Members have a paper on students and the council tax from Ann Thomson, who is the head of the Executive's local taxation branch. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has a problem with the order. With respect to students and the council tax, the committee says:"The restricted category of student for the purpose of the disregard operates as an overt discrimination against EU students and Scottish students studying abroad."However, the committee also notes"that the previous Order predated changes to the Treaty affecting the free movement provisions … as the Court noted in the cases"listed in the committee's report, and goes on to say that "the law has moved on."The Subordinate Legislation Committee says that European Union students who study here are subject to positive discrimination because they are disregarded for council tax purposes, but a student who studies abroad and whose home address is here is not disregarded. The opinion of the legal experts is that the order raises a devolution issue, because it is outwith EU law. That is how the law stands, but it has not been challenged. There are students from Scotland studying abroad and there are EU students here.Members could agree to write to the Executive with our comments on the order; alternatively, we could ask the Executive to revoke it or we could just agree that we have no recommendation to make.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Council Tax (Discounts) (Scotland) Consolidation and Amendment Order 2003 (SSI 2003/176)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Trish Godman Lab 7
- Keith Harding Con 5
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
The record
13 contributionsThere has not been a case of a Scottish student studying abroad where the local authority has determined that their main residence is in Scotland and charged them council tax.
That may have happened, but we know that the law has not been challenged.
I think that there is a flaw in the Executive's advice, because it is my understanding that there are no exemptions in France. A student from Scotland studying in France will be liable for council tax in France, which puts them at a disadvantage.
The converse is that, under the order, a French student over here would be disregarded.
We are here to safeguard our own students.
The law has never been challenged.
In France there are no discounts or reductions. If people have a property there, they pay the full council tax, regardless of whether they live there.
We have two pieces of legal advice; one is from the Executive and the other is from the Parliament's adviser to the Subordinate Legislation Committee. It is a question of which we believe. I do not think that I have the wherewithal to know who is right and who is not. There is a question about the order that needs to be addressed. If we agree that we have no recommendation to make, I take it that the matter will continue in another place. Interruption. I have been advised that it will not.
I think that you will find that there are different rules throughout the EU as regards discounts.
There is a question mark over the legal advice, because we have been given one set of legal advice through the Subordinate Legislation Committee and another through the Executive. We have to decide whether we simply agree that we have no recommendation to make on the order and leave the matter to be sorted out elsewhere.
All countries have council taxes, although they have different names. We need to know which countries exempt students from those taxes, because some do while others do not.
Once the Executive agrees on a legal position, it can lodge an amending order, even if we agree that we have no recommendation to make today. Do we agree that we have no recommendation, in the knowledge that such an amendment would be made later if necessary?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Mar 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government Committee Tuesday 25 March 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 13
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.