Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Youth Football (PE1319)

Tuesday 23 June 2015 Public Petitions Committee About 10:45–11:15 Petitions 25 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

25 contributions
John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

The next continued petition is PE1319, by William Smith and Scott Robertson, on improving youth football in Scotland. As previously agreed, we are taking evidence from Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People. Members have a clerk’s note and the commissioner’s report.

I welcome commissioner Tam Baillie to the meeting. He is accompanied by Gillian Munro, his information officer. I invite Mr Baillie to make a short opening statement of no more than five minutes. We will then move on to questions.

I also welcome to the meeting Chic Brodie MSP, who has an interest in the petition.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

Thank you for the invitation. I want to set the context for the production of the report that led to today’s hearing.

I believe that the petition is the second most long-standing that the committee is considering. Late last year, I was approached by the then committee convener, David Stewart. Evidence had been provided to the committee on, I think, two occasions, and it had also received lots of written evidence, some of which was conflicting. In order to provide further information to the committee, I was asked to get the views of children and young people who are involved in youth football.

We offered to do two things. As you will see in the report, we have produced what we call a child rights impact assessment, which looks at all the information that is in the public domain and assesses whether the practices have an impact on children’s rights. Gillian Munro was the main author of that assessment.

We also commissioned academics from the University of Edinburgh to engage with children and young people. They involved 28 young people in focus groups and undertook individual interviews with 19 young people in a fairly comprehensive exercise. It came across difficult ethical issues. Young people who are signed to clubs are living their dream, so we had to ensure that they were properly protected when they made statements or gave us information.

I am delighted to be here. I will touch on a number of the findings. There is an issue about 10-year-olds signing what they think are contracts, and potentially being held to them throughout their formative years. There is also the issue of 15-year-olds being held to contracts, sometimes against their wishes, for a further two years until they are 17. There are also perception issues in which young people think that they are not allowed to play for clubs or that their behaviour is restricted by the “contracts”. I would put that in inverted commas because there is a bit of a debate about whether what is signed are contracts. As far as the children are concerned, they have signed a contract and it impacts on their behaviour because they do not get to play for schools. That is not the case for all, but there are certainly restricted practices.

On a positive note, the young people really love their football. They would go to the ends of the earth to play football so we must ensure that they are treated respectfully and that we do not, in any way, abuse their enthusiasm and their aspirations of attaining the dream of becoming a professional footballer.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Thank you for a comprehensive report, which was well received in a lot of quarters. What is the report’s key message for Scottish football clubs and organisations? What is the key recommendation for the committee?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

The key finding is that when the system operates well, all is fine and good. However, when it does not work well, you find that the odds are stacked against children and young people.

I alluded to the fact that a 10-year-old can sign a contract. There is a well-meaning system of compensation for the clubs so that they can expect certain payments, depending on how they are graded for the quality and the expense of their academy or the training that it provides. However, if a young person chooses to try to get out of their contract, they are sometimes left hostage to the original club because there is a dispute over the payment. That can last for quite a long time. In theory, they could be held year on year because the payments have not been made. That is one issue.

11:00

The second issue is that when 15-year-olds sign a contract—and I will call it a contract—it is at the behest of the club whether they are released from that contract when they turn 16 and throughout their 17th year. The rationale is that time, energy and resources have been invested in the development of that young person and sometimes it takes a while for that to blossom. When someone is 15, it might take time to assess their quality and the club wants to see whether to keep them or not, but currently only the club can make the call about whether to release them.

The third issue is about children not being allowed to play for their school. The Scottish Football Association has tried to rectify that and make it clear that such a condition cannot be built in. Allowing children to play for their schools is, however, still at the discretion of the clubs and one of our recommendations is to remove that element.

We have a number of recommendations. A young person should have the same notice period as they would in youth football. In other words, if they want to move clubs, they should be able to give 28 days’ notice. That would be the end of it and they could then go elsewhere.

The registration bind on 16 and 17-year-olds should be removed—there should be no difference between the terms that young people sign up to as 15-year-olds and the previous terms.

When there are disputes, they should be resolved expeditiously so that a young person or child cannot be held for a long time and prevented from either playing for another club or moving to another club.

The recommendation on when reimbursements are paid is buried in the report. Part of the difficulty in the system just now is that compensation has to be paid up front, whereas we have so many youngsters in our system that it would be better and more sensible if the compensation kicks in when they sign a professional contract with a professional club.

There is no complaints process just now, so one needs to be built in. At the end of the day, there might be a need for regulation and monitoring, but my preference would be for self-regulation rather than what might be an expensive regulatory framework. We might discuss that later, but self-regulation would be better than having to have external regulation.

That is quite a shopping list of what we are calling for, but I thank the committee for the opportunity to lay out our recommendations.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Your report has been in the public domain now for a few weeks and you have just highlighted some of the key recommendations. Overall, how do you think your conclusions have been received by football organisations and young people?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

The purpose of producing the report was to shine a light on the issues and stimulate some improvement, because the petition is called “Improving Youth Football in Scotland”. The key bodies are the Scottish Professional Football League and the SFA. We sent copies of the report to both those bodies but we did not ask them to comment on it. We received an acknowledgement from the SFA. It is within the capacity of those two bodies to look at how to improve the system. Many of the recommendations are targeted at the governing bodies.

The report has certainly got some coverage and I am pleased about that, but it is not about the publicity; it is about whether we will change how we deal with our children. I certainly think that their rights are being infringed right now because of the restrictions on what they can do and on their behaviour. As things stand, sufficient attention is not paid to the education of children and young people during the time that they are expected to be nurturing their skills.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

You mentioned that you have sent copies of your report to the hierarchy.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

Yes—we sent copies to the SFA and the SPFL. As I said, the SFA has sent back an acknowledgement. The committee might be interested in the response that comes back from the governing bodies; I will come on to that point.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Do you think that the SFA and the SPFL will accept your recommendations, or will they face challenges?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

Well, they have not responded up to now. Given the fact that the petition has gone through the committee’s process, the committee might consider seeking their view on whether they will implement the recommendations.

You might want to call in the SFA and the SPFL although I know that you have called them in previously. I certainly hope that you will seek reassurance from them that they will be capable of self-regulation—you can make an assessment of that—before we follow up on any recommendation for external regulatory frameworks. That would be a matter for the Government, and I think that the committee would first want to satisfy itself about the governing bodies’ response.

If you are not satisfied, we should bring the issue to the Government’s attention. I have already met the minister; he knows that I am giving evidence today and he is aware of the stage of the process that we have reached. It is about time that we saw an end to the petition. For me, the end point would be an improvement in the way in which we deal with the children and young people who are the talent of the future.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning. Are the problems that have been identified with Scottish football clubs and children’s rights associated with all clubs, or are there good working practices out there in Scottish football?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

As I said earlier, when the system works well, it works very well. I cannot possibly comment on the practices of all the clubs in Scotland, because I am not familiar with them. I am, however, familiar with the different star gradings and the costs of the training regimes. I am not familiar with the exact costs, but I know that some regimes are deemed to be more expensive and offer more compensation than others.

Although the system is well-meaning, one of the problems is that the clutch of clubs with the lowest star ratings might be tempted to harness and include as many young people as possible in their training regimes in the hope that other, richer clubs will come along, and the original club will get the compensation.

I will give you an example, as we have some comparisons. Germany has a population of 82 million and, during the past 10 years, it has invested more than €500 million in its state-of-the-art academies, which produce world champions. In a population of 82 million, a total of 4,735 children are involved in the under-19 academies.

In comparison, Scotland has a population of 5 million, and somewhere between 2,500 and 3,000 children and young people involved in our academies. There is something significant going on there, given that such a small country has a much greater proportion of youngsters in academies than a very successful footballing nation such as Germany does.

I do not think that we are in a position to suggest that Scotland should put in the level of investment that Germany puts in, but there is something in the way in which Germany manages to nurture the talents of a much smaller proportion of its footballing talent, whereas we seem to take a very wide approach. By doing that, we give false hope to many of our children who are involved in the academy system. They are desperate to be involved in it because it is the realisation of their dreams, but we know that the vast majority will not have that dream realised, given the numbers involved. We need to think through the issues, and consider what false hopes we are building up among many of our children.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

How do we bring about the attitude change in Scottish football that you are seeking through your report?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

It is part of a much wider issue. Our business is children’s rights, and I think that a better and more informed approach to children’s rights would assist.

However, the issues are not confined to the realms of football—I could go on to list a whole number of areas. I think that, by following some of the recommendations in the report, we would start to swing the pendulum back from all the power being concentrated in the hands of the clubs to at least listening to the views and opinions of children and young people.

One of the key tenets of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child is the right to have and express an opinion, and for due weight to be given to it. Right now, no weight is being given to the opinions of children and young people because there are no means by which they can escape from some contracts. When a contract is challenged, all the odds are stacked in favour of the club. That cannot be right; it is so unfair.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Mr Baillie, you mention in your report that you would like an independent regulatory body to be set up.

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

We said that consideration should be given to that. In the first instance, the SFA and the SPFL should act.

I cannot direct the committee and tell you what to do, but I think that consideration should be given to the organisations’ responses to the report, on the premise that we need assurances. Unless the organisations implement some of the recommendations, we run the risk of breaching the UNCRC. There might be a challenge to that at some point because of the way in which we have allowed our children to be treated while they are pursuing their aspiration of becoming football players. We can treat them much better and get better results.

I will give you another comparison with the German approach. I have a document entitled “10 Years of Academies: Talent pools of top-level German football”. It contains a comment from Bayer Leverkusen, which runs one of the highly regarded Bundesliga academies. The young people are in the academies for football, and yet the document states:

“‘Do Not Neglect School’ is the law, not just in Leverkusen but at all other clubs’ academies. In the changing rooms, boards display which team has achieved the best average results in the past six months and the individual rankings of the best schools.”

In other words, the academies in Germany pay as much attention to the academic achievements of the children and young people as they do to nurturing their talent.

Despite the good practice that you may identify in Scotland, we would be hard pressed to find clubs that give the same care, attention and diligence to the educational attainment of the children who are on their books. If anything, some of the clubs in Scotland—as I characterise them in the report—have as many young people as possible on their books in the hope that they can get some investment through the compensation for that child or young person.

I would be interested to know what attention the SPFL pays to the educational attainment of children and young people. If Germany can do it, we should be able to do it in Scotland.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Are there any other questions?

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

First, I thank the convener for indulging me by letting me attend this session, on an issue that is close not just to my heart but to the hearts of others who are involved.

Good morning, Mr Baillie. The comment that you have just made about schools is quite important. Why would there be any difference? I have spoken to Skills Development Scotland, which says that the registration forms are not worth the paper that they are written on and that the contracts do not meet legal requirements on payment.

Why, in your opinion, should there be any difference between protecting youngsters’ rights—particularly when we are talking about 15-year-olds—in football, and protecting the rights of modern apprentices in other areas in which young people join up education with the exploitation of their talent?

11:15

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

First, it does not matter whether the contracts are not worth the paper that they are written on, because the perception of the young people involved is that they are contracts. In fact, they are delighted to be signing up to a club because they see it as one step closer to their dream of becoming a professional football player. That means that we have to build in extra protections, because the young people make themselves vulnerable at the point of signing. The Professional Footballers Association Scotland has produced a useful document on that; I would make it mandatory for young people to be made aware of that document before signing a contract, because at least it lays out some of the consequences of signing.

Drawing a parallel between those young people and those who have modern apprenticeships, it is true that the youngsters are having their talents nurtured and brought on, but we have to ensure that they are properly protected, especially if we are talking about signing young people of 10. Parents are keen to get involved in all this. One of the findings from the focus groups and individual interviews that we undertook was that the support of the family was critical. Families often put a high level of investment into their child in order for them to make progress in this area.

I do not know whether that answer satisfies—

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

That is fine.

Later today, I am meeting someone whose son is an under-15 international player who has signed a contract, or an alleged contract, with a major Scottish club. As you said, some clubs are okay, but the SPFL does not seem to have any control over the clubs; in fact, it is the other way round. This particular young player lives in Fife and often has to travel to train with his club in Glasgow. He is not being allowed to leave that club unless a fairly significant sum is paid by whoever he might go to. How does that situation sit with the UNCRC?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

As I said, if we create a transfer market for children and young people we are treating them as commodities. It is difficult to make decisions in their best interest if there is a price on their head. That is why I suggested that we try to decouple the movement of children among clubs from payment. One way of doing that would be to ensure that any payment is triggered only when the child signs for a professional football club.

The payment situation needs a bit of careful thought. It is well intentioned, as it is about trying to ensure that the smaller clubs are compensated when they put time and effort into a young person, and that there is an incentive to do that. However, the impact when things do not work out—the case that Mr Brodie mentioned is an example—is that the child suffers. That just cannot be right, and it cannot be good for the development of football to have a young player who has talent that will blossom to be stymied and held back because of a dispute between two of our clubs. That just does not make sense. I am not an expert on the inner workings of football, but I know that that is in contravention of the UNCRC.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

In the past, some of our great footballers have come up through boys clubs—there are very good boys clubs. What is the fundamental difference between that and the present approach? Is it the money aspect?

Tam Baillie Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People
link

The people who run our boys clubs are part of a vast army of people who provide, on a voluntary basis, amazing input and support to children and young people. They are a shining example of people who would do that whether they were paid or not—although in fact they are not paid.

A much wider question is how we get some of the resources and relatively big money in Scottish football to filter down in a way that does not provide perverse incentives to our grass-roots game. That is a bigger question than any that I could answer through my report. However, if there was a review of the payment system, it would be worth looking at how we resource the lowest level in youth football.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

There are no further questions. I suggest that the committee reflect on the evidence that it has heard and consider a paper on that at a future meeting. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I thank Mr Baillie and Ms Munro for their attendance, which is much appreciated.

11:20 Meeting suspended.

11:23 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 57
  2. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 72
  3. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 25
  4. 11:15 New Petition Petitions · 52
  5. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  6. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  7. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.