Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Sewage Sludge (PE1563)

Tuesday 23 June 2015 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00–10:45 Petitions 72 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

72 contributions
John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

The next item is consideration of petition PE1563, by Doreen Goldie, on behalf of Avonbridge and Standburn Community Council, on spreading of sewage sludge.

We will take evidence from the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and Scottish Water. Members have a note by the clerk and submissions. I welcome Mark Aitken and Chris Dailly from SEPA, and Mark Williams and Brian Duff from Scottish Water. As both SEPA and Scottish Water have provided detailed written submissions to the committee, I will move straight to questions.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning, gentlemen. The petitioner has called for sludge spreading on land to be stopped. What are your views on that, and what are the implications if more sludge has to go to landfill or be incinerated?

10:15

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

SEPA does not support the call for a ban. There is a place for sludge application to both agricultural and non-agricultural land. It is a valuable resource; we need to treat our waste as a resource. Sludge is a useful addition in terms of nutrients and it has many benefits for soil structure and so on. Clearly, however, there has been an unacceptable impact on communities around the country. We have to balance that and ensure that the resource is used well and regulated well.

In terms of alternatives, landfill is not a sustainable option. We need to move away from the idea that we should stick our waste resource in a hole in the ground. That is the old way of doing things. There is also an enormous cost to the public purse in landfill tax. Landfilling that type of waste also causes its own problems in terms of odours and leachates and so on, which have to be managed.

Incineration is an option and has a place; a third of Scotland’s sludge is incinerated, at the moment. There is the potential for that to increase and there seems to be capacity for it. However, there is obviously an energy and financial cost associated with that. Again, it is a loss of resource.

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

From a Scottish Water perspective, sludge recycling to land is a safe and sustainable practice, provided that it is carried out in accordance with the rules, guidance, regulations and non-statutory controls that we cite in our submission. As a practice it is well-established around the world, and over many decades sludge has been used as a nutrient resource and for soil stabilisation.

The key issue for us is to look again at the controls in order to satisfy ourselves that we are meeting the expectations of the environment for communities across Scotland. There are areas, between Scottish Water and SEPA and within the wider Government review, where we can identify practices that we can do differently.

We also need to set the context: sludge-to-land is one of the minority waste streams and there is a much bigger question around how we manage those resources. Sludge-to-land remains part of Scottish Water’s strategy for sludge management in the future. We send some sludge for recovery via waste-to-energy incineration. That is done primarily through cement manufacture and those sort of kilns; we do not have a dedicated facility for such an outlet in Scotland. If land application were not an option for us, that would have some fairly big implications for Scottish Water, and we would have to think differently about sludge.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Scottish Water is responsible for most of the sewage plants in Scotland. Can you explain the process of how sludge comes to be applied to the land once it has been produced by the sewage plant? What charges are paid in the process and to whom?

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

I will hand over to my colleague, Brian Duff, who will go through our operational practices. Scottish Water is the national waste water service provider and we have some private finance initiative schemes in place, but they are accountable to Scottish Water in terms of how they are run. Brian will talk about the end-to-end process for sludge arisings and recycling.

Brian Duff Scottish Water
link

The main process is to treat the sludge on site. Thereafter there is a three-stage process. First, we identify suitable farmland, liaise with the farmers and carry out soil analyses. Once we have accepted that the soil is suitable to be spread on, we look at the cropping details and sludge analysis to ensure that the applications rates are suitable for the nutrient levels, taking into consideration metal levels and pH. Once that has been accepted and agreed, we move on to the application stage. The application can be done in two ways: straight out to the field and incorporated or using stockpiles in the corner of a field, waiting for the next crop to come round and applying it when it is required.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

What charges are paid in that process?

Brian Duff Scottish Water
link

There are no charges.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Scottish Water is responsible for most of the sewage plants. What other operators are out there and what percentage are they responsible for?

Brian Duff Scottish Water
link

The PFI operators do approximately 80 per cent of our sludge; the larger cities’ facilities are all operated under PFI. However, we still have a duty of care to ensure that the material is recycled properly. Beyond that, there are a few smaller businesses that do private-sector tank emptying. They will deal with their sludge in their own way. Scottish Water does the highest percentage.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

What information is available on how much and where sludge is applied to land in Scotland?

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

In relation to agricultural land, there is the annual register—I think that it is lodged with SEPA—so it is a matter of public record. The register contains information down to the level of individual fields, including tonnages and analyses of the chemicals within the material. That information sits on the annual sludge register for the regulatory controls in that space. Scottish Water has a duty to produce the information by the end of March each year for the preceding year.

Mark Aitken Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

The register includes the private finance initiative schemes, in addition to the information from Scottish Water. We require the PFIs to supply us with their data.

Additional data are held on sludge use on non-agricultural land. That is collected separately under waste management licensing exemption regulations.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

You have said that there is a register of where sludge is spread. How many complaints do Scottish Water and SEPA get from communities and how quickly do you respond to them?

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

Scottish Water is aware of the recent issues in parts of the central belt. I cannot give you an exact answer on the number of complaints, but I know that there have been complaints that have been associated primarily with stockpiles. I am aware of several complaints that are with SEPA, which it has brought to Scottish Water’s attention in recent months. I do not know whether SEPA has the number.

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

I do not have a total number, but I can give the committee a flavour of some of the big incidents associated with sewage sludge that we have experienced over the past 18 months to two years. One of the biggest was in Erskine in 2014 around the time of the Commonwealth games: SEPA received over 200 complaints about storage of that stockpile, which was an example of an inappropriate storage location close to a housing estate. When the material was spread, there were, again, upwards of 200 complaints about the spreading activity and the odour that was generated by that.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I would have thought that the panel would have come to the committee today with the total number of complaints that you have received.

As my colleague David Torrance has, I have a constituency interest in the problem, which has plagued residents in part of my constituency for a number of years. The fact that the petition originated in my constituency highlights the seriousness of the issue in Falkirk East. However, redirection of sewage sludge away from the Falkirk district by Scottish Water is welcomed by local residents, and I am sure that the on-going sludge review and implementation of the Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Act 2014, which will happen shortly, will see improved regulatory controls.

It is clear that some operators flout and abuse the regulations, so there may be an argument for a fit-and-proper-person test and consideration of whether some operators should be operating. As the supplier, how does Scottish Water check that sludge is stored and applied in accordance with the regulations, and does it take into account the effect on communities of storage and spreading of sludge.

Brian Duff Scottish Water
link

We undertake risk assessments. The contractor provides us with the evidence and we go out and do checks to ensure that storage of sludge in stockpiles is done properly. We also take into account the effect on local communities. We have people on the ground and we are adding to that number, in order to ensure that we check every stockpile that we have out there now.

The checks that we do on contractors are just the normal procurement checks to make sure that they are fit and proper to carry out their role. We check that they have trained staff, and we check the equipment and their background in doing the job. That is all done at the procurement stage.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

There is no formal fit-and-proper test as yet, is there?

Brian Duff Scottish Water
link

We do a technical evaluation of all our contractors to make sure that they are capable of undertaking the role, and to make sure that they have adequate numbers of trained staff.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

That is clearly something that the Government can consider in the future with regard to potential new legislation.

What role do you have in inspecting storage and application of sludge, and what steps do Scottish Water and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency take if you discover a problem?

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

Under the current regulatory framework, SEPA’s role in relation to sludge spreading on agricultural land is about collection of information and assessment of the register. Any nuisance that arises from agricultural spreading falls to the local authority, under general statutory nuisance provisions; SEPA does not have any legal powers there.

Under waste management licensing controls, SEPA regulates storage of sludge prior to agricultural or non-agricultural spreading—for example, for land restoration projects at former opencast sites and so on. All that the law requires at the moment is a notification to SEPA; there is no assessment of whether the storage location is appropriate—that is not required by the regulations—and there is no minimum distance specified from receptors. At the moment, things are not where they should be in terms of our being on the front foot in respect of storage locations, and of the law being set up to assist us and protect communities.

SEPA will assess sludge application to non-agricultural land, as with land-restoration projects. That requires an application to SEPA, which we assess to determine application rates and so on. We inspect the sites and we respond to complaints that we receive.

We also do extra compliance work. For example, in SEPA’s east region, which ranges from the Borders up to Dundee and Angus, we undertook last year an initiative in which we assessed all storage locations to determine whether they were appropriate within the six-month timescale that is required by law. Any locations that were found to be breaching the rules had their exemptions removed or the stockpiles moved. That initiative was carried out in collaboration with Scottish Water.

Other enforcement options are available to us. We can remove a waste management exemption, which is the authorisation—the licence—that allows the sludge storage or application to take place. There is a minimum period of 21 days for that to take effect. We can, similarly, serve an enforcement notice to require that waste stockpiles be removed, for which—again—there is a minimum period of 21 days. Clearly, for people living in a community that is impacted by odour, that 21-day period is too long.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

How many inspections have been undertaken and how many have resulted in enforcement action in the past 12 months?

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

I do not have those figures in front of me.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I would have thought you should have had those figures with you today.

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

I can give a flavour of the type of enforcement action that we have taken. We have removed exemptions and served enforcement notices to require removal of stockpiles right across Scotland. However, I do not have the specific numbers.

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

I can, indeed.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I am disappointed that you do not have them with you today.

There is an added complication with regard to the mobile licences that are issued by SEPA, which have clearly been abused by a number of operators, in my opinion. Are there any plans to clamp down on mobile operators? They are continually applying for mobile licences, which are being granted because there is no way round that. Is there some way to stop that happening?

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

You mentioned the regulatory reform process, which is a partnership between the Scottish Government and SEPA. Part of that is a new permissioning framework, which will rebalance the way that we license not only organic waste to land but other waste management activities.

At the moment, there is a range of options. The 2014 act provides a framework, but the detailed proposals are to come in secondary legislation. We could require contractors who are involved in sludge application to be licensed, which would require a fit-and-proper-person assessment. At present, if a sludge contractor has a poor compliance record in one area and an exemption has been removed, SEPA can take account of that when assessing an application for future sludge uses by that contractor. The fit-and-proper-person test would allow that as part of the application process.

10:30

We could also require that mobile plant licences be used only for specific activities. I think that the legislation originally intended them to be used for on-site, in-situ remediation of contaminated land, and not for some of the more odorous activities such as lime treatment of sewage sludge, which has been a problem in your constituency.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

We have to ensure that the secondary legislation is as robust as possible. The sooner that it is in place, the better.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

Good morning, gentlemen. I, too, am a little surprised that you do not have figures with you, because I thought that that was why you were here.

You made a comment about how contractors move on. The other issue, which I sometimes find in the building trade as well, is that contractors still exist but change their names. Do you have a mechanism for policing that?

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

That can be challenging under the current regulatory framework. There could be an associated company with the same individuals but a different company name. There are no detailed proposals on the table, but there is scope to have the fit-and-proper-person test take account of associated persons. That could address some of those issues, at least in part.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

It is easy for people simply to change the name of the company and continue their malpractice. Accountability is important. In fact, it is vital. I would therefore really like to see some proposals from you chaps in the very near future.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

I will ask about some of the health issues that the petition raises and the impact on the environment, particularly wildlife.

I read with interest in the SEPA submission that most of the research that has been done relies on research that was done by the European Commission 10 years ago and desktop studies that were done seven years ago. Is the fact that we have increasing growth of housing in the green belt and that some of the work that used to go on before is now in increasing proximity to human habitation having an impact on the residents of those houses? They fear that contamination might be taking place because of the spreading of sludge on agricultural land or, in particular, non-agricultural land, for which there is less regulation.

Mark Aitken Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

As you rightly point out, the work that we reviewed was carried out 10 years ago. There is a need for some follow-up work that takes into account the new measures and practices. Those studies, which generally did not find any implications for human health, were based on the caveat that the measures were carried out in full accordance with current regulations and guidance. However, your main point is right. Practices in Scotland have been changing and I recognise the need to consider the impact more carefully, particularly the effect of odour and nuisances on communities nearby. It is clear that communities have suffered from that.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Is it not also true that, in the past 10 years, the science has moved forward and we are identifying more contaminants in the sludge materials that are used because of the eating habits and other habits of the population from which the sludge emanates? Are we becoming more knowledgeable? We get figures. There is a 99.999 multiplier in respect of the contaminants, but it is clear that, when the science gets better, we will know what materials are being passed through the sludge and their impact on the soil.

In the non-agricultural sector, what can we do to ensure that the monitoring takes place at an appropriate level and that we do not just spread more contaminants on the soil or spread airborne contaminants to the population that surrounds the areas where the sludge is being disposed of?

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

From a general Scottish Water perspective, the quality of sludge has improved over the past few decades, largely because of earlier European directives on dangerous substances and other things. That has meant that we have had more up-front controls over what has come into our waste water treatment works to start with. The sludge is therefore cleaner—if that is the right word—with fewer contaminants, including metals, than it was in the past. From an agricultural perspective, that is very tightly controlled. I suggest that we keep the other issues under review.

On the sludge to land review that is going on and wider controls, we are happy to be involved in that discussion and to see where we need to go next.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

The SEPA submission says:

“SEPA do not have regulatory powers to control odour in all circumstances (such as spreading on agricultural land).”

Who has the regulatory powers? If SEPA does not have regulatory powers in that area, to whom would a concerned citizen go to get action taken? I have heard from constituents that they have gone to SEPA—I have done this, too—and the standard response has been, “That’s not within our regulatory powers. You need to go and speak to somebody else.” Who would they speak to in those circumstances?

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

It would be the local authority, usually the environmental health department. Where there is not a specific power in law for SEPA as a regulator to control the odour—there is not in the case of agricultural spreading—the matter falls to general statutory nuisance provisions under the Environmental Protection Act 1990, for which the local authority is responsible.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

In the current review that the Scottish Government, Scottish Water and SEPA are involved in, have there been any discussions about additional powers for Scottish Water or SEPA? One of my concerns is that, when people go to an environmental health department, it will pass them to SEPA, and when they go to SEPA, it will pass them to an environmental health department. The standard response from the environmental health department is that it does not have the resources to examine the matter, but SEPA does. How do we resolve that circle that people are put into and ensure that action is taken when appropriate?

Also, is 21 days a sufficient period between a notice being issued and action being instituted against someone who is found to be in breach of the regulations?

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

I will answer your last question first. The 21-day period that is specified in law is a minimum period before the notice can take effect. To answer the question simply, that is not quick enough, as I said earlier; the period is far too long.

On the here and now and liaison with local authorities, I am aware of the picture that you painted, and we do not like to find the public in that position. We do not like them to be handed from one authority to the other. We try to work collaboratively with local authority environmental health departments. We have a good relationship with the Falkirk Council department, for example.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Is that because the residents of Avonbridge and Standburn have raised issues and, basically, pulled SEPA into the debate? Is it because of the issues that those residents face?

Chris Dailly Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

I do not think so. I have knowledge of the Falkirk area because I used to be the unit manager in that geographic area, so I know the situation quite well, but we also have examples of joint working with the Ayrshire councils and Renfrewshire Council in SEPA’s west region. We try to do the best job that we can do, with good communication and interaction.

SEPA fully supports the proposal that the Sludge (Use in Agriculture) Regulations 1989 and the Waste Management Licensing (Scotland) Regulations 2011, which apply to non-agricultural land, be incorporated in a single regulatory framework. That would be better for the public and for SEPA as a regulator, if we were to have responsibility for it.

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

From Scottish Water’s perspective, it is in all our interests for people to have confidence in the regime. In the conversations that we have had with SEPA and the Scottish Government, we have looked at how sludge is managed and recycled under the regulations and the visibility of the activity to SEPA, because sludge needs to be looked at in context with the materials and activities on land that may have an impact on odour and other things. It would be good to have statutory controls and more overarching visibility of SEPA to give people more confidence.

On the use of sludge in agriculture, the water industry and Scottish Water have been concerned to ensure that we have clear codes of practice that go beyond the statutory minimum. We want to pull the biosolids assurance schemes into the picture. The whole system must rest on public confidence in the activity, and we are therefore open to such conversations.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

That is what the petitioner is trying to do—to get the public to have confidence in the system. It is clear that public confidence is lacking in relation to the issues that have been raised by the petitioner—and by other communities, as members have said.

Can Mr Williams or Mr Duff clarify the reference to PFI operators? The paper from SEPA refers to

“sludge producers (generally Scottish Water and PFI operators or their contractors)”.

How many PFI operators and how many contractors operate in the sector? Once we start moving down the chain from PFI operators to contractors, it must become more difficult to regulate who is doing what and who is monitoring it. The paper mentions the

“testing of sludge at least once every 6 months.”

Are you confident that PFI and other contractors are monitoring sufficiently in relation to the material that is produced?

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

The 11 PFI concessions in Scotland have all been very involved in the biosolids assurance schemes and they work at the same levels of assurance that we expect of Scottish Water. They all adhere to common industry practice.

Brian Duff knows more about the contractual arrangements and the practicalities of the management of sludge recycling.

Brian Duff Scottish Water
link

There are three main contractors across Scotland that recycle sludge for both Scottish Water and the PFI schemes. The PFI schemes do their own monitoring and checks on their contractors. Because of all the issues, Scottish Water has gone on to the front foot by doing its own audits of the PFI operators and the contractors so that we have a better view of how well they are operating.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Are the PFI operators operating on behalf of Scottish Water?

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

Yes.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Has Scottish Water subcontracted the work to PFI contractors?

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

Yes. The PFI concessions provide the facilities and operate the plant.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

My final point goes back to Angus MacDonald’s point that it would have been useful for the committee to have more information today. It would have been helpful to be able to compare the incidents that have been reported in the past year with historic incidents. It seems that we have only recently had a growth in the number of incidents. It would be useful to have information to enable us to support or debunk my earlier comment that the growth of housing on the green belt has meant that more communities are coming into close contact with the spreading of this waste material. It would be interesting to know whether there is a substantial increase in reporting and, if so, what the issues are around that.

10:45

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

When my sons were very young, they used to have an expression during the spreading seasons, when they would put on a straight face, look at me and say, “It’s not very Disney.” We can probably all empathise with that. However, I understand the benefits, as you have articulated them.

I want to get an understanding of our relative use. SEPA’s submission gives an average figure for Scotland of 6 tonnes per hectare in 2014-15, but there were different averages for different uses. In Europe, the practice seems to be variable. You cite a number of countries where two thirds of sludge is used as a fertiliser, but two thirds of what amount? Your submission does not give me any relative understanding of how much is produced across the European Union and how much is applied as an average across the landmass of the countries. If that were to be calculated and put in a table, where would Scotland sit in it?

Mark Aitken Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

We can certainly prepare that information for you. It is available. We extracted and summarised the information in our submission from a table. I am afraid that I do not have it with me, but we can certainly supply it to the committee.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Do you have an idea as to whether we would be near the top of the table or somewhere else on it?

Mark Aitken Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

In terms of the percentage of material that is applied to agricultural land, we would be not quite at the top but perhaps about one third of the way from the top. Countries such as England, France and Spain have a higher percentage of sludge applied to land. Of course, reflecting their population, they also produce higher quantities of sludge.

Mark Aitken Scottish Environment Protection Agency
link

The figure is far higher in England and France, for example, in terms of the percentage of the total and the tonnes applied.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I would be grateful if a table of that nature could be produced, because it would give a better impression, to me at least, of where we sit.

Is that an evolving position or is it consistent?

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

From Scottish Water’s perspective, I echo the view that we are not near the top—we are roughly middling to slightly above average in Europe in terms of the proportion that is recycled to land. When we look at the trends and the emerging strategies in other European countries, we find that those are very much led by the availability of land bank and the appropriateness of using land in those areas. Some European countries, such as the Netherlands, have much less opportunity to recycle to land.

The key thing about our practice under the Sludge (Use in Agriculture) Regulations 1989 is to ensure that we are typing the sludge to the appropriate soils so that we do not present a risk. The approach is very much dictated by the topography and the land holders across European countries.

It will be a moving feast over time. New technologies might come on to the market that will allow us to do something a little differently. At the moment, as you have heard, about a third of Scotland’s sludge goes to energy recovery, because that is the appropriate thing for us to do, using the cement manufacturing facilities that are available. In Scotland, the key thing is that we retain several options so that we are not stuck with one outlet.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I can sympathise with that. I guess that I want to know whether there is an evolving trend elsewhere in Europe and whether other countries could be moving towards new technologies faster than we are while we are relying on spreading. In consequence, our position on the league table could change because others have improved their performance or the use of new technologies. I would like to understand that. I am sympathetic to the underlying argument, but I would perhaps be less sympathetic if we were relying on that statistic without demonstrating that we are not falling out of step with practice elsewhere.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I want to pick up on Jackson Carlaw’s point on comparisons with other countries. Mr Williams mentioned that, in Scotland, a third of sludge goes to incineration or energy recovery. I have done some research into the practice in Sweden, where 50 per cent goes to incineration. Open-air disposal has become less popular in Sweden since a sludge tax of 250 Swedish krona per tonne was slapped on to such spreading. Clearly, the issue is a matter for Government, but I would be keen to hear your professional opinion on whether a sludge tax would concentrate minds in Scotland.

Mark Williams Scottish Water
link

I suppose that a policy principle of the waste hierarchy, which is driven by Zero Waste Scotland, is a presumption against not reusing the resource in some way. A sludge tax for applying sludge as a recyclable product would present fairly significant challenges. I cannot remember the exact figures, but the value of the benefits in terms of nutrients and so on is the best part of £150 to £200 a hectare for the cropping regimes that come on to the land. I suggest that taxing that further would probably drive down the sustainability of the practice.

I have not given much thought to the matter, but my initial reaction is that it would be a big challenge to maintain a recycling outlook with such a tax.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

As there are no further questions, I ask members what action they want to take on the petition.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I would like to be in receipt of the additional information that we sought during the evidence session before we take a view.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Yes. It would also be good to seek the petitioner’s views and hear back from her before we make a final decision. I note that she is in the public gallery.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Like Jackson Carlaw, I think that we need to get the further evidence that we requested from SEPA and Scottish Water. When we next consider the petition, I would hope that the petitioner will have responded to SEPA and Scottish Water’s comments. The committee might want to consider further action at a later date, but at present I am content to await the further information that has been requested.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I should have mentioned that we must wait to hear the outcome of the review before we take a further decision. Should that require a full consultation, I imagine that the matter will continue for some time. I think that the cabinet secretary told me in the chamber that the review is due to be completed at the end of the summer. That is as specific as he was.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Do members agree to the action points that have been raised?

Members indicated agreement.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I thank Mr Duff, Mr Williams, Mr Dailly and Mr Aitken for their attendance.

I will suspend the meeting to allow a changeover of witnesses.

10:53 Meeting suspended.

10:55 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 57
  2. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 72
  3. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 25
  4. 11:15 New Petition Petitions · 52
  5. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  6. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  7. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.