The key finding is that when the system operates well, all is fine and good. However, when it does not work well, you find that the odds are stacked against children and young people.
I alluded to the fact that a 10-year-old can sign a contract. There is a well-meaning system of compensation for the clubs so that they can expect certain payments, depending on how they are graded for the quality and the expense of their academy or the training that it provides. However, if a young person chooses to try to get out of their contract, they are sometimes left hostage to the original club because there is a dispute over the payment. That can last for quite a long time. In theory, they could be held year on year because the payments have not been made. That is one issue.
11:00
The second issue is that when 15-year-olds sign a contract—and I will call it a contract—it is at the behest of the club whether they are released from that contract when they turn 16 and throughout their 17th year. The rationale is that time, energy and resources have been invested in the development of that young person and sometimes it takes a while for that to blossom. When someone is 15, it might take time to assess their quality and the club wants to see whether to keep them or not, but currently only the club can make the call about whether to release them.
The third issue is about children not being allowed to play for their school. The Scottish Football Association has tried to rectify that and make it clear that such a condition cannot be built in. Allowing children to play for their schools is, however, still at the discretion of the clubs and one of our recommendations is to remove that element.
We have a number of recommendations. A young person should have the same notice period as they would in youth football. In other words, if they want to move clubs, they should be able to give 28 days’ notice. That would be the end of it and they could then go elsewhere.
The registration bind on 16 and 17-year-olds should be removed—there should be no difference between the terms that young people sign up to as 15-year-olds and the previous terms.
When there are disputes, they should be resolved expeditiously so that a young person or child cannot be held for a long time and prevented from either playing for another club or moving to another club.
The recommendation on when reimbursements are paid is buried in the report. Part of the difficulty in the system just now is that compensation has to be paid up front, whereas we have so many youngsters in our system that it would be better and more sensible if the compensation kicks in when they sign a professional contract with a professional club.
There is no complaints process just now, so one needs to be built in. At the end of the day, there might be a need for regulation and monitoring, but my preference would be for self-regulation rather than what might be an expensive regulatory framework. We might discuss that later, but self-regulation would be better than having to have external regulation.
That is quite a shopping list of what we are calling for, but I thank the committee for the opportunity to lay out our recommendations.