Thank you, and good morning. I begin by echoing what I said in my letter last week, in which I recognised the hard work and dedication of police officers across Scotland. The overwhelming majority carry out their duties with professionalism, integrity and commitment to the communities that they serve. However, as I also said, when things go wrong, it is essential that there is a robust, fair and transparent system that is capable of addressing misconduct, maintaining public confidence and upholding the high standards that are rightly expected of policing in Scotland.I turn to the regulations. I want to make it clear that they do not establish a new policy direction. They implement the framework that was legislated for by the Parliament through the Police (Ethics, Conduct and Scrutiny) (Scotland) Act 2025, including the differentiated arrangements for senior officers’ conduct proceedings, which is a key principle that was supported by all parties and stakeholders during the passage of the legislation.The regulations are subject to the negative procedure. Therefore, the committee’s choice is simple: allow them to come into force or annul them entirely. If annulled, that would mean the loss of a substantial package of reforms that would implement key recommendations from Dame Elish Angiolini’s review. The reforms would improve timeliness, transparency, support for complainers and witnesses, case management, disclosure and accountability.Much of the debate around these regulations has focused on the question of independently chaired hearings. Although that is an important issue, the Government does not accept that they are the sole measure of whether the conduct system is fair. Fairness must be assessed by reference to the proceedings as a whole, balancing the rights of officers, complainers, victims and witnesses alongside the wider public interest in maintaining confidence in proceedings.10:15Some have argued that too many cases progress through the gross misconduct system and that successful appeals are a basis for concluding that the system is not working effectively. However, Police Scotland’s own data does not support that assertion. Most matters that are referred to professional standards never reach formal misconduct proceedings, and those that do so are generally among the most serious cases, including allegations of off-duty criminality.Of the officers who are currently suspended, more than half are awaiting outcomes from the Crown Office or criminal justice proceedings. Nearly two-thirds of all suspensions relate to either domestic abuse allegations or sexual offence allegations. Appeal outcomes must be considered alongside the wider volume of cases resolved without appeal, rather than treated as a stand-alone measure of the effectiveness of the system.We have also heard much through this scrutiny process from a policing and officer perspective, but committee members also need to be mindful of the interests of victims and survivors, as well as informants, whose voices we have heard much less. Fairness cannot be considered solely from the perspective of the officer who is subject to proceedings; we must also consider the person who has had the confidence to come forward, and the witnesses who may be asked to give evidence, some of whom may also be serving officers. Victims and survivors must be listened to, supported and kept appropriately informed. These reforms strengthen their position and provide greater support for those participating in proceedings. The right of an officer to a fair process is fundamental, but fairness cannot be viewed solely from one side. A credible misconduct system must command the confidence of officers, victims and survivors, and the wider public.The committee has also heard calls for independently chaired hearings across all ranks. Such proposals would represent a fundamentally different conduct framework and would require further primary legislation, which is not pragmatic. There has been an enormous amount of engagement, consultation and scrutiny over years, which first informed the 2025 act and then these regulations. It is also notable that the United Kingdom Government has moved away from having legally qualified chairs for non-senior officer hearings in England and Wales, concluding that chief officers should retain responsibility for disciplinary decisions within their forces. The Scottish Government agrees. It is also a position that was previously advanced by the Scottish Police Federation during scrutiny of the bill, when concerns were raised about interference with the operational responsibilities of the chief constable, and reference was made to the reversal of the England and Wales model. Against that backdrop, recent calls for a different approach have not always been accompanied by a clear explanation of why those earlier concerns no longer apply.There is also a wider public sector comparison to consider. The majority of public sector employees facing disciplinary proceedings are subject to processes that, appropriately, are led by senior managers within their own organisation. Therefore, such proposals move policing away from, rather than towards, wider public sector norms. Accountability for standards and responsibility for disciplinary outcomes should remain aligned. If the chief constable is accountable for standards in policing, the chief constable must retain meaningful responsibility for enforcing them.I finish by reflecting on the comments made by Dame Elish Angiolini when she appeared before the former Criminal Justice Committee in May 2024 to discuss the bill. In her evidence, she said that she was“impressed by the people who conduct the investigations”and felt that“what they do is far from the actions of people who are all pals together.”She also said:“I think that the system in Scotland is possibly nearly as good as you can get it. It is always possible to improve the system, and to incorporate good ideas that could enhance it, but, generally, it is significantly better than it was when I started as a young fiscal depute.”—Official Report, Criminal Justice Committee, 16 May 2024; c 11.That is the context for where the bill took us and where these regulations take us.I therefore encourage colleagues to consider the cumulative benefits that the regulations deliver, the improvements that they make and the consequences of those benefits being lost should these instruments be annulled, with the effect that the current system would remain in place. We have a system that can be improved.