We asked the Executive to explain why it chose to use a combination of powers in the order, not all of which are subject to parliamentary procedure, and why it chose to disregard the requirement in article 36(1) of the principal order—the Scotland Act 1998 (River Tweed) Order 2006 (SI 2006/2913)—regarding the citation of instruments made under that provision.Members have the Executive's response. What are your conclusions? Are you happy for the committee to report on the ground of failure to follow proper legislative practice?
Official Report · Committee
Executive Responses
Tweed Regulation Order 2007 (SSI 2007/19)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 16
- Ken Macintosh Lab 10
- Stewart Maxwell SNP 4
- Euan Robson LD 3
- Ruth Cooper 1
The record
34 contributionsYes.
That is about the combination of enabling powers, which are subject to different procedures. Do we want to report the order on the ground of failure to follow proper legislative practice or on that of defective drafting with respect to compliance with article 36(1) of the principal order?
Failure to follow proper legislative practice.
Yes, I think so.
I should refer to my entry in the register of members' interests, as president of an angling association in the area concerned. I do not see the purpose of reporting the order at all. The purpose of the order and of the combination of powers is to provide a more coherent working framework for people who have to use the legislation in one particular geographical area. However, if we really want to respond on the basis of a failure to follow legislative practice on the first point, that is okay. On the second point, the answer that has been provided seems perfectly sufficient to overcome any objections that might possibly be levelled at the order. My observation is that the issue that has been raised concerns so fine a detail as to be almost not worth the mention.
Have you been referring to paragraph 125 of the legal brief?
Yes.
It says:"We do not therefore think that the absence of the words from the title of the Order perils the legal validity of the order although it is less than satisfactory in drafting terms."
That is but one opinion. I do not think that the matter merits reporting, frankly.
Okay.
But then I could be in a minority of one.
No—I think that what Euan Robson says forms part of a general point about whether other committees understand the references we make when we report to them. I sometimes worry about the tone or language that we use when we raise an issue and mention a "failure to follow proper legislative practice". I agree with Euan Robson about the very minor point that has been raised in this case—although it is correct, in that our legal advisers have pointed out that proper legislative practice would indicate the inclusion in the title of the instrument of certain words that have not been included. The question is whether reporting to the lead committee along those lines is helpful. We could make a similar point about a number of other things we have considered today. Do lead committees understand what we are advising them? If they read that we are reporting a "failure to follow proper legislative practice", do they understand that that indicates a fairly minor point, not something serious that they must act on?Now that I have had the issue explained to me, I have no strong feeling about whether we raise it. I agree that it is minor. Committees should not be in any doubt about our advice or how to interpret our reports. I sometimes worry that another committee will read what we give them and think, "My goodness, this looks serious." How serious do people think "failure to follow proper legislative practice" is?
It can cover the full range, starting with something fairly minor. We mention our concern if that is appropriate.
But it is nearly always about a minor point, is it not? "Defective drafting" is a step up—it is a bit more serious. "Failure to follow proper legislative practice" is used for minor matters. I am not sure whether our colleagues in other committees know that. We almost have a language of our own.
Perhaps it would do no harm to give a bit of clarification. We could clarify the explanation of the point we are discussing. We could mention that it is a minor point.
I suggest that it is something to bear in mind long term, which we could mention in a legacy paper, if we produce one. We use terms such as ultra vires and have a scale on which we report issues that arise with Scottish statutory instruments. By way of comparison, a report from Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education tells readers how to interpret it and explains what fair, unsatisfactory, good and excellent mean. I think that we need to do something similar for SSIs. Either that or we need to moderate our language and use plainer English.
That is a good point. In relation to the order, the first point is more serious and the second is relatively minor.
They are both minor.
I think that the legal advisers would argue that the first point is not so minor. It is about using two, different, procedures.
The first point is a much more valid one to make—although that is not to agree completely with what has been said about the second point. The first point is about different powers with different outcomes. It is about putting two different things in the same place, which I think is unwise and unhelpful, particularly as some of the powers can be affected by parliamentary procedure whereas others cannot. It is very odd to have those powers in the same instrument. That is a substantive point.The second point, as we have been saying, is more minor. Ken Macintosh's comments are fairly reasonable and valid, but I think that they are for a legacy paper. They are for another committee to think about when it considers how it reports. It is not really a matter for us now, eight weeks before dissolution. We should stick with reporting in the normal way for now.
As Ken Macintosh said, we can take that on board for later. Are we agreed? We will report the order as has been proposed, on the ground that it does not follow proper legislative practice. I know that Euan Robson said something slightly different, but is the rest of the committee in agreement? Ruth Cooper wishes to say something about the committee's reports.
When it comes to the term "legislative practice" we are governed by standing orders. If the committee decides to report, it has to choose from the terms that are available under standing orders. There have been times when the committee has not wanted to go so far as to report on the matter. In such cases, it has drawn attention to something using correspondence—it has printed its correspondence to the Executive and the Executive's reply and drawn the lead committee's attention to that. That is another option. A report, in which other, more important, matters are raised, could include such correspondence if the committee wished to do things that way.
I think we will stick with what we have normally done. Is that agreed, for the moment? We will keep that in mind for the future. You have made a good point, Ken.
Raising and overstating inconsequential points undermines our case when we raise serious points.
It does.
It is self-defeating.
Yes. We will have a think about that.
I understand what Ken Macintosh is saying: we would not raise a serious point and call it "failure to follow proper legislative practice".
No—we would call it a matter of great concern.
We would not use a phrase such as "defective drafting" to raise a serious point. Ruth Cooper is quite right to mention that we are following the rules that are laid down in standing orders.
I think that we are agreed on this.
I think that we probably are.
Okay. Let us move on.
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Feb 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Subordinate Legislation Committee Tuesday 6 February 2007 Subordinate legislation · 1
- Delegated Powers Scrutiny Committee business · 1
- Delegated Powers Scrutiny Committee business · 14
- Delegated Powers Scrutiny Committee business · 43
- Executive Responses Committee business · 14
- Executive Responses Committee business · 30
- Executive Responses Committee business · 3
- Executive Responses Committee business · 34
- Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 2
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 9
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 7
- Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 3
- Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.