Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

G8 Summit (Peaceful Protest) (PE871) G8 Summit (World Poverty) (PE874)

Tuesday 28 June 2005 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 22 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

22 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We are joined by Mary McDevitt and Jo Ross, who are British sign language interpreters and who are here to provide interpretation services this morning. Welcome to the committee. To aid interpretation, I ask members to speak clearly and into their microphones.PE871 on the G8 summit is by Rosemary McIlwhan on behalf of the Scottish Human Rights Centre and the G8 Alternatives Group and calls on the Scottish Parliament to express its support for peaceful protest during the forthcoming G8 summit, including at Gleneagles itself. Members will note that we also have PE874 on the agenda. Can I have members' agreement that we consider the two petitions together?

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

I would like a little guidance, convener—and I am not being difficult, honest.I understand why you are bringing the petitions together, but can you reassure me about the committee's rules? I do not want both the petitions to end up closed. One of them is very current and will have to be dealt with now, but the other could easily be revisited in the future. Is it safe to put them together?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I can reassure you on that. If we had not combined the two petitions, the second petition would not have been on this morning's agenda. It came in very recently and, normally, it would have been too late to be put on the agenda. Putting the two petitions together is my way of trying to get it on the agenda before the G8 summit, so that the petition is relevant. If we addressed it after the G8 summit, we would not be doing the petition any service at all. Is that okay?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

PE874 is by Shauna McIntyre and it calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the First Minister to follow the advice of Sir Bob Geldof and lobby the G8 heads of state on global poverty.Mark Ruskell is here and he wishes to comment on the petition. I received a phone call from the First Minister's office this morning and he has said that, because of the timescales and our efforts to deal with the petitions before the G8 summit, he would be more than happy, on receipt of the petitions today, to give a positive response to them within the next couple of days. We will bear that in mind as we discuss the petitions.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I welcome that statement of intent from the First Minister.I watched a documentary on Sunday night. It featured an African child of around 16 who died giving birth. All of us in the Scottish Parliament now understand that we do not just have a right to protest at the G8 summit; we have a duty to protest at the G8 summit. In recent years, there has been a huge failure on the part of the G8 to tackle major problems and the millennium development goals.I do not want protesters in Strathearn to be thwarted from getting their concerns across; I do not want local people to be unnecessarily disrupted—and I speak as somebody who lives within 12 miles of Gleneagles hotel; and I do not want the leaders' safety to be put in jeopardy. However, we can deliver rights for the three different parties.Because there is a lack of agreed routes for marches in the area around Strathearn, there could be a complete free-for-all next Wednesday. Over the past year, when arrangements for the summit have been discussed, the attitude of the police has been, "Well, you know, whatever happens in the area, we'll be able to deal with it." That attitude really concerns me.Protesters are coming to Strathearn and were planning to do so long before Bono or Bob Geldof extended an invitation. The people who are coming have a lawful right to protest, but they have no lawful way of actually exercising that right in the area. That worries me. The attitude of the police seems to be, "Well, the make poverty history demonstration is on the Saturday four days before the leaders arrive, so you'll have had your demonstration." I do not think that that is good enough. Human rights cannot come in instalments. Either we have the right to protest or we do not.We need to find a solution. It cannot be beyond the wit of the British state—which we are part of, Rosie Kane is part of, and the police and the Executive are part of—to enter into dialogue with the local council and with peaceful protest groups to try to come to a solution that respects the rights of local people, respects the rights of the leaders to meet at Gleneagles hotel safely, and respects the rights of protestors to protest, as called for in PE871.The geography of the Strathearn area is being redesigned by the security operation to make it extremely difficult for any sort of lawful right to protest to be delivered. That is a mistake.I leave members with the thought that I do not want the epitaph of the summit to be, "We dealt with what happened, but we did not uphold people's rights to protest." We cannot just deal with the situation; we have to uphold people's rights and we can do that, but some urgent dialogue is needed. The main demonstrations are planned for Wednesday next week, so we have very little time. I welcome the First Minister's words to which the convener referred, but we need a sense of urgency and I ask the committee to consider that in its response to the petition.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

I agree with what Mark Ruskell said, apart from the worrying bit about my being part of the British state. I declare an interest in that I am involved with the Scottish Human Rights Centre and G8 Alternatives.Mark Ruskell rightly said that what was initially sought was the right to march past Gleneagles. Let us be clear about what we were asking for—to march past Gleneagles for a number of reasons. Live 8 and make poverty history make excellent points and have got coverage on the television and everywhere else. We know about the pain in the world, we know that debt cancellation is required, we know all that and that is fantastic. However, the eight guys who are making the decisions at the summit need to know how we feel and they live in a bit of a bubble. They need to hear the peaceful protest go past them because we the people—and we are talking globally here—need to express that and our protest has to be within earshot.As Mark Ruskell pointed out, a whole mishmash has erupted. There is a stigma attached to protest and accusations are made that protests are dangerous. We are all trained in non-violent direct action and we know exactly what we are doing, so there is no reason for this row to have erupted. We are now brought to the position where our human rights are being infringed because we cannot express ourselves near to Gleneagles hotel on the day. There is a short time to make things right. I do not know what the First Minister intends to say about that. However, my concern about the two petitions is that the situation is not yet played out. We do not know how much further our human rights could be pushed aside in the coming days and weeks in relation to the G8 summit. That is why it is imperative that such an infringement is not just a concern for the moment; it is a concern that we could be excluded from the democratic process and our right to speak up denied.I hope that we protect this petition and keep it open to allow us to have another look at it. I hope absolutely that the First Minister takes Bob Geldof's words to anybody with whom he hobnobs at the G8 event. It is worth noting that the things that Bob Geldof said have also been said by many of us in the Parliament. We have been booed, but when Bob says them, he is applauded. Let us applaud those words and take them forward. I hope that the First Minister will respond positively to both petitions and I hope that our freedom to march past Gleneagles will be upheld. However, we do not know for sure whether that will happen, and other things could negatively affect our human rights. That is why it is important that we hold open the petition so that we can revisit it.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I give you a commitment now that it will be on our agenda in September so that we can look at the petitions post-G8. Are you happy with that?

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

I am grateful to you for that. It does not surprise me that you would do that.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

Perhaps not unexpectedly, I am not trained in non-violent direct action, but that does not mean that I am not concerned about the problems of the third world or Africa. I have visited Africa under my own steam on several occasions in recent years and seen at first hand the poverty. I am as passionate as anybody about solving those problems. Just because I will not be demonstrating anywhere in Edinburgh or around Gleneagles does not mean that I do not care. I resent the implication vested in the two previous statements. The police have been doing a very reasonable job. They have been working particularly hard to try to be as reasonable as possible with the demonstrators. The right to protest is one thing—and I am totally in favour of the right to protest—but, in Scotland, questions about the right to protest and the damage that might or might not be caused as a result of it, is overshadowing the real issues, which are to do with world trade and third-world poverty, which I am hugely concerned about. Other people's human rights must be considered as well as those of the protestors. Of course, I am thinking of the citizens of Edinburgh and the people in the communities that Mark Ruskell spoke of and among whom he lives. The issue of rights is not one sided.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

It is important that we send a signal that we enjoy the right to protest because we live in a healthy and vibrant democracy, which needs to be protected at all costs. There have been discussions about the route and other practicalities between the police and local authorities and I take some comfort from assurances that it is intended that the action be peaceful. In that context, I welcome the First Minister's agreement to take the petitions today and to move on them swiftly. That shows that he is listening and is responsive. I would like to disagree slightly about the importance of the demonstration on 2 July. We have an opportunity for Scotland not only to be on the world stage but, through an expression on the part of all our people, to demonstrate not an image of protest that is all to do with campsites or whatever else might spring to people's minds, but of families from communities across Scotland assembling in Edinburgh to say that we want to make poverty history. I do not dismiss what is going to happen on 2 July because I think that it will send a powerful signal, which relates to the terms of PE874. I encourage people to come to the demonstration. It will be peaceful and it will have a family atmosphere. I know many people from my constituency who will be coming through. Finally, I must say that, while I admired Bob Geldof—and, indeed, probably have many of his records—it is the view of the Scottish people that matters much more in relation to making poverty history across the world.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

I have little to add to what Jackie Baillie has said about keeping things in perspective in terms of what is happening on Saturday, the concerts in London and Edinburgh and, of course, events at Gleneagles—or as close to it as the protestors are able to get. I support their right to demonstrate within earshot of the G8 leaders, as Rosie Kane said. Like Jackie Baillie, I will be marching in Edinburgh on Saturday. It is important that the message that we send shows that we are not putting our individual concerns above those of the developing world. It is also important to recognise that we should not assume that people such as John Scott who will not be going on Saturday for whatever reason have a lack of interest in the cause. On the question of the petitions, I am not quite clear what it is suggested that we do. Convener, you said that the First Minister will make a statement on the petitions and that we will continue them until that point. Nonetheless, the first petition asks us to make a statement about the ability to protest. However, if we simply continue the petition, we will be making no such statement until the G8 summit has passed. What were you saying about what we will do when we revisit the petitions in September?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

When we revisit them in September, we can address—post-G8—what the implications of the petitions were. I cannot know what the First Minister's statement will be or whether he will make it a public document. I could ask him if he is prepared to do that, as that would allow the Scottish Executive's position to be contextualised prior to the events taking place. I cannot pre-empt the First Minister's intentions; I simply welcome the fact that he has noticed the petitions and wants to ensure that the committee knows that he is prepared to make a positive response, given that the G8 summit is only a week away.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

Is there a way in which the committee can make a positive response as well?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

There would be no harm in that at all.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

Does your conversation with the First Minister's office lead you to believe that he will make a statement on this matter in Parliament?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

No. I think that the First Minister will respond to me, as the convener of the Public Petitions Committee. I will clarify whether that letter can be made public. That might be a vehicle for him to have his views on the two petitions publicly stated, but I do not want to put any more emphasis on that than would be fair. The suggestion has been made that we could write to the petitioners and let them know of our support for the petition, which would give them a statement from the committee, if that would be helpful.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

The emphasis must be on peaceful protest because, if we do not have peaceful protest, we will do a major disservice to every child who is dying throughout the world. No one in Scotland who is on any of the demonstrations next week should engage in any form of violence, because that would destroy the whole case.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

For more than a year now, the emphasis from G8 alternatives and connected organisations has been on peaceful protest. Their emphasis has always been on peaceful protest. At other G8 summits, the aim has always been to pursue peaceful protest, but the barriers that were erected were often the cause of difficulty. Peaceful protest has always been and continues to be the emphasis. It has not changed.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We can make that clear. We can write to the petitioner with our views. Also, as with any petition, the response from the Executive will be sent to the petitioners, so they will have sight of it. I will clarify whether the First Minister would like us to make his letter public as soon as I can.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Can we be more positive and ask him that we be able to release what he says?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

That is what I am going to ask him. I will clarify whether that is his intention. Is that okay?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 28 June 2005 Petitions · 2
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 49
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 36
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 33
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 28
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 22
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.