Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2026 [Draft]

Wednesday 18 November 2026 Criminal Justice Committee About 09:03 Subordinate legislation 53 contributions · 8 speakers

This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

53 contributions
Helen McDade Reform The Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Item 5 is consideration of an instrument that is subject to the affirmative procedure. The purpose of the Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2026 is to make GPS electronic monitoring legally available for certain court-imposed bail conditions in the sheriffdom of Tayside, Central and Fife. The pilot would not be time limited and its impact would be evaluated.The regulations add circumstances in which an approved GPS device may be used for a court-imposed electronic monitoring requirement. The new circumstances apply where a sheriff, sheriff principal or summary sheriff in the sheriffdom of Tayside, Central and Fife has imposed a monitoring requirement in relation to a specified aspect of pre-conviction or post-conviction bail. The regulations are expected to apply to solemn and summary cases, before and after conviction, and GPS monitoring may be used alongside radio-frequency monitoring where appropriate.The regulations also widen the circumstances in which monitoring information may be shared for local authority functions. That will allow information to be shared for relevant reports made available by a local authority to a court, a procurator fiscal or the Lord Advocate, as well as for the relevant supervision, advice and guidance.The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee considered the instrument on 3 November and made no recommendations in relation to it.We will now have an evidence session on the instrument with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and supporting officials. We will then proceed to a short formal debate on the motion.I welcome back Neil Gray, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice. We are joined by Graham Robertson, public protection unit head, and Jamie MacQueen, from the legal directorate, both from the Scottish Government.I invite the cabinet secretary to make a brief opening statement.

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

Thank you for welcoming me back. Colleagues will feel that I have never been away.I am grateful for the opportunity to discuss the draft Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2026. Electronic monitoring has been available in Scotland since 1998, and around 2,800 people are currently monitored on any given day. Of those, more than 900 are bail cases monitored by radiofrequency technology.Radiofrequency technology remains effective and has different capabilities to GPS. Our approach to piloting GPS seeks to assess the relative capabilities of each technology. The regulations, alongside the negative instrument that was laid on the same day, will enable the wider use of GPS technology in the next phase of electronic monitoring in Scotland.The related negative instrument, the Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2026, will amend existing regulations on approved devices to expand the range of approved monitoring devices that are available to a court to include a GPS personal identification device, a mains charger and a portable charger.Alongside those regulations, the instrument that we are discussing today limits court-imposed GPS monitoring to compliance with bail conditions in the sheriffdom of Tayside, Central and Fife, where we have committed to piloting GPS-monitored bail.The pilot is judicially led, with the full support of justice partners and the Scottish Government. I record my sincere gratitude to Sheriff Principal Gillian Wade KC, who is leading the development and implementation of the pilot within her sheriffdom.Decisions on whether bail is granted, what conditions are imposed and whether electronic monitoring is appropriate remain matters for judicial discretion in each case. The regulations do not alter that; they simply provide an additional tool.To conclude, our approach in Scotland has been to take an incremental approach to the development of GPS technology. We are aware of the challenges that some jurisdictions have had. Regulations permitting the use of GPS within home detention curfew were approved by your predecessor committee in 2025. Ahead of today’s session, I shared with the committee a recently published Scottish Government process evaluation of the first phase of GPS use in Scotland. The lessons learned from its use in relation to home detention curfew give us sufficient confidence to proceed with a further pilot, which the regulations, if approved, will enable.12:30

David Linden SNP The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston and Shettleston
link

I invite colleagues to put questions to the cabinet secretary. As we agreed in the committee’s pre-briefing, the first batch of questions will come from Ms Bland.

Amanda Bland Ind Central Scot and Lothians West
link

I will try to keep my questions short. Do we have an exact start date?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

That is to be determined by the sheriff principal, as it is led by them. We expect that it will be in the new year.

Amanda Bland Ind Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Okay. I understand that the roll-out will be phased, but do you have a firm timetable for it?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

As I set out in my opening statement, the roll-out will be determined on the basis of judicial decision making. At the point at which the sheriff principal agrees that it will start, it will be open to the judiciary in the sheriffdom to consider the additional tool of GPS-monitored bail.

Amanda Bland Ind Central Scot and Lothians West
link

In relation to exclusion zones, are there individually assessed digital boundaries for victims’ homes and workplaces and, potentially, children’s schools?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

That is an area that we can potentially expand through the use of GPS technology. The reason why we are seeking to move forward with an incremental process, as I set out, is that there have been challenges in other jurisdictions, as colleagues will be aware, to do with signal drift and the need to charge devices. That is why we want to test the approach and ensure—

Amanda Bland Ind Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Does that mean that there will be no exclusion zones?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

No. That is an additional part that GPS technology allows for. What I am saying is that we must test the capability of the technology to allow for that. That is why, in addition to the pilot on home detention curfew, which has been evidenced, we are providing the opportunity for a pilot on bail conditions to be part of the consideration as well.

Amanda Bland Ind Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Okay. Will the victim receive a real-time alert if the GPS device is tampered with or the battery is not charged and it runs out?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

I will bring in Mr Robertson to give some of the detail in a moment. The monitoring, whether it is done through GPS or radio frequency technology, will continue to happen in real time. That is why the resourcing of Police Scotland and justice social work is so important, because it ensures that we can do the monitoring successfully. Notification of victims where there has been a breach of bail conditions or HDC is already established, but I will bring in Mr Robertson to provide more detail on that.

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

The current radio frequency service has the ability to notify victims if devices are used in their houses. The use of exclusion zones is a feature of the current service using the current technology, so it is not new. It is one of the strengths of the current service. The box operates in the inverse way to monitoring a curfew. You put it in a victim’s house, it has a range around it, and it has a phone line directly to the victim. It will let them know straight away, so it enables safety planning.That is one of the reasons why we need to proceed cautiously with GPS. There will not necessarily be a box in the person’s house and we may not have their contact details. We need to proceed carefully to test whether it will be a safer and better option for victims, and part of that is to understand where there are legitimate alerts that need further investigation.

Amanda Bland Ind Central Scot and Lothians West
link

To be clear, where there is tampering or a breach of an exclusion zone, the offender could be outside the victim’s house and they would not necessarily know that. Is that correct?

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

At the moment, there are tamper safeguards in the devices. There is a Kevlar strip with a fibre-optic band through it, and if the person tampers with the device, that will be known to the provider. In most circumstances, if the person is in their house, you would not need to go near a victim. You could go and explore the circumstances of the tamper there. We have to consider carefully the psychological impact of telling victims about every aspect of the monitoring service and what might or might not be happening. It is not just about physical harm; it is also about psychological harm.

Amanda Bland Ind Central Scot and Lothians West
link

My point is that, on the question of whether the victim knows when there is a breach and that the offender could be very close to them, so the victim can get themselves to safety, the answer is no, that system is not in place.

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

That is the system that we have now.

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

It is not an either/or. There could be scenarios where it could be both, and it will depend. It is important that when this is used is down to judicial discretion, rather than it being directed to be used, like any other element of bail conditions is.

David Linden SNP The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston and Shettleston
link

I will go to Ms Chapman for a question, and then I will come to Ms McNair.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

Following up on Amanda Bland’s question, I had a question about civil liberties and human rights, but if the decision on monitoring is judge led and judge directed, I am satisfied with that.There is a question about tampering or batteries failing or whatever, but there is also a broader question about the security of the system and its robustness against, for example, cyber attack. Can you give us more assurances on that?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

With any digital system, we must ensure that there are protections and safeguards against cyber attack—that will not be unique to this system. However, I take Ms Chapman’s point. We are progressing cautiously and bringing forward a pilot to ensure that we are able to assess some of those concerns. The answers that Mr Robertson has provided about some of the system’s potential limitations mean that this technology is not foolproof or beyond reproach. We want to test how the technology can work, particularly in relation to the possibility of tampering and the obligation for the individual to charge their device, which are differences between this technology and the radio frequency system, where there is not that requirement. There has been evidence in other jurisdictions of that being a particular challenge. However, a failure to charge the device, depending on the strictures that are put down by the judiciary, could and should be considered a failure to comply with bail conditions. There are clear implications as to what would happen if there is such a failure.

David Linden SNP The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston and Shettleston
link

Thank you, Ms Chapman. Ms McNair, were you looking to come in?

Marie McNair SNP Clydebank and Milngavie
link

Yes, convener. I am interested in finding out why this sheriffdom was selected.

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

I will bring in Mr Robertson to respond to that, as he is closer to some of the discussions around that. We brought forward the intention to have a pilot. We wanted it to be in a sheriffdom, rather than nationwide, so that it could be done proportionately. There was a willingness on the part of the sheriff principal in this case to take part, for which I am very grateful. Mr Robertson has been closer to some of the discussions around the willingness to do that.

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

The selection came through engagement with the chief executive of the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service, and then by writing to the Lord President. That sheriffdom was suggested, and, as it includes a mix of rural and urban areas, we think that it provides a good mix for the testing.

Marie McNair SNP Clydebank and Milngavie
link

I have one more question. What protections will exist in relation to the retention of locational data?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

In terms of data protection and the civil liberties element?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

They will be the same as with any other area where data is gathered. When that is done through radio frequency or radio monitoring, for instance, it must be done in line with the Scottish Information Commissioner’s guidance on the retention and holding of that information by proportionate means.

Stephen Kerr Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The question was asked about when the pilot begins, but when does it end?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

As the convener said, it is open ended. If the pilot is successful, our intention is to roll out the system further.

Stephen Kerr Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It is open ended, so it might go on forever, basically. What is the timetable for evaluation? At what point are you going to draw a line in the sand and make a decision?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

We would need to get to a threshold of evidence gathered on the effectiveness, which is why we cannot prejudge what the judiciary will determine with regard to what GPS technology usage can be. We could not sit here and—

Stephen Kerr Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

There will be an evaluation, will there not?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

Yes, of course it will be evaluated, but the point is—

Stephen Kerr Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Do you know how far down the line that will be?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

We want to continue to evaluate the position. My point is that we cannot predict how many cases the judiciary will deem GPS technology usage appropriate for, so we cannot give a timetable for when that will happen.

Stephen Kerr Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

In the interests of time, I am asking the question simply to find out whether it works, because, ultimately, if it does not work the way that people think it is going to work, they will not use it at all. I am interested in exactly when you put a line in the sand. You are saying, “Yes, we have a pilot; it is open ended and, assuming that it works, it is effectively a permanent thing”—that is what it sounds like—but, really, my question is: when do we decide that it works?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

Yes. That is the point that I cannot give a definitive timescale for, because, if only one case is heard in the course of a year, we can assess on only one case. We need to ensure that there is sufficient evidence to assess the technology’s effectiveness—that is why the pilot is open ended. However, clearly, we need to determine whether this becomes a substantive part of the justice system and is rolled out more widely.

Stephen Kerr Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You say that one case is not enough, so the logical next question is: how many cases will be enough? These are basic things. If you were conducting any kind of business exercise, you would have some idea about timetabling and how many cases represented a good sample. Why do we not know that? It sounds bizarre that we do not know that.

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

I do not want to prejudge or pre-empt in any way, and I do not want to place any expectations on the judiciary to have to utilise the technology. It is a voluntary process and an additional tool for the judiciary to use, so I do not want any undue pressure on the judiciary to feel that it must utilise the technology. That is the reason; it is not because we do not want to have an evaluation—of course we do. We will need to evaluate the pilot because the intention is that we will be able to roll out the use of the technology further.

Stephen Kerr Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I suspect that you have answers to all these questions but that you just do not want to say them in public, so I will take that away.Elsewhere in the judicial system, where is GPS monitoring being tried and how is it going? What is the evaluation process?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

It is being used for home detention curfew. That has been expanded in recent months, which I very much support, and part of the consideration of the expansion was about the utilisation of GPS technology to provide additional safeguards. As I set out in my opening statement, an evaluation has been conducted of the usage and the cases in which that has been taken forward. Part of the assessment also helps to inform—

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

The assessment is that, in these cases, it is an effective and proportionate usage. I have to say that it is a relatively small number of cases, but the report has been published and can be seen by the committee. I am happy to share that.

David Linden SNP The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston and Shettleston
link

This will have to be the last question.

Stephen Kerr Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Yes. In your note, you acknowledge that this will potentially put further burdens on Police Scotland, which is already highly stressed in relation to front-line resources. I take it that it is fully involved in the planning for this. Are you taking any steps to alleviate the other burdens of Police Scotland to allow it to take up the slack in this area?

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

Police Scotland has been involved in the process and is content with the arrangements we have in place. Mr Robertson has reminded me that the assessment of the HDC processes has been shared with the committee.

David Linden SNP The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston and Shettleston
link

Thank you, Mr Kerr. We are way over our time, colleagues. I will speak to the committee in private session after the meeting about the amount of time that we have taken today, because it is not what we agreed.As no other colleagues are trying to catch my eye, we move to agenda item 6, which is the formal debate on the instrument on which we have just taken evidence. I remind everyone that officials may not speak in the debate.Cabinet secretary, please speak to and move motion S7M-01586.

Neil Gray SNP Airdrie
link

No further comments beyond the evidence are required, convener.Motion moved,That the Criminal Justice Committee recommends that the Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2026 draft be approved.—Neil GrayMotion agreed to.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:03 Crime and Antisocial Behaviour (E-bikes and E-scooters) Evidence session · 153
  3. 09:03 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 173
  4. 09:03 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 53
  5. 12:45 Financial Services and Markets Bill Bill debate · 8
  6. 12:50 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.