 8
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 8
- Tricia Marwick 7
The record
23 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s ambitious programme for Scotland.
It is now a week since the First Minister was asked about the serious allegations around the property deals of her business spokesperson Michelle Thomson. Since then, the list of questions has only grown.
We were grateful to the Lord Advocate for coming to the chamber to make it clear that the delay in pursuing the case against the lawyer representing Michelle Thomson was down to the Law Society of Scotland. We now know that it was not the Crown Office that delayed investigations by more than a year, but we do not know who did so or why.
As I said last week, I am not asking the First Minister to comment on a live police investigation. However, does she think that the Law Society, in delaying action on the case for so many months, has met its responsibilities on the matter?
In the long list of ridiculous questions that I have been asked by Labour in the chamber over a series of months, that one takes the biscuit. I am not responsible for the Law Society of Scotland—[Interruption.]
Order.
The Law Society of Scotland is an independent regulatory body. If Kezia Dugdale has questions for the society, I suggest that she would be better advised to direct those questions to it.
I said last week—and it is worth repeating today—that serious allegations have been made, and I take those allegations very seriously. If they are proven, that would be serious and, in my view, unacceptable. However, a police investigation is under way, and earlier this week we heard that a referral has been made to the Westminster Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards. It would therefore be prejudicial for me to comment in detail on the substance of allegations that are under live investigation—[Interruption.]
Order.
Everyone—even MPs—is entitled to due process and a presumption of innocence. Let us allow the investigation to proceed. When it concludes, if there are questions to be answered or if I require to take any action as Scottish National Party leader, that will happen.
I make it clear that I take, and will always take, responsibility for any action that relates to the SNP. With the greatest respect, however, I will not take sanctimonious lectures from a Labour Party that in the previous session of Parliament watched five of its MPs or former MPs be sent to jail. [Interruption.]
Order. I call Ms Dugdale.
The Law Society has duties around the regulation of solicitors that are gifted to it by an act of Parliament. The society is also an integral part of our justice system, and the First Minister has ultimate responsibility for that justice system. That matters because people must have confidence that the system treats everyone the same, regardless of party or position. The public will not accept any perception, fair or otherwise, that the Scottish establishment is closing ranks to protect one of its own—[Interruption.]
Order.
Not when vulnerable families have been taken advantage of in that way, and not when we see pensioners on our television screens talking about how they have been exploited.
Will the First Minister join me in calling on the Law Society to hold a proper, independent, external inquiry into the matter and to publish all papers relating to the delay?
I think that the Law Society should answer all and any questions that are directed to it. I cannot answer on behalf of an independent organisation, but I would certainly welcome publication of any or all documents relating to this case.
The Law Society is a regular and vociferous critic of this Government on a wide range of policy issues—as I am sure Kezia Dugdale will know, because even if she has not done so personally, many members on the Labour benches will have quoted those criticisms on umpteen occasions. Presiding Officer, can you imagine the outcry if, on one or other of the issues on which the Law Society takes the opposite view to that of this Government, I asked for an investigation into the running of the Law Society? The Opposition, rightly, would be up in arms. The Law Society is an independent organisation.
What we heard in this chamber from the independent Lord Advocate is the fact that the Crown Office acted speedily and appropriately when it received the referral from the Law Society. The matter has now been referred to the police and a live police investigation is under way. I think that it is incumbent on all of us to allow that police investigation to do its work.
I welcome that answer from the First Minister and the support that she offered for full publication from the Law Society. I think that that is welcome progress.
Members: Oh!
I welcome the answer and still they groan.
There are more than questions of legality here; there are questions of judgment. Last week, the First Minister told us that she did not know about the case in question until she read about it in the papers, and I take her at her word. However, we still have not had an explanation for the fact that the First Minister personally appointed Michelle Thomson to lead on business policy for the SNP. There is a contradiction here: on the one hand, everybody in the SNP praised Michelle Thomson for her business experience; but on the other hand, the First Minister says that nobody in the SNP knew anything about Michelle Thomson’s business experience. That does not stack up.
Michelle Thomson’s company boasted that the increase in the number of people struggling to pay their mortgage during the recession was “a great opportunity” and that if people were emotionally distant they could make a “huge profit”. I ask the First Minister: is preying on desperate people ever an ethical way to run a business?
No, I do not think that it is. If those allegations and any other allegations are proven—[Interruption.]
Order. Let us hear the First Minister.
As I said last week, we will treat that as a serious matter. As I also said last week and as I say again today, I did not, and the SNP did not, have any prior knowledge of the serious allegations that have been made. If Kezia Dugdale has evidence to the contrary, she should bring that to the chamber instead of simply indulging in insinuation.
I picked up on Kezia Dugdale’s comment about judgment. I think that that is important because the judgment that I take seriously—in fact, the only judgement that matters to any of us in here—is the judgment of the Scottish people. I think that Kezia Dugdale should occasionally look at what is happening outside this chamber. For the past eight years, all that we have heard from her and her colleagues is “SNP bad, SNP bad, SNP bad”, but all that has happened in that time is that SNP support has risen and Labour support has declined. It is perhaps time for a new tactic by Kezia Dugdale before it is far too late for a party that is dying on its feet. [Applause.]
Order. Let us hear Ms Dugdale.
I came to the chamber to ask questions about businesses that make their money from exploiting vulnerable people, and the First Minister’s response was to refer to a poll and tell us that everyone loves her. That is really quite incredible.
This is the last First Minister’s questions before the SNP conference. We know that Michelle Thomson was due to play a starring role at the conference, hosting a fringe event called “What is stopping UK businesses from exploring new markets?”. The First Minister personally endorsed Michelle Thomson as a candidate saying:
“Michelle knows what she’s doing”.
Now we all know what Michelle was doing.
Is it not time for the First Minister to admit— [Interruption.]
Order.
Is it not time for the First Minister to admit that Michelle Thomson’s business dealings were wrong, that she was wrong to appoint her and that it would be wrong for Michelle Thomson to return as an SNP MP?
I will continue to take the approach that I set out last week and set out again today, which is to allow investigations to take their course and to act on the conclusion of those investigations. It is because the allegations are serious and because they are being treated as serious that, right now, Michelle Thomson is not a member of the SNP, she does not hold the SNP whip at Westminster, she is not a spokesperson for the SNP and she will not be attending the SNP conference. That is what happens when serious allegations are raised that concern the SNP. If only Labour, down the years, had always acted as appropriately as that, we might be in a different situation.
I will continue to act appropriately, and I say to Kezia Dugdale that she should do likewise because, if she continues to indulge in the behaviour that we have seen repeatedly from her and her colleagues, I think that her and her party’s fortunes will continue to go in the same direction that they have been going in for quite some time.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 8 Oct 2015 →- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- National Film Studio Questions · 6
- NHS Fife (Consultant Vacancies) Questions · 4
- Rail Investment Programme Questions · 12
- Long-distance Rail Routes Questions · 7
- Flu Vaccinations Questions · 4
- Planning System Questions · 5
- Stirling Council (Sport) Questions · 4
- Economy (Central Scotland) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 23
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Police Opinion Survey First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Refugee Crisis First Minister’s Questions · 4
- “The Cost of the School Day" First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Budget 2014-15 (Underspend) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- HM Naval Base Clyde (Spending) Members’ business · 42
- Further Education (Glasgow) Statement · 31
- Smoking Prohibition (Children in Motor Vehicles) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 34
- Decision Time Decision time · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.