Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Male Victims of Domestic Abuse and Violence (PE1307)

Tuesday 26 January 2010 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 61 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

61 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

PE1307, from Alison Waugh and Jackie Walls, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Government to ensure that all publicly funded action—campaigns, publications, action plans, projects and training programmes—on domestic abuse and/or violence is overhauled to acknowledge fully the extent to which men are also at the receiving end, and to address the needs of male victims and their children.I welcome Alison Waugh and John Forsyth to the meeting. With them are two men who want to speak, but wish to remain anonymous. I thank them for coming along. We recognise the sensitivities around their submitting their views and the bravery that it takes for them to do so. It will be helpful for the committee, in its consideration of the petition, to hear those views. I will identify the two men as Mr A and Mr B—I think that my command of the English language will stretch that far. I invite Alison Waugh to make some opening remarks.

Alison Waugh
link

I apologise on behalf of Jackie Walls, who is unable to attend the meeting.I am a teacher by profession, but I am here as a member of the public. Over the past few years, my eyes have been opened to the reality of the damage that thousands of men in Scotland experience at the hands of abusive partners. Jackie Walls, who is based in Fife, would have been able to tell you about the efforts that she has made to raise the issue in Fife and about the resistance that she has encountered as she has tried to do so. John Forsyth is an experienced journalist who has taken a close interest in the way in which domestic abuse has come to be reported and, sometimes, misreported in Scotland. I was shocked when I discovered how much damage men can suffer at the hands of an abusive partner—even if their partner is a small woman. I was even more shocked at the abuses that those men can suffer when they leave the abusive home. False allegations are common. Contact with children is often withheld and impossible financial demands might be made on them by their abuser. After all that, they are told by the Scottish Government and Scottish Government-funded organisations and agencies that men are overwhelmingly the abusers, that domestic abuse is gendered and is an abuse of male power, that violent women are simply defending themselves against male intimate terrorists, that only women need specialist support services and that, although domestic abuse can happen to men, it is extremely unusual. That can leave those men feeling that there must be something wrong with them. Incredibly, our children are going to be taught all that in schools as part of the national domestic abuse delivery plan. Children of abused men were excluded from the consultation on the delivery plan. That consultation was groundbreaking and was good for the children who were asked, but only children of abused mothers were spoken to. Children of abused men are excluded from projects such as the children experiencing domestic abuse recovery—CEDAR—project because the parent who was abused happens to be of the wrong gender. The other day, in a school, I picked up a leaflet about domestic abuse that looked very welcoming to all children, but it was not for all children at all.The current Government line has been that Victim Support Scotland has been given £4 million, and that it can support all victims impartially. It is implied that it can provide the specialist support that men need. However, that raises the obvious question why we need the tens of millions of pounds that are spent on women's support services—the situation is not that different, I am afraid.Specialist services seem to work. Scottish Women's Aid is rightly proud of the fact that it can turn women's and children's lives around, provided that it can deliver the right support at the right time. All that we are asking for is the support of this committee to help us impress on the Scottish Government the fact that abused men and their children have the same right to that sort of support. Pretending that the issue is not a problem, or saying that further research is required, is a cynical denial of the evidence that is already before everyone's eyes. If ordinary people with no axe to grind, such as Jackie Walls and I, can find the evidence and meet the people who are struggling in the face of official indifference, it is clear that what is missing is the will, not the information.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I invite one of the other contributors to speak.

Mr A
link

Thank you, convener. This is extremely difficult for me, and I ask your forgiveness in advance if I do not manage to complete my remarks. I was married to someone with acute borderline personality disorder, which was finally deemed to be incurable. For 17 years, I endured physical violence and neglect, psychological and emotional torture, positively artistic manipulative behaviour, gross financial irresponsibility, pathological and wholly unfounded sexual jealousy and virtually unrelenting verbal aggression and disdain until I broke. All I ever wanted to do was care and provide for my family. It took 12 years before I stopped having nightmares. I was compelled to stop work on health grounds at the age of 54. Now, more than 20 years on, I am told that I suffer from post-traumatic stress at the extreme end of the spectrum.I have worked with disturbed teenage boys at a list D school; I have run a hotel; I have hawked coal around the housing estates of this city and climbed its tenements; and I have taught mathematics at a state school. Whatever job I did, that was my refuge and my rest. My real work never began until I got home. More recently, I served for two years on the ManKind helpline, which for a long time was the only specialised helpline in Britain for men. I have listened to many men in tears. The fact that almost every man I spoke to was amazed to discover that his experience was not unique indicates the profound sense of isolation felt by male victims, and that additional suffering is a direct result of stated Government policy.I have had to see many doctors, therapists and psychiatrists and I have sat in many waiting rooms where I have seen many posters proclaiming "Domestic Abuse—There is no excuse. Phone Women's Aid." I had to conclude that the invitation was not being extended to me.This problem ignored is not a problem solved. Our society will continue to pay through depression, alcoholism, unemployment and suicide. I do not matter any more—my time has gone—but please help us to change course for those who are to come.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you very much. I realise how difficult that must have been for you and I appreciate the way that you have shared your private thoughts for our benefit and to help our deliberations.I think that it would be best to open this up to members' questions, comments and observations. If John Forsyth or anyone else wishes to contribute, they should let me know and I will try to ensure that they get in.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Listening to Mr A, one could not help but be sympathetic. I have a few questions for Ms Waugh and Mr Forsyth.Ms Waugh, you said that the usual claim is that men are overwhelmingly the perpetrators of domestic abuse. Let me play devil's advocate. What evidence do you have to dispute that?Alison Waugh A lot of independent research shows that men are not overwhelmingly the perpetrators.

Alison Waugh
link

Our own crime survey, which has just been carried out, shows that.

Alison Waugh
link

Was it 16,000?

John Forsyth
link

I might be able to contribute here. The Scottish Government's crime and justice survey on partner abuse, which was published just last month, draws on by far the largest sample size—16,000, as I recall—and is the most independent piece of work on domestic abuse that has been carried out for either this Scottish Government or its predecessors. Those who had had a partner, who made up 90 per cent of the sample, were asked about their experiences of some form of domestic abuse and/or violence since the age of 16 and those who had had a partner in the past 12 months were asked about their experience of domestic abuse and/or violence in that period. Of those who had had a partner in the past 12 months, 5 per cent of women said that they had experienced some form of domestic abuse and/or violence. The figure was the same for men.One of the survey's advantages for the committee is its independent approach. When men and women were asked whether they had experienced domestic abuse, 3 per cent of men and 14 point something per cent of women said yes. However, when they went through a list of experiences that the respondents might have had at the hands of a partner—all of which, although separately identified, fall within the generally accepted definition of domestic abuse—the figure for men rose from 3 to 15 per cent, and the figure for women rose from 14 to 20 per cent. It indicated that, if asked straight out, men do not necessarily feel comfortable with the label "domestic abuse". However, if you ask them what experience they have had, the task of labelling is taken away from them, the figures are substantially higher and the gap between the experience of men and that of women is distinctly smaller.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I thank the petitioners for raising the issue, and give particular thanks to Mr A for his contribution. I have little doubt that the petition raises a significant hidden equalities issue that must be exposed, but I would like to ask a practical question. Mr A mentioned the ManKind Initiative helpline. I wonder whether you would give us some more background on it. Is it a charitable organisation? Is it United Kingdom-wide? How long has it been going?

Alison Waugh
link

It is a charity that receives a small amount of funding at the moment. I believe that it has been run for years on a shoestring.

Mr A
link

It is UK-wide but I suppose that, by necessity, there is not a lot of advertising of the helpline in Scotland. It is much more widely known down south, so it receives far more calls down south.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Do you know whether it is used a lot? For instance, is there any evidence of how many calls it receives?

Mr A
link

I do not have up-to-date figures, but it receives many calls every week—dozens.

John Forsyth
link

We do have a report from ManKind with that sort of detail. We do not have it right front of us, but we could leave it with the committee.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I would like to thank Mr A for his contribution. One of the myths about domestic violence perpetrated by women against men is that men can stand up for themselves and that they are not being strong enough, but not wanting to fight back—not being violent in return—is not a weakness but a strength. Your appearance here, Mr B, indicates that strength. Whether or not you feel comfortable speaking, the fact that you have appeared here is testament to your strength. It is important that we acknowledge that, because of the myths that surround the issue. There is still a lot of work to do on the issue, but for a long time women who were victims of male domestic violence found it difficult to come forward—they still do. However, it is also extremely hard for men. We need to get society to accept that men can be victims of domestic abuse and violence. It is great to have the opportunity to highlight that issue.Alison Waugh, you referred to the Government having said that violent women were simply defending themselves. I would be very surprised if that were not a slight exaggeration on your part. However, I wanted to ask you about the CEDAR project. You said that it excluded the children of male victims. Are they specifically excluded or are they just not encouraged? The petition asks the Government to address fully the needs of male victims and their children. In what way is the Government not addressing those needs? Will you give us practical examples of services that are available to women but not to men and their children? Where is the shortfall?

Alison Waugh
link

The first priority is to make it clear to the general public that the Government accepts that men can be real victims and that, if they come forward, they will be believed and not doubted and that the Government will not immediately send someone from Scottish Women's Aid to check that the woman is all right; if it does, it should also send someone to check that the man is all right. The Government should make the culture more accepting of men being honest about being abused. At the moment, it is extremely difficult for a man to tell anyone.It will take some time for men to feel confident, but there must be some confidence building to make it possible for them to speak. We are aware of a document published by the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children that made a determined effort to encourage boys to phone ChildLine. The NSPCC realised that boys, like men, are reluctant to talk about their feelings and difficulties. As a result of the campaign, the proportion of callers who are boys has doubled. We appreciate fully that men often cannot talk about their problems and would take the option of suicide rather than do so. We must find a way of stopping that and encouraging men to feel that they can talk. For a start, we want no more posters that are only about male violence against women, because that is a sure-fire way of inhibiting men from coming forward.Men with children are in a difficult situation. If they feel that their partner is abusive and may be dangerous to the children, too, they will stay in the family home for as long as they can, because they are not allowed to leave with the children. Even if there were a refuge to which they could go, they could not take their children there; I suspect that the police would immediately be alerted and they would be accused of kidnap. I have heard of a case in which an abusive mother disappeared with the children and the father had great difficulty discovering their whereabouts or whether they were safe. There must be a safe place to which men can go. Such places would not have to mirror exactly Scottish Women's Aid refuges; they might have to work in a slightly different way.Psychiatric and psychological counselling services, delivered by people who are trained and experienced in dealing with men who have suffered domestic abuse, must be made available freely. Some counsellors may be able to deal with the issue, but it would be good to know that specifically trained people were available.In all professions that deal with families and children, there should be people who are trained to understand the reality of domestic abuse, so that they know that the people with whom they are working may include men who have been abused and children whose dads have been abused. The Government-funded training on domestic violence is good at educating participants about what can happen to women, what effect it can have on women and how difficult it is for women to escape. That is good—we need to know that. However, such training avoids completely the issue that a man may be on the receiving end, and the difficulties that apply to men, some of which are slightly different. A huge training programme is needed in Scotland—all professionals in the legal setting and in education need to be trained in the area.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I ask the other petitioners to be brief, as a number of committee members want to ask questions and another MSP has expressed an interest in the petition.

John Forsyth
link

The CEDAR project is funded initially from European money. Three pilot projects are under way in different parts of Scotland. They are intended explicitly for the children of abused mothers, and the families that participate will be chosen by Scottish Women's Aid. We are clear that we do not want to diminish or devalue the work that is done by Women's Aid, but by definition it will not include the children of abused fathers.I will add one useful observation. I spoke yesterday to the officer who is in charge of policing domestic violence and abuse in Strathclyde Police. Strathclyde Police ran a campaign—to which it gave a great deal of pre-publicity—on challenging domestic abuse and violence during the Christmas period. In Strathclyde, the figures are quite consistent: one in six of the incidents of domestic abuse and/or violence that were recorded during the Christmas period and in the past year involved a male victim of a female perpetrator.The officer explained to me that Strathclyde Police has been trying to change its approach—he called it a sea change—during the past year. The police are quite properly saying to the perpetrators, "We know who you are, and we are going to challenge you rather than wait for victims to come forward". He said that one aspect of that involves the police working closely with groups that are able to help them to understand the problem at a general level, as well as encouraging victims to come forward and report that they have been on the receiving end of domestic abuse.The Strathclyde Police website lists 20 different organisations to which women who are on the receiving end of domestic abuse can go for assistance, which include local branches of Women's Aid as well as national organisations. The site refers to lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people, and the officer specifically said that the police had been working closely with LGBT Scotland during the past year on the issue of building up people's confidence so that they feel able to report abuse.I asked the officer whether it would be helpful if there was even one organisation in Strathclyde that was able to assist the police in the same way by discussing the needs of men who are on the receiving end of domestic abuse and which would be able to encourage men to come forward and even to recognise abuse, never mind to report it. He said that although that is part of Strathclyde Police's sea change in approach, there is unfortunately no such organisation.To go back to the Government's crime and justice survey, one of the further questions that was asked of people who had experienced domestic abuse in the last year was whether the police had come to know about it. That included questions about whether the victim had reported the abuse to the police, whether someone else had reported it to the police on their behalf or whether the neighbours made the call and the police arrived.The proportion of women who had experienced such abuse in the past year and whose case had become known to the police was 35 per cent, whereas the proportion of men was 8 per cent. I entirely accept the sincerity of the Strathclyde Police officer when he talked about the need to build confidence, but that has to start somewhere, and recognition at Scottish Government level must be the starting block.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I have a specific question for John Forsyth. I know that he has campaigned on the issue for some time and has indicated that he feels that a gender-based analysis is hindering attempts to raise the issue of male victims of domestic violence and to move the debate forward. Does he wish to expand on his views on that? Like John Forsyth, I was pleased—in fact, I was delighted—by Strathclyde Police's Christmas campaign on the issue of domestic violence, because the television and poster campaigns depicted males as potential victims of domestic violence too.At a meeting with senior police officers in one of the divisions in Strathclyde in 2008, I asked how they would record male victims of domestic violence. One of the officers told me that they did not have male victims of domestic violence in their area so there was no need to record them. Would John Forsyth care to comment on the gender-based analysis and how he thinks the agenda is moving forward?

John Forsyth
link

From my experience as a journalist and from working in the dim and distant past for campaigning organisations such as Oxfam and Shelter, I understand the importance of having a framework for thinking. The job of campaigning organisations is to help to develop such frameworks to engage with legislators and encourage them to recognise an issue. That is what single-issue campaigners do. Interruption.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

John, we will just wait until that mobile phone stops ringing. Interruption. Mine is two cones and a bottle of Irn Bru, by the way.

John Forsyth
link

At least it was not my phone.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Do not worry—there is no punishment.

John Forsyth
link

In the 1970s, women's organisations started to demand that domestic abuse be addressed. That was the first time that it was concentrated on as an issue in itself. However, a framework for thinking is not a fact; it is a point of view. It has become a problem for the Scottish Government that, in its early days, the Scottish Parliament adopted the gender-based analysis of domestic abuse and domestic violence as policy. I think that there were three debates on the matter within the Parliament's first five months and the gender-based analysis was explicitly adopted as the basis for recognising the problem and creating funding streams for organisations. A framework for thinking is jolly good for a single-issue campaign on the outside that is demanding that a problem be addressed, but it is a problem for a legislature when that framework moves from the outside to the inside and becomes an ideological litmus test. As Alison Waugh said, requirements are now placed on the national health service, the teaching profession and social work services in Scotland to train their front-line staff in domestic abuse issues, but what that means is training them on the basis of the gender-based analysis. That is concerning. I worked for a while in the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, so I have experience of the mandatory domestic abuse training. It is half a training course because it is hidebound by the gender-based underpinnings and, therefore, deliberately excludes the experience of men who are on the receiving end of domestic abuse and of their children. For example, it quotes half a table in a Home Office document. Everyone knows that, in the United Kingdom, two women a week are murdered by a partner or former partner; the same table in that document also tells us that, every 10 days, one man is murdered by his partner or former partner. That does not appear in any of the training courses. I happen to know, through freedom of information requests, that between 2003 and 2008 there were 68 partner homicides in Scotland—40 women and 28 men were murdered by a partner or former partner. It does not seem proper to me that mention of those 28 homicides gets dropped out of the training. That is a fatal flaw.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I will let Bill Butler in, so that members—

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I want to let Bill in first, but I guarantee that we will not lose sight of the fact that you have a question.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Thanks very much, convener.In response to my initial question, you quoted from and made various points about the Scottish crime and justice survey. That is one piece of research, which is quite broadly based, as it involves a big sample. I agree that, as a legislature, we should proceed on the basis of the evidence rather than that of ideological litmus tests. I am all for that.On that basis, I refer to another piece of research, by Professor Marianne Hester of the University of Bristol, who in June 2009 published the paper, "Who Does What to Whom?", which demonstrated that there were significant differences between men and women as perpetrators of domestic violence, with men being much more likely to be repeat offenders. It stated:"the intensity and severity of violent and abusive behaviours from the men was much more extreme ... This was also reflected in the nature of the violence used ... Men's violence tended to create a context of fear and related to that, control. ... This was not similarly the case where women were perpetrators."What is your reaction to those findings?

John Forsyth
link

I think that Marianne Hester works in a department at the University of Bristol that is entirely and explicitly committed to work in the area of gender-based analysis. I have looked at some of the research that she has done with police forces and in other areas of research. Perhaps the most interesting thing to note about her research is that at the simplest level, although she says that domestic violence is much more of an issue for women, she does not deny that her findings are that it is a significant issue for men.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Yes, but in the quote from her research that I read out—I am sure that you have read the whole paper; I have not—she seemed to be saying that the nature of the violence used and perhaps the circumstances were different, depending on the gender of the perpetrator. You quoted an interesting statistic on homicides, but each case has its own particular circumstances, as you will know, as someone who served in the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. All those homicides are to be regretted—they are tragedies—but I wonder whether, if we were to take a scientific approach, which it is necessary to do in research, we would find that in the cases in which women were the perpetrators, that was the result of years and years of violent domestic abuse. What would you say to that hypothesis?

John Forsyth
link

On the basis of my experience at a lowly level doing precognitions in the fiscal service—I am not a lawyer—

John Forsyth
link

However, I am well enough aware that, in a homicide case, the first and often the only line of defence or mitigation for the accused is to blame the deceased. I have no reason to think—and nowhere in her research does Marianne Hester produce any evidence to indicate—that the situation is likely to be any different in cases in which it is men, as opposed to women, who are on the receiving end of domestic violence. It is often asserted that the situation is likely to be different, but there is precious little research evidence to sustain that notion.It used to be the case that the gendered analysis relied heavily on the statistics in police incident reporting or research such as the crime and justice survey, but now that the statistics have become more difficult to answer and are running against the simple form of its argument, that analysis is having to develop different distinctions. I saw research the other night that referred to abused father syndrome, which is an obvious reflection of the notion that arose in recent years of abused or battered wife syndrome. I accept that we should take a scientific approach. My suspicion is that, if we looked scientifically at each of those homicides—if it were possible to look scientifically at them, which is not so easy—it is likely that there would be very little difference in that aspect of the lead-up to the homicide.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Did you say that it is likely that there would be no difference?

John Forsyth
link

There is no evidence—

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Absolutely, but do you accept that that, too, is mere assertion?

John Forsyth
link

I say that only because there is no evidence, other than ad hominem examples, on the other side either. I would welcome scientific research on the matter, because—

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I always like argument that plays the ball, not the man.

John Forsyth
link

I suggest that, up to this point, the vast majority of the interest has been in the situation of women who are victims. I regret that quite a lot of the research tends to find what it set out to look for. There should not be a competition between victims.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Perhaps the witnesses can clarify the situation for me, but one issue is that, although John Forsyth has quoted the figures, the 68 homicides have to be looked at carefully to see how they happened and what the circumstances leading up to the situation were. Another issue is that much of the evidence and analysis is based on reported incidents. Although we can draw on figures that are as accurate as they can be in respect of homicides, what do the witnesses feel about the reported incidents of domestic violence and abuse overall? I think that there is a vast underreporting of domestic violence and abuse, irrespective of gender. Do the petitioners think that such underreporting is more prevalent among male victims of domestic violence and abuse than it is among female victims of domestic violence and abuse?

Alison Waugh
link

For a start, the research in the Hester report is based on a very small sample, so we cannot really extend it to the whole country, but she makes a very interesting point in her report with reference to police reporting of cases. The researchers had a problem with their research because, in one of the police authorities that they were looking at, the figure for the percentage of female victims was 57 per cent. That is unusual for police recorded cases of abuse. The reason given for that low figure was that the police were apparently told in training that, if they were unsure who was the victim and who was the perpetrator, they should pick one and name that person as the perpetrator, but the police in Northamptonshire refused to do that. In Northamptonshire, if the police really could not decide who the victim was, they would record both partners as victims. For that reason, the proportion of women victims was 57 per cent in Northamptonshire but much higher—the average was about 75 per cent—in other police authority areas. To me, that implies that, if the police are in doubt, they name the man as the perpetrator. I can draw no other conclusion from that. Perhaps that has a bearing on other points that Professor Hester makes in her report.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Let me bring others into the discussion at this point. At the tail end, we can try to sweep up other issues as we reach conclusions about what to do. Mary Scanlon has expressed an interest in exploring the issues that the petition raises, and I know that another individual also wants to contribute.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Convener, thank you for allowing me to speak to the petition even though I am not a member of the committee. I have supported the petition on the website, so I will just briefly add some points about my support.When I tried to intervene earlier—for which I apologise, convener, although I tried to do so through the chair—I wanted to ask about the gender-based analysis that was the subject of John Wilson's questions to John Forsyth. I understand that such a gender-based analysis has been reversed by the Welsh Assembly Government. Can the petitioner perhaps clarify that?I also understand that the Minister for Parliamentary Business agreed at a meeting of the Parliamentary Bureau that there should be a parliamentary debate in the foreseeable future on violence against men.I associate myself with Anne McLaughlin's comments about Mr A and Mr B. I also thank Alison Waugh and John Forsyth for speaking to the committee. That is sometimes nerve-wracking for us as experienced parliamentarians, so we can only commend those who appear before this committee to get an issue on the parliamentary agenda.Over the past nine years, incidents of domestic violence in which the victim was female and the perpetrator was male have increased by 33 per cent. Over those nine years, incidents involving a male victim and a female perpetrator have increased by 163 per cent. Over the same period, incidents involving a female victim and a female perpetrator have increased by 500 per cent. Incidents involving a male victim and a female perpetrator now make up more than 12 per cent of all incidents of domestic violence. It is important to get that on the record.I understand that the best service that is offered in Scotland to any male victim of domestic abuse that was perpetrated by a female is a telephone helpline in England. Details about such helplines are posted on the websites of two police forces and of several councils as well as on the Scottish Government website, but no money from Scotland is given to such helplines in Scotland. If someone in Dundee or Fife phones up one of the helplines based in Brighton or Somerset, the services in Brighton or Somerset will not be able to help the caller. It seems quite unfair that details of those helplines are posted on the official websites of councils, Victim Support Scotland and the Scottish Government when we are not willing to offer such support or fund such services.There are support services to help male perpetrators to address their behaviour through, for example, anger management, but there are no services to address females' behaviour and help them with anger management.I have spoken to the police about the children of male victims. Again, this is anecdotal, so I trust that my colleague Bill Butler will not enter into a line of questioning on it, but I understand that, when there has been an incident, the male is removed, even if the abuse was perpetrated by a female against the male. It worries me that children are left with a mother who has just beaten up her husband. What signal does that give to the child? It seems that their reward is to be left with the perpetrator. That makes me worry about their future behaviour.The approach is based on there being a male perpetrator and a female victim. As I said, if there is a female perpetrator and a female victim, the female victim will get help but the female perpetrator will not. When there is a male perpetrator and a male victim, the male perpetrator gets help but the male victim does not. John Forsyth mentioned LGBT people. We must remember that we are not just talking about men against women or women against men. We are also talking about same sex-relationships.In a parliamentary question, John Wilson asked what funding is in place for support services for male victims of domestic violence. The answer was:"There have been no specialist male services tackling domestic abuse established in Scotland to date."—Official Report, Written Answers, 14 May 2009; S3W-23659.I hope that that will change. I am pleased to say that we had a meeting with Alex Neil and I believe that he listened carefully. I want to put it on the record that, unfortunately, the SPICe briefing does not examine the content of the petition, which is to examine the"publicly funded action"to support"male victims and their children."The petition clearly urges the Scottish Government"to ensure that all publicly funded action (campaigns, publications, action plans, projects, training programmes, etc.) on domestic abuse/violence are overhauled to fully acknowledge the extent to which men are at the receiving end and to address the needs of male victims and their children."It is unfortunate that, in one paragraph, the SPICe briefing discusses female victims. I would take nothing from the systems that are in place to support female victims, who should get every penny. However, today, on Burns's birthday, I hope that our desire for equality and our compassion for our fellow man will be acknowledged. In fact, Burns's birthday was yesterday. Sorry—I am a day late, but that still stands.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

You must have had a few whiskies last night.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

You raised a lot of points, Mary. Some of them were touched on in the opening comments and questions, but we want to pull those things together. I am sure that SPICe will reflect carefully on the comments that you made on the detail that was provided.I give Mr B an opportunity to make a contribution. He has been very patient.

Mr B
link

I will give a brief introduction to some of my experiences and what I went through. My ex-wife had threatened me a few times with a knife. On one occasion, she told me that I would be stabbed if I went to sleep. I have a professional occupation and I was awake all night before having to go into my work the next day. I will give a few other examples. She threw a hot deep-fat fryer at me as well as vases, cups, ornaments etc, all of which left holes in the walls. I hate to think what would have happened if she had managed to catch me with one of them. She manipulated who could be my friends and isolated me from my family. She attacked me by kicking me in the groin, spitting on me and scratching me on my face and arms until they bled. I had to take time off work because of the injuries. She would hit me with her fists, and again I had to take time off work.She had a lot of financial control. When I discovered that she had had an affair, she wrecked my house. She threw washing powder, smashed the plates and completely messed up the whole house. I called the police at that point, but they were unable to do anything. She disappeared with my children for 10 days, and that was after taking an overdose. My worry was for my children. I wanted somebody to ensure that my kids were safe, well and out of harm's way. The news sometimes reports on mothers or fathers who have taken their children away and ended all their lives, so that was always at the back of my mind. Achieving consistent contact with social work services and the police was very difficult. Eventually, I managed to persuade them to check on my children, but I still did not know where they were until I finally stumbled on them at a garage.When I contacted the police and social work services in the early years of our relationship, a letter was sent to her to ask whether she was okay and she was treated as the victim. She never accepted any services, although I encouraged her to consider services to help her with anger management and so on. I was never offered any services.After many years of my suffering such behaviour and of my children witnessing it—that included a few more assaults from my ex-wife and threatening telephone calls and texts, and she scratched my friend's car—a warning was finally issued to her. I would have benefited from having somebody to speak to—I never had anybody to speak to. The subject was embarrassing and I did not want to speak to my friends or family about it. Domestic abuse just did not happen to men.I never appreciated the situation until I did the Fife Council training, when I sat as a victim thinking, "That happened to me—that's me you're talking about." We heard, "Males are doing this, this and this," but I was thinking that all that was being talked about was happening to me. That enlightened me that I was suffering from domestic abuse. When I sat through that training, I felt dismissed and hurt. I empathised with many of the victim scenarios and recognised many of the behaviours that my ex-wife had perpetrated.I would like the Government to consider an equal and gender-fair response. After separation, I had to pay more than £5,000 to see my kids. I have a professional occupation and I have encountered several instances in which I have been restricted in offering support to people who have been in similar situations to me. More services should be available to people who have suffered as I have.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We are pretty clear about the issues that the petitioners and Mr A and Mr B have raised. Members have asked extensive questions and Mary Scanlon has identified evidence and information in research. We want to pull that together in deciding what to do next.Under the petitions process, we gather in the petition and identify whom we wish to raise points with to gain more understanding. We are nowhere near the stage of making core recommendations but, if a parliamentary debate is in the offing, members will have another chance to be lobbied and—I hope—to speak about the issues that have been raised. We need to interrogate the information about what happens on the ground—the approach that is taken and where people can and cannot go—and the reason for the gap in services that people have spoken about.I invite committee members to suggest how to progress the petition. From what we have heard, I presume that we want to continue the petition and to explore the issues on the petitioners' behalf.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

The issue is obviously very serious. Domestic abuse is domestic abuse is domestic abuse. I applaud the bravery of Mr A and Mr B in coming to the meeting.We should agree with the convener and continue the petition. We should write to the Scottish Government and ask it what its initial reactions are to the petition. We should also write to Victim Support Scotland, Scottish Women's Aid, the Samaritans, the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children and the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland to ask for their views on the issues that the petition raises relating to the serious subject of domestic abuse and violence, and what action, if any, they would like the Scottish Government to take to address those issues.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I was going to suggest specific questions that we could ask the Government. However, like Bill Butler, I think that we should write to many other organisations and ask them specifically what they would like the Government to do. Perhaps we should wait until we receive those organisations' responses before we ask the Government specific questions. I wanted to ask whether the Government recognises that such abuse and violence happen and the importance of the issue as well as about things that Alison Waugh talked about, but it would probably be better to wait until we receive all the views from the organisations that Bill Butler mentioned. We could proceed from there.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Bill Butler suggested that we write to ACPOS, but I ask that we do not do so at the moment, as it might give us its general view. I think that we should write to specific police forces in Scotland, because how different police forces tackle domestic violence, whether the perpetrator is male or female, is an issue. I suggest that we select four police forces to write to. We could write to Grampian Police, Fife Constabulary, Strathclyde Police and Lothian and Borders Police and ask them to respond to a range of questions about how they address, report and record domestic abuse and assist in domestic abuse cases.We need to get a balance, as there is a wider issue to do with violence and abuse in society. It is not simply about considering whether males or females are the victims or perpetrators; I have a wider concern about the continuing perpetration of abuse and violence in society in this day and age. The petitioners have raised that issue. People will carry the impact of what they witness in their homes and families with them for ever more in how they perceive their role in a normal family or society setting.We should write to the four police forces that I mentioned and ask them how they deal with issues on both sides, and about their reporting methods and the support mechanisms that are in place. There may be adequate or sufficient support for female victims of domestic abuse and violence—some may argue that that support is insufficient—but the issue of support mechanisms not being in place for male victims of domestic abuse and violence has arisen today.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Can we also write to a selection of local authorities to find out how social work departments respond when they get referrals? I was struck by what Mr B said. His wife got a letter that asked whether she was okay. People would not dream of sending such a letter to a man if it was thought that he was the perpetrator.

Mr B
link

I think that police forces' responses are changing through time. What I mentioned happened probably about four or five years ago. Things are getting better now.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I was going to suggest writing to the Association of Directors of Social Work, but perhaps it would be better to write to individual authorities.I asked earlier about the ManKind Initiative helpline. I would like more information about its workload and where it comes from. I also wonder whether we can get input from the Law Society of Scotland or perhaps family lawyers. There must be a wealth of experience there of issues involving domestic abuse.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

My only additional observation is in response to the question that John Wilson asked. In answer to written questions, the Government has referred to research that was carried out eight years ago. Attitudes and perspectives have changed since then. Because more knowledge is out there, women who have experienced domestic violence feel more confident in some respects about coming forward. However, we do not yet have an equivalent level of confidence among men, which strikes me as the heart of the petition. It is about creating space for individuals who are experiencing violence to be able to come forward and not to go through the experiences that Mr A and Mr B have articulated to us.We need to explore issues with a range of folk. We will bring back the petition to the committee in due course, when Mr A and Mr B will have a further opportunity to be present at the committee. We need to explore several issues. The fact that we have taken more than an hour on an oral presentation is not a reflection of the contributors; it is more that we needed to find information from them and it is testament to the fact that we want to find a better solution. One positive aspect of the Scottish Parliament since 1999 has been that it has allowed space for the debate about domestic violence to come to the fore. We are now at the next stage, at which we want to consider what we have learned and how we can use that to address the concerns that the petitioners have raised. I thank Mr A and Mr B for their contribution.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 26 January 2010 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 61
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 44
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 49
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 32
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.