Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Scottish Human Rights Commission (PE603)

Tuesday 18 March 2003 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 39 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

39 contributions
John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The first item on our agenda is consideration of new petitions. The first petitioner is Jim Slaven, on behalf of the James Connolly Society. His petition calls for the establishment of a Scottish human rights commission. Mr Slaven, you have three minutes to make an opening statement before I open the floor to questions from members of the committee.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to say a few words in support of the petition. It is important that we set out the background to the petition, which seeks the establishment of a Scottish human rights commission.The commission would be based on article 14 of the European convention on human rights, which deals with discrimination. For some time, the James Connolly Society has campaigned against discrimination and for equality. It is important that we set up a commission that deals specifically with human rights. I refer members to a United Nations report on human rights that sets out the position on cultural rights in the British state. Paragraph 13 of the report by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights states:"The Committee is concerned that human rights education provided in the State party to schoolchildren, the judiciary, prosecutors, government officials, civil servants and other actors responsible for the implementation of the Covenant does not give adequate attention to economic, social and cultural rights."The United Nations is saying clearly that there is a deficit in this country as regards cultural rights.It is important that we compare what we have proposed in our petition with what the Scottish Executive subsequently proposed in a consultation document. There are major differences between the two sets of proposals. The James Connolly Society welcomes the consultation document that the Executive issued after our petition was submitted. We also welcome the opportunity that we were given to take part in the conference on the consultation document, which was informative and helpful. We will continue to play an active role in that discussion until the deadline for submissions to the consultation is reached in June.The major difference between our proposals and the Executive's proposals is that we believe that the Scottish human rights commission must have the right to take up cases in its name. As I have indicated, we believe that there is a problem of discrimination in this country, especially against religious, political and cultural groups. The human rights of individuals, groups and communities are often systematically abused. Many of those individuals and groups are not in a position to pursue cases under article 14 of the European convention on human rights, which deals with discrimination. If we are serious about challenging human rights abuses in this country, we should set up a commission with the right to take up cases.Although we agree with the consultation document's assertion that the commission must have an educative role, provide information and be able to offer advice to bodies such as the police and councils, we believe that sanctions must also be available to it. The commission must be able to take up the cases of people who are unable to pursue those cases. The human rights commissions that have been set up in Ireland—even in Northern Ireland—have the right to pursue cases.In its consultation document, the Executive states:"Ministers have already decided that the Scottish Commission will not be empowered to take on individual complaints."However, it offers no explanation for that decision. In our submission to the consultation, we will challenge the Executive's decision. For that reason, it is important that the petition should proceed on its own merits. We would like the Public Petitions Committee to refer the petition to the Equal Opportunities Committee, the European Committee and to one of the justice committees, so that it can discussed separately from the Executive consultation.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Lloyd Quinan is here in support of the petition.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

If members have been to their desks this morning, they will have seen a copy of the report on the first seminar of the consultation on the establishment of a human rights commission, which I attended and to which Mr Slaven referred in his presentation. When they read that report, they will discover that the majority of people who attended the seminar—representatives of non-governmental organisations and of the voluntary sector in Scotland and international contributors representing primarily human rights commissions across the world—recommended that our human rights commission would not be in the spirit of the Paris principles if it was not able at least to support cases, if not to carry them through. The key issue is that the proposal should not be seen as a potential budgetary pressure. I suggest that the commission's ability to carry individuals' cases through with its imprimatur would be subject to the rules on legal aid, which will be relevant to the commission's development. We are a new Parliament and we should consider the models throughout the United Kingdom—particularly the one in Northern Ireland. We would sell ourselves short if we did not give the commission the ability to take up cases.I agree with the petitioner's submission. I ask the committee to forward the petition to the European Committee for its confirmation of the Paris principles, which lie behind article 14 of the European convention on human rights; to the Equal Opportunities Committee, for obvious reasons; and to whichever of the justice committees is the lead committee on the matter. I hope that the Public Petitions Committee will see fit to pass the petition on to those three committees.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

The Equal Opportunities Commission in Manchester has a facility for pursuing complaints on behalf of complainants, as does the Disability Rights Commission, I understand. Will you explain the rationale behind not proposing that the Scottish human rights commission could pursue complaints?

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

I agree with the spirit of what you say. The Executive has ruled out granting the commission the power, even though there would be parallels with other human rights commissions and other bodies in the state. During the consultation period, we must tell the Executive that it has not explained that big omission.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Point 2 in part D of your petition refers to"Informing the party of the available remedies and promoting access to them".Should the measure be an alternative to or additional to taking legal action in a court?

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

Individuals would have the right to take action in court. However, the important factor is people who cannot do so. Article 14 is about individuals and groups who are discriminated against. The commission must have the right to take cases in its name on behalf of marginalised people.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I am not sure whether our views meet. Lloyd Quinan mentioned legal aid. If you had your way, you would hope that someone who approached the commission would have access to legal aid in the normal way. I still wonder whether you consider the commission a substitute for the courts or a way of giving people a choice.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

We think that the commission would be in addition to, and not a substitute for, the courts.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Apart from Northern Ireland and Ireland, do you know whether any other places in the European Union have such systems? We could find that out.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

I do not know, but no human rights commission that has been established recently has omitted the right of the commission to take up cases. The spirit of the Paris principles is that a commission should have as broad a remit as possible. It is clear that the proposal is not in keeping with that. That is the major distinction that our petition makes.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

You asked us to pass the petition on to the European scene. Did you know that that is unnecessary? Anyone can access the European Parliament's Committee on Petitions, just as you have accessed this committee today.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

That is right. That avenue is open to us, but as we have submitted the petition to the Public Petitions Committee, we believe that it would help if this committee referred the petition to a European committee.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Mr Slaven made a serious allegation that there was evidence of religious and political discrimination in this country. Will he please give me an example?

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

I could give you numerous specific examples, but the point is that we live in a state where situations arise in which people feel that their rights are being abused.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

For example, there is the way in which the Irish community is treated at ports and airports. We believe that the human rights of people from that community are regularly infringed when they are travelling back and forward, even when there is not a security element.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

Are they, as European citizens, being treated any differently from citizens of any other European country?

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

Yes.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

We believe that the existing legislation targets certain groups. In relation to people of north African origin, for example, legislation has recently been used specifically to target certain groups. If you do not accept that, let us have a human rights commission to which we can refer such issues so that it can make its judgments.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

The issue is not whether I accept what you say. I would totally object if, under its governmental structures, this country discriminated against anyone on a religious or political basis. However, I am not aware of that happening. Sadly, we live in an age of terrorism and, on that basis, some elements of control have to be put in place. So far you have not given me an example of our Government being in default on any issue of discrimination against anyone.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

I refer you again to paragraph 13 of the report by the United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. I will not read out the whole paragraph again, but it says that this state"does not give adequate attention to economic, social and cultural rights."The United Nations is saying that there is a deficit. We are proposing that we should deal with that and set up an independent, effective Scottish human rights commission to examine the matter.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

As you will be well aware, this is one of the oldest issues to come before the Parliament. I remember attending a conference in Glasgow in 1999, shortly after we were elected, at which Mr Jim Wallace made a stirring speech. Not much has stirred since, however. Why do you think that the matter has dragged on for four years? The comparison with Northern Ireland seems to be the most significant, as Northern Ireland is part of the UK. Could you expand on your point? Do you think that the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission really has full powers in this regard? Should we be aiming for exactly the same powers that are available there, or should we be going beyond that?

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

I do not know why it has taken so long for the Executive to proceed. Action is long overdue, however. On the comparison with Northern Ireland, it seems absurd that, in the devolved state in which we now live, only one part of that state can have a human rights commission with certain powers. I do not think that the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission has full powers; indeed, I would like its limited powers to be increased. However, it is outrageous that the Scottish Executive's proposal for Scotland does not even go that far. The Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission has the right to take up cases. I would like the powers of a Scottish commission to be wider than that with regard to the ability to demand evidence from witnesses, to access documents and to go on unannounced visits. The least that we could expect would be for the Scottish human rights commission to have the same powers as its Northern Ireland counterpart. That means having the right to take up cases.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

Yes. The central theme of our petition is that we should be complying fully with the Paris principles, which involves giving the human rights commission as broad a mandate as possible. That means the commission having the right to take up individual cases under article 14 of the European convention on human rights.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

You say that you have not been told why the Executive did not propose that the Scottish human rights commission should have the powers that you mention. Could you speculate on that? What are people saying?

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

To be fair to the Executive, there is a period of consultation, during which we would like to tease the matter out. However, the omission is stark. The Executive has simply said that such a right has been ruled out, but it has given no explanation whatever for its decision. It might be that, as Lloyd Quinan said, there are some budgetary considerations to take into account, but such matters could be quite easily got around.

Jim Slaven James Connolly Society
link

Exactly.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The petitioner is now free to listen to our discussion about how to proceed with the petition. I ask members to turn to the recommendation for further action, which was made before we heard from the petitioner. It suggests that, as the petitioners have the right to participate in the Executive's consultation, the committee should take no further action but instead simply recommend to the petitioners that they take part in the consultation.That said, having listened to the petitioner's comments and the following discussion, I am aware that the Executive will introduce proposals to establish a Scottish human rights commission after the consultation is over. The petition should be fed into the system at that point. I should also point out that the three committees that have been mentioned—the Equal Opportunities Committee, the European Committee and either of the justice committees—will not deal with any petitions between now and the end of this parliamentary session. In any case, we would first ask for a response from the Executive. I suggest that, at this stage, we should write to the Executive and specifically ask why it has not included the power to take up individual cases in its proposals for a Scottish human rights commission. We should also ask it to comment on the UN committee report that was mentioned, which highlights a deficit in relation to discrimination in this country.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Convener, when you ask the Executive that question, will you also ask it to explain why a different situation exists in Northern Ireland—which, after all, is a part of the UK?On a separate point, the first paragraph of the petition refers to a deficit of knowledge among the public about the ECHR. We should ask the Executive whether it has any plans to disseminate more information about an issue that really puzzles people. Perhaps that would be one of the main functions of a human rights commission—at least, it certainly should be.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I was happy with the original recommendations. However, I recognise that other members have different views. Given that we live in a free and unfettered democracy, I will go along with the majority's wishes on the matter. However, I should point out that the human rights record of the UK and Scotland is as good as any country's.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I agree with the course of action that the convener has proposed and I support Winnie Ewing's suggestions.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I, too, agree with the proposed course of action. However, we should make it clear that a consultation is on-going. Despite the fact that certain matters have been written out of that consultation, that does not prevent anyone from reiterating the need for such a power during the consultation process. All of us who have worked on committees know that new measures appear in a bill that is put before Parliament because of responses to the consultation on the draft bill. Although the consultation does not cover the proposal in question, that does not mean that the petitioner should not respond to the consultation and raise that point.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Do members agree that the committee should write to the Executive along those lines and that our successor committee can decide what to do when it receives the Executive's response? Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Obviously, the petitioner will be kept informed when the petition comes back on to the agenda.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 18 March 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 2
  2. Items in Private Procedure · 1
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 39
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 56
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 113
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 69
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 29
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  18. Convener's Report Procedure · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.