I would like to make a few comments about myself before giving a brief summary of my submission to the committee. I am head of the maritime research group at Napier University's transport research institute, a position that I have held since 1998. My present full-time and permanent position is that of professor of maritime transport. The committee may wish to note that I started my career in 1974 as a shipping clerk in Leith, with the Currie Line, and that my doctoral research concerned the subject of strategic management in international shipping. My research and teaching activities include port, maritime and transport policy, port privatisation, maritime economics and logistics, modelling the feasibility of shipping services and port facilities, and strategic management in the shipping and ports industry. I have been commissioned by a wide range of public and private sector organisations to conduct research into ferry services worldwide, including throughout northern Europe, the Mediterranean, Latin America, the United States of America, Japan and Australia, and I have also been commissioned to undertake research into all Scottish ferry markets, including potential cross-Forth ferry services; services on the river and firth of Clyde; Scotland to Northern Ireland routes; services to the Western Isles and the northern isles; possible United Kingdom coastal ferry routes for the transport of freight; and international ferry services. In 1996, I was appointed specialist adviser to the Westminster Scottish Affairs Select Committee for its inquiry into northern isles shipping service subsidies and, in 1999, I was appointed adviser to Scottish Enterprise in relation to the proposed ferry service between Scotland and the continent, which commenced operations in 2002. In 2001, I was appointed specialist adviser to the Regional Development Committee of the Northern Ireland Assembly for its inquiry into the proposed privatisation of the port of Belfast. I have just completed an appointment for the south east of Scotland transport partnership and the Shetland transport partnership, which involved advising those bodies and working on an international tender to select an operator for the proposed freight ferry service between Rosyth and Norway that is expected to commence this November, subject to European Union funding. I am currently advising the Isle of Man's Select Committee of Tynwald on the Steam Packet Company during its investigation into the only ferry service that operates to the Isle of Man. My written statement included a number of reports that involved independent research by Napier University or by major EU projects in which we had been partners. In short, they show that there is substantial evidence to confirm my view that it is neither necessary nor desirable for the state to operate maritime transport services. There is also considerable evidence that the state is unable effectively to operate a commercial shipping business and that subsidies are getting out of control. In my view, the state should seek to withdraw from commercial ferry operations at the earliest opportunity, in line with policy and trends throughout the EU and, indeed, in Norway, with or without subsidy, as required. Tenders will also prevent any so-called cherry picking—although, as Roy Pedersen, a founder member of the Highlands and Islands strategic transport partnership and now a member of Highland Council, wrote in a letter to The Herald this week, there are no cherries to pick as, according to CalMac's most recent accounts, all routes are loss making. The committee should remember, however, that tenders for private sector operations are the norm in other member states and in Norway.