Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Rosebank Oil and Gas Field

Wednesday 18 November 2026 Meeting of the Parliament About 15:03–16:10 Debate 79 contributions · 18 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

79 contributions
Kenneth Gibson The Presiding Officer · Cunninghame North
link

The next item of business is a debate on motion S7M-02068, in the name of Mark Ruskell, on Rosebank and upholding the Paris climate agreement.

Members who wish to speak should press their request-to-speak button now. I call Mark Ruskell to speak to and move the motion. You have six minutes, please, Mr Ruskell.

15:03

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

In 2015, the world came together to sign the Paris agreement at the 21st UN climate change conference of the parties—COP21. It was a moment of hope after decades of indecision and inaction. Hundreds of thousands of people gathered on streets around the globe, including here, in Edinburgh, demanding the breakthrough.

The United Kingdom pledged, alongside other nations, to keep the climate within safe limits and to strive for a world that is liveable, not just for us but for all generations to come. Keeping the world to well below 2C of temperature increase while keeping on track for 1.5°C is not an abstract calculation; it is about saving lives.

As Nicola Sturgeon said at COP26, in Glasgow:

“every fraction of a degree above that intensifies the catastrophic nature of what we face. If we allow it to happen, we do risk life on this planet becoming unrecognisable.

Every single leader … without exception … knows that. No-one can pretend otherwise.

And each and every country gathered round the negotiating table also knows the action that is needed to prevent it. So there is no excuse for failing to act.”

Nicola Sturgeon was right, and she is still right.

There have been so many warnings. Opening up new oil and gas fields, including Rosebank, would be completely incompatible with the Paris agreement goals. The International Energy Agency has repeatedly said that, in order to keep the 1.5°C global warming limit on track, there must be no new investment in oil and gas. Research shows that burning oil and gas in existing fields, never mind at Rosebank, would blow the 1.5°C global carbon budget by a long way. Nicola Sturgeon was right: there is no excuse for failing to act.

However, five years on from COP26, in Glasgow, all that I hear from political leaders across the UK is excuses for inaction. They say that the time is not right, that the lights would go out and that we need fossil fuels to fund renewables. Those myths are perpetuated by an oil and gas industry that is quite prepared to extract every last drop, throw its North Sea workers over the cliff edge and then move its capital somewhere else while blaming governments for daring to tax its profits.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

Energy workers in my region have repeatedly felt let down by failed promises to develop a plan to shift from oil and gas to renewables. The oil and gas industry clearly has no interest in securing long-term sustainable jobs for those workers.

Does Mark Ruskell agree that we need a coherent strategy for investment in renewables, which would leverage investment from the private sector alongside state support, to ensure that workers have the certainty that such a strategy would provide instead of having to rely on a mythical failed promise such as Rosebank?

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Maggie Chapman is absolutely right. Workers in the north-east have been continuously failed. Even at times in the past 10 years when we saw record profits, we saw record job losses. The time for a plan is long overdue, as is the time for this Government to come up with an energy strategy that shows how public and private investment can work together.

This year, we have seen the Government’s commitment to a green energy transition slip. Ministers have already met with one of the developers behind Rosebank four times to discuss how projects can be brought on stream. In the past month, cabinet members welcomed the approval of Jackdaw and signed off on a new gas-fired power station at Peterhead. Last week, the First Minister confirmed that his party opposes UK legislation that would ban new oil and gas exploration. That is reckless, especially given that it comes from the same party that welcomed the world to COP26, in Glasgow, only five years ago. This is disaster capitalism. It is a headlong rush to maximise profits in the face of energy insecurity. It gives not a thought to the impact on the generations that will come after us.

Last week, the secretary general of the United Nations said at COP31 that

“fossil fuel interests keep making a killing while killing our planet.”

Let us be clear about Rosebank. The field would produce six and a half times more climate pollution than Scotland’s annual emissions. The suggestion that Rosebank will improve the UK’s energy security is a fantasy. Ninety per cent of its reserves are oil and will be sold to the highest bidder in the international market.

Monica Lennon Lab Glasgow
link

Mark Ruskell will be aware of reports that around £200 million of profits could flow from Rosebank’s oil to the Delek Group and that the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign has written to the Prime Minister about its concerns, calling on the UK Government to carry out a comprehensive assessment of the risks that are linked with a decision on Rosebank. Mark Ruskell made the case about the climate risk, and Rosebank would be a climate disaster, but does he recognise that it is also a serious human rights issue?

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Yes—100 per cent. I applaud Monica Lennon’s leadership on that issue. It is hugely important for this Parliament, which has committed to a boycott, divestment and sanctions policy, that the Government follows through on that enormous commitment.

If most of the oil that is being burned is to be burned outside the UK, Rosebank must be assessed against the remaining global carbon budget for 1.5°C, not just the UK’s and Scotland’s domestic carbon budgets. That points to a major flaw in the Scottish National Party’s amendment, because the issue is not only about ensuring that we are compatible with domestic net zero targets set by climate legislation; it is about a broader failure to act in line with global advice. Given everything that we know and all the warnings and advice that we have received from scientists and independent bodies such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the IEA and the UK Climate Change Committee, the only climate-credible decision is to reject Rosebank.

There is also the cost. Far from reducing the burden on taxpayers, Rosebank would ramp it up. Researchers at Uplift have uncovered that, in effect, 80 per cent of its development costs would be paid for by generous tax reliefs. With the end of the windfall tax—wilfully cheered on by some members—Rosebank’s developers could get even more money in reliefs than they pay into the UK Treasury. While the profits of Equinor and Shell soared in the third quarter of this year, everyone else is facing skyrocketing energy bills. I know of no other sector of the economy that has been given such a forest of magic money trees. Ed Miliband was right when he said that Rosebank would be a

“Colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism”.

Approval would send a message from the North Sea that states around the world should double down on fossil fuel exploration and licensing. Bullied by Donald Trump, the world is at a dangerous point where the goal of not surpassing 1.5C degrees is barely alive. With no binding international agreements to manage the decline in fossil fuels in an orderly way, approving Rosebank could spark a free-for-all—a race to develop more oil and gas and a race towards climate breakdown.

Remember Nicola Sturgeon’s words:

“there is no excuse for failing to act.”

There is no credible excuse for MSPs not to vote for our motion at decision time.

I move,

That the Parliament agrees that new oil and gas exploration licences and the proposed Rosebank oil and gas field are incompatible with the UK’s commitments under the Paris Climate Agreement to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees, and opposes the development of the Rosebank oil and gas field.

15:11

Stephen Gethins SNP The Minister for Europe, External Affairs and Energy · Dundee City East
link

We have lodged a straightforward amendment, such that any new decisions on oil and gas must be made in accordance with the law, including any climate legislation. It was a failure to take that into account in the past that led to years of court action. I am sure that colleagues here can agree that we should, at least, not be repeating those mistakes of the past.

We will continue to rely on fossil fuels for years to come, so, given that domestic production has a lower carbon footprint than imports, that resource should be utilised.

All of that is within the context of reaching our net zero targets, as set out in law, by 2045. I want to be clear on that and on the importance of the amendment in my name, which I will shortly move, in reaffirming the Scottish Government’s commitment to Scotland’s climate legislation and to achieving net zero by 2045. Our statutory carbon budget framework requires sustained action to reduce emissions, and our climate change plan sets out more than 150 actions to deliver the first three carbon budgets up to 2040. I acknowledge the work that is being done on that by Gillian Martin. That commitment underpins how the Scottish Government approaches the debate.

Stephen Gethins SNP Dundee City East
link

I will make some progress first, if I may.

Much as I might not like it, decisions on oil and gas licensing and the consenting of individual offshore fields are reserved to the UK Government. I would much rather that they were made here, but, unfortunately, they are not decisions for this Government or Parliament at the moment. The majority of us obviously want to see that changed.

We believe that the benefits of Scotland’s energy wealth cannot be fully achieved within the current devolution settlement. It is vital that powers over Scotland’s energy are in Scotland’s hands. We will continue to make that point to the UK Government, asking it to transfer responsibility for energy powers to Scotland, as this democratically elected Parliament has overwhelmingly voted in favour of that.

We are also clear about the energy future that we want for Scotland and about the purpose that the remaining resources of the North Sea should serve in making the transition. I welcome the opportunity that Mark Ruskell’s motion provides to debate those questions today. They are important questions.

The Scottish Government is absolutely committed to tackling climate change. Climate change exists—we know it in the science. We need to keep repeating that.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I ask the minister to reflect on how his amendment refers to legislation from this place. It relates to net zero targets, which are about domestic production and domestic emissions. However, some 90 per cent of what comes from Rosebank will be exported: it will be burned in other jurisdictions. That does not impact on the net zero targets that the minister is talking about.

Stephen Gethins SNP Dundee City East
link

I hope that Mr Ruskell will forgive me, but I cannot pre-empt the decision on Rosebank. As I set out earlier regarding Jackdaw, which was the subject of a 92-page report, any decisions that we make must be within the law, and any decisions that the UK Government makes must be within the law. I would have thought that we would have taken that for granted. Indeed, we all take that very seriously.

On energy security, Russia’s illegal invasion of Ukraine transformed European energy markets and exposed the consequences of dependence on insecure sources of energy. More recently, another conflict in the middle east has again demonstrated how directly we, in Scotland, feel the consequences of global events. The international context matters, not least to me, as the minster who has responsibility for Europe and external affairs.

Holly Bruce Green Glasgow Southside
link

Will the member take an intervention?

Stephen Gethins SNP Dundee City East
link

No. This is an important point.

The position on oil and gas that my party agreed to at our conference last month sets out clearly that, in the interests of energy security, protecting Scottish jobs and accelerating growth in renewables, domestic production is preferable to international importation, which has a bigger carbon footprint. Sourcing our oil and gas from domestic resources matters for our climate objectives as well as our energy security. Figures from the North Sea Transition Authority put the average production emissions of oil and gas extraction at 22kg of COequivalent per barrel of oil. That places the UK well below the global emissions intensity of 33kg of COequivalent per barrel of oil. That does not weaken the case for transition; it strengthens the case for getting the transition right. We cannot transfer our energy dependence, emissions and economic opportunities overseas while we continue to consume those fuels at home.

We must secure a parallel-track approach whereby we accelerate the development of our renewable energy system while responsibly managing declining North Sea resources and supporting the workers and communities—many of whom are represented by myself and Gillian Martin—who are affected by that change. The transition is already happening. In 2024, 73 per cent of the electricity that was generated in Scotland came from renewables, compared with 50 per cent across the UK. Independent analysis by the Fraser of Allander Institute estimates that Scotland’s renewable energy industry supported almost 50,000 full-time equivalent jobs in 2024. That is the future that we want to accelerate: renewable generation, Scottish supply chains, high-quality jobs and greater long-term energy security. I believe that the remaining wealth of the North Sea should help us to get there. For decades, hundreds of billions of pounds in revenue has flowed from the North Sea to the Treasury. The chancellor has suggested that, had Britain followed Norway’s approach, a sovereign wealth fund would have been worth around £1 trillion. We cannot change those decisions, but we can learn from them. That is why we want future revenues from the North Sea to support the transition. We are investing more than £107 million through our just transition training fund to offer support to more than 1,000 oil and gas workers. Just think what we could have done with a futures fund.

As I said, we believe that decisions on the North Sea should be taken on a case-by-case, evidence-led basis. We are already halfway to net zero and continue to be ahead of the UK as a whole in delivering long-term emissions reductions. We remain clear about our destination: a stronger renewable energy system, greater energy security and a just transition that protects workers across Scotland. That is a sensible approach to the transition. To be clear, especially for the Conservatives and Reform, Scotland is absolutely committed to reaching net zero by 2045. We will continue to pursue the twin-track approach of accelerating renewables while managing the transition away from fossil fuels.

I move amendment S7M-02068.4, to leave out from “and the proposed” to end and insert:

“must be compatible with climate legislation.”

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

I call Paul Sweeney to speak to and move amendment S7M-02068.2.

15:18

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

We all agree that we need to uphold and reaffirm our commitment to meeting the UK’s obligations under the Paris climate agreement and that, ultimately, we need to achieve our goal on net zero emissions.

Holly Bruce Green Glasgow Southside
link

Will the member take an intervention?

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

No. I will make some progress, thank you.

However, it feels as though we diverge sometimes in the chamber about how we will achieve that goal. We need to try to find a way forward that is socially just. The last time we debated the issue in the chamber, we had a Conservative motion that demanded that we “drill, baby, drill,” whatever the cost. This time, we have a Green Party motion that is fiercely focused on the environmental effects of hydrocarbon production. In different ways, both positions ask the Parliament to pass judgment on a quasi-judicial decision that sits outside the Parliament’s competence. That is not to say that the motion today lacks merit.

I respect the passion that Mr Ruskell and other colleagues bring to the subject, and the case for climate justice has never been clearer. This summer was the hottest on record in the United Kingdom. Who can forget the photographs of southern England, whose green and pleasant land was burnt brown, or of Europe’s mighty rivers, which ran so low that shipping on the Rhine had to be halted? We find ourselves in a world whose food supplies will feel the strain for years to come, with the shocks being felt in global prices and inflation. The reality of climate change is here. It is a crisis, and we must recognise that reality.

I believe that Labour has done more than just talk on this matter. Last week, at COP31 in Antalya, the Prime Minister said that he had come to show British leadership in a world where climate issues have taken too much of a back seat and that, as the UK takes up the presidency of the G20 next year, the UK Government will put climate resilience back on the agenda and will make debt, development and insurance key issues.

That is not mere talk. The UK Government has made an inaugural contribution of £400 million to amplify the new climate investment funds mechanism, which aims to mobilise private investment for clean energy and technology projects in developing economies. The Prime Minister said that—

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

I want to finish providing the detail of what the Prime Minister said. He said that that new mechanism will aim to secure £5 billion of new private finance for clean energy projects around the world. The money generated by that mechanism will make climate justice a reality here and around the world.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

If the UK Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero rejects Rosebank, will Scottish Labour welcome that?

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

We will await the decision. It is entirely fair of me not to want to prejudice my colleague on that. Any other approach would be unreasonable. We need to be honest about that. With the world as it is, we also need to be honest about the difficult judgment that needs to be made and the balance that needs to be struck.

Although we all want to move away from fossil fuels—of course we do—oil and gas and the durable refined hydrocarbon products that our society, our homes, our hospitals and our industries still depend on will remain an inherent part of our economy for years to come. Climate justice is not only a question for communities in the global south; it is a question for Scotland. It is a question for all the communities—including the hard-working families in the north-east of our country—across the whole of the UK who earn their daily bread from the oil and gas industry.

We have seen what happens when such transitions are left to market forces. We watched what happened when the pits, the shipyards and the steelworks were closed. The message from the Conservative Government at the time was always the same—that there was no alternative and that the market would provide, but it did not. That process left permanent scars across working-class communities in our country and across these islands. Those scars have still not healed.

We must not allow the same fate to befall the communities that depend on the North Sea. That is why Labour will introduce a carbon border adjustment mechanism to prevent carbon leakage and to protect domestic manufacturers from high-emission imports. Ultimately, it a fallacy for this country to practise a form of industrial greenwashing whereby we sacrifice our own industries, celebrate the fall in our emissions and refuse to acknowledge that we are simply exporting those emissions around the world. From next year, that will change. We have a chance to build a genuine green industrial revolution here at home.

We need only look across the North Sea to see what a different choice looks like. Norway took its petroleum wealth, stood up a state oil company and built a sovereign wealth fund.

Monica Lennon Lab Glasgow
link

Paul Sweeney and I strongly agree that we want there to be a just transition for workers and communities in Scotland. However, can he help me to understand in what way approval of the Rosebank field would help us to accelerate a just transition? I think that people need to know.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

That is certainly an issue that the UK energy secretary will have to wrestle with. I do not envy her dilemma in that regard. We must recognise that the cliff-edge approach of simply shutting down industries presents challenges.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

I am afraid that I must make progress, because I am running out of time.

We face a difficult dilemma in balancing the competing challenges.

Of course, the UK has stopped issuing new licences. For fields that were licensed under previous Governments, a legal quasi-judicial process must be followed. The decision on consent will be taken by the UK energy secretary, with final consenting decisions resting with the North Sea Transition Authority. It is not for the Scottish Parliament to interfere in that process. We must recognise that it was designed to balance our economic needs, our energy security and our international commitments to combating climate change.

That is what the amendment in my name seeks to do. It reaffirms our commitment to the Paris agreement and to net zero, which is why I am pleased to move it.

I move amendment S7M-2068.2, to leave out from “agrees” to end and insert:

“reaffirms its commitment to meeting the UK’s obligations under the Paris Climate Agreement and achieving net zero emissions; considers that oil and gas production and durable hydrocarbon products will remain part of Scotland’s economy for years to come and are vital to energy security and the economic security of working families and communities; notes that the decision on whether to grant consent for the Rosebank development will be taken at ministerial level by the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero through a quasi-judicial process, with final consenting decisions resting with the North Sea Transition Authority; recognises the need for a wider programme of reindustrialisation that supports jobs, domestic supply chains and investment in communities across Scotland, and believes that the transition to a lower-carbon economy must be a just transition that protects workers and communities while creating new industrial opportunities in the energy industries of the future.”

15:24

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

The unamended motion proceeds from a false premise, and it cannot be supported by anyone with any grasp of the facts. The Paris agreement does not require the UK to stop producing oil and gas. Article 2 commits countries to limiting global temperature increases, to pursuing efforts to limit warming to 1.5°C and to progressively reducing greenhouse gas emissions. It does not prescribe that a country must immediately cease producing fossil fuels irrespective of the circumstances, its energy requirements or the consequences for global supply.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I will, in a second.

It is obvious that the UK can pursue its Paris commitments through measures such as the decarbonisation of electricity, transport, heating and industry—

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Will the member sit down, please? Continue, Liam Kerr.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

The UK can pursue its commitments while continuing to produce its own oil and gas during the transition. The question that the motion ignores is whether developing Rosebank is incompatible with a 1.5°C pathway. Instead, it jumps to the conclusion that approving Rosebank would cause global warming to exceed 1.5°C. In fact, just last month, a Government assessment estimated that Rosebank could generate about 1 million additional tonnes of UK emissions by 2042 against an overall limit of 90 million tonnes. Therefore, the blithe assertion in the motion that Rosebank is incompatible with the UK’s commitments is an engagement in sophistry and distraction.

Holly Bruce Green Glasgow Southside
link

Rosebank is incompatible with the UK’s commitments under the Paris agreement to limit global warming to 1.5°C. Existing global oil and gas reserves already far exceed what can safely be burned, making fields such as Rosebank completely incompatible with that aim. Does Liam Kerr agree?

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

No, and I am afraid that Holly Bruce has not been listening. The study that she referenced assumes that all existing reserves will be extracted and burned. The real question is how we manage demand, maintain energy security and ensure that production comes from the most responsible sources. When it comes to production, I prefer to deal in facts, such as the fact that—as we have already heard—production emissions from Rosebank will be about 12kg of carbon dioxide per barrel. That is less than half the average of current UK oil production and about a third of the global average. Any environmentalist who is genuinely interested in reducing emissions should be demanding that we produce oil from Rosebank rather than using higher-emitting alternatives.

Demand is the part that is always missed in Mark Ruskell’s motions. If Rosebank is not consented, that will not mean that the oil will stay in the ground. The UK and the world will continue to consume oil for many years, even under the most ambitious transition to net zero. That is not just about the usual green targets in transport, aviation, manufacturing and medical equipment that save lives; it is also about the plastic in Mark Ruskell’s shoes, the polyester in his suit and the fertiliser that he uses to grow his quinoa. If that oil is not produced domestically, the demand will not disappear; the oil will still be sourced and used, and we will still import more from countries with higher production emissions, weaker environmental protections and longer supply chains.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Will I get my time back, Presiding Officer?

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Yes, the member will get his time back.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

In that case, I will take Maggie Chapman’s intervention.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

If Liam Kerr is so desperate to keep oil and gas reserves for plastics, why the hell are we burning them?

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

The whole point of taking the oil is to refine it into the products that we all wear, and that Mark Ruskell is wearing right now. Maggie Chapman will have got that question from her laptop, which was produced using oil and gas.

I mentioned importing more oil. The cabinet secretary made some important points earlier, particularly on Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and how vulnerable countries can be when they become excessively dependent on international energy markets and politically unstable suppliers. That fact is that Rosebank—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Do I have time to take the intervention?

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Yes, the member can take an intervention.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I will take Monica Lennon’s intervention.

Monica Lennon Lab Glasgow
link

Liam Kerr was excited about Mark Ruskell’s suits and other items, but I know that he wants to deal with facts in this debate. He will know that North Sea reserves are owned by private companies that sell exported oil to whichever region or global market offers the best price. Does he accept that the destination of Rosebank’s oil is determined by the international market, not our national interests?

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

International markets determine where you sell something, of course; however, I am expressly dealing with the jobs that result from that sale—I talked about security, and that point relates to those jobs. I know that the Greens will not be aware of this, but the developer on the Rosebank project already employs 210 people. The FPSO unit—Mark Ruskell can look that up later—is already in position and, incidentally, it is electrification ready.

Over its lifespan, Rosebank is expected to support nearly 600 full-time jobs, on average; it represents nearly £9 billion of planned investment, £24 billion in projected economic value and an estimated £500 million a year in tax revenues; and the developer anticipates spending approximately £700 million with UK suppliers and a similar amount on wages.

This is an internationally recognised offshore engineering industry with a highly skilled workforce, as Monica Lennon alluded to, which includes businesses with expertise in subsea technology, fabrication, maintenance and marine engineering—precisely the capabilities that we need to develop offshore wind, carbon capture and other emerging technologies.

Voting for the motion to stop Rosebank would weaken our energy security, displace production overseas, put skilled jobs at risk and undermine the very industrial capabilities that we need to develop the energy transition. That is not an environmental policy but an act of economic and environmental self-sabotage. That is why I have no hesitation in urging members to reject the motion and vote for my amendment.

I move amendment S7M-02068.1, to leave out from “are incompatible” to end and insert:

“would provide substantial economic benefits for Scotland and the North East and would significantly bolster Scotland's energy security; opposes recently announced proposals to ban any new exploration for oil and gas in the North Sea, and calls for the energy profits levy to be scrapped.”

15:31

Duncan Massey Reform North East Scotland
link

Look, I am pleased that we have another opportunity to discuss and champion our oil and gas industry, and I am very clear about what Reform wants. We acknowledge the continuing importance of oil and gas globally and in the UK—a point that the high prices resulting from current geopolitics surely emphasise—so we are clear that we need to maximise our North Sea oil and gas resources by approving projects such as Rosebank and Jackdaw, which started recently, and, of course, new drilling. We must also fix our tax system and get rid of a 78 per cent tax rate, to enable more investment.

I am also clear that, on the other side, the Greens’ policy on oil and gas is basically to end it, impoverish ourselves, destroy jobs, make ourselves more dependent on imports and probably send most of Aberdeen to some sort of re-education camp or something. However, I am not clear what the other parties stand for. I assumed that the SNP was wholly aligned with the Greens until recently, since it was shouting from the rooftops about its presumption against new oil and gas. However, despite more positive rhetoric and many questions put to it, I still do not know what its view on oil and gas is or whether it backs Rosebank and new drilling.

As for Labour—well, who knows? It seems to have somewhat moved away from Miliband’s rhetoric and it has now approved Jackdaw—a bit late, but well done. The Office for Budget Responsibility seems to think that Labour will approve Rosebank, since it is already included in the OBR’s tax receipt calculations; however, Labour continues to preside over a 78 per cent tax rate and just introduced a new Orwellian-named Energy Independence Bill, which seems to do the exact opposite of what that name suggests, by banning new licences and new drilling.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

The member often refers to a need to reduce import dependency. Does he therefore welcome the UK carbon border adjustment mechanism, which will offset the fallacy of de-industrialising our economy to simply import intensive carbon products from elsewhere?

Duncan Massey Reform North East Scotland
link

I do not welcome the CBAM, which I think will drive huge increases in the cost of living in this country and across the UK. I think that we need to get rid of carbon taxes, which are destroying all of our industries. Labour’s internal report says that the move to ban new licences, and drilling in particular, will cost at least 870 jobs. In my opinion, we will lose far more.

Quite often, we hear the rhetoric, particularly from Labour, that the North Sea is a declining basin. It seems to be Schrödinger’s North Sea to Labour—it is insignificant and in terminal decline, but, at the same time, it is so large and dangerous that we must ban any further exploration.

I reiterate that, in all possible scenarios, the UK and Scotland will need oil and gas for decades. In the UK, 75 per cent of primary energy still comes from oil and gas. Globally, the figure is nearer 85 per cent. I also point out that global oil production is around 100 million barrels per day. The UK produces about 0.7 million barrels of that per day, and Rosebank, at its peak, will produce about 0.06 million barrels per day. Therefore, there is a total lack of proportion when it comes to discussing the extent of the UK’s and Scotland’s importance in this debate.

Nevertheless, domestic production, especially at Rosebank, is extremely important for the country. We know that we are dependent on oil and gas, we know that we are facing high prices due to disrupted supply, and we know that emissions are lower for domestic production. We should all recognise that, and we should all back our North Sea oil and gas industry, which is probably still Scotland’s largest single employer, our largest taxpayer and our largest source of engineering capability.

I call again on the Scottish Government to be clear and unambiguous in its support for our North Sea oil and gas industry. The Parliament and the Scottish Government should thank the industry for, and congratulate it on, bringing Jackdaw online safely and quickly. We must back Rosebank, back new drilling and licences, back jobs, and, in particular, back Aberdeen.

15:36

Yi-pei Chou Turvey LD North East Scotland
link

As an MSP for the North East Scotland region, I know that this issue matters a great deal to my constituents and to more than 100,000 people across the core sector and the supply chains in Scotland.

The north-east is at the heart of the oil and gas sector in the UK, and I cannot deny that when I speak to my constituents about this issue, I do not hear a unified voice. I hear a range of equally valid and widely different concerns. Their livelihoods will be impacted, and we risk leaving them behind if we do not get this right.

Advocating for certainty for my constituents does not mean that I do not also acknowledge the very real risk that the climate crisis poses to our society. The two are not and never have been mutually exclusive. However, given how reliant we are, as a society, on oil and gas—us and our neighbours in the European Union—and given the need for energy security in an uncertain world, fossil fuels will still be part of the energy mix for some time to come.

To Scottish Liberal Democrats, that means that we must work harder to drive down demand and move towards new technology, to reduce emissions, lower bills and create thousands of well-paid new jobs. In my region, those jobs are vital—not just oil and gas jobs, but a myriad rural jobs that are interconnected, including in the fishing industry, forestry and agriculture. Offshore wind turbines are still installed by vessels that need fuel. The vast majority of rural jobs are still, and will be for a long while, dependent on the use of oil and gas. Our country’s resilience, like it or not, is still reliant on some element of oil and gas sovereignty to keep us warm and to keep us fed.

The recent decision by the UK Government to approve Jackdaw will come as a relief to my constituents in the north-east, who have seen opportunity vanish and promises of a just transition fall short. Achieving net zero and a greener future for our country depends on retaining their skills and our supply chains.

When it comes to the new oil fields such as Rosebank, Scottish Liberal Democrats have always been clear that any new North Sea licensing must be subject to a rigorous and strict climate test that takes account of the UK’s climate change commitments on global emissions, direct and indirect emissions and effect. It is absolutely incumbent on the UK Labour Government to be 100 per cent transparent about the result of its findings and to take action.

The situation that we find ourselves in was created by the previous Government, which made grand pledges from 2019 but did not have the backbone needed to follow through with meaningful change. Its lack of competence has undermined investment in all sectors of the energy industry. Whatever the secretary of state decides on consent, both of Scotland’s Governments need to do more to meet emission targets, improve energy efficiency in homes and get the just transition moving—a transition that retains home-grown skills and brings jobs and growth across the country.

I spoke about those who will feel left behind without a just transition. Leaving them behind is not an option. A just transition is not a buzzword but a frightening reality for those who face losing their homes, their communities, their livelihood and their future. We must work across all levels of government and of education to get us there. Let us face the reality of the situation that we are now in and plan strategically for the future that we would like to see.

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

We move to the open debate. The time limit for all speeches is five minutes.

15:40

David Barratt SNP Cowdenbeath
link

There has been an obsession with North Sea oil and gas in the chamber in recent months. I get it. It matters to our economy, to jobs and, crucially, to the very real climate emergency. However, the focus of our attention has been misplaced.

I am instinctively opposed to further drilling for oil and gas. The scientific evidence tells us that we must move away from fossil fuels if we are to limit global warming to 1.5ºC, but I am acutely aware that, if we stop drilling in the North Sea today, that will not change our consumption of oil and gas tomorrow. As long as demand exists, there will be a market for those fuels, whether they are extracted from the North Sea, the United States, Iran or Russia. That is not me arguing in favour of drilling or saying that that would not have an impact on global emissions. What I am saying is that we are only talking about half the equation. We cannot solve the climate crisis while focusing on supply only and ignoring demand. The debate that we should be having is about how we reduce our dependence on oil and gas, how we accelerate the transition to renewable energy and how we ensure that our policies tackle climate change and deliver the reduction in emissions that we need.

Right now, there are worrying contradictions in our approach. Take transport: the Scottish Government’s climate change plan depends substantially on a shift away from petrol and diesel vehicles towards electric vehicles. Meeting our climate objectives depends on us delivering that transition, yet the UK Government is considering weakening its zero emission vehicle mandate, following intense lobbying from parts of the motor industry. We cannot claim to take our climate commitments seriously while allowing policies that are designed to reduce fossil fuel consumption to be weakened.

Liam Kerr: [Made a request to intervene.]

Paul Sweeney rose—

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

I call Paul Sweeney.

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Apologies—I call Liam Kerr.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Does David Barratt regret the significant reduction in the number of EV charging points that ChargePlace Scotland has supplied over the past few years?

David Barratt SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Yes, but that is a complex debate. ChargePlace Scotland will inevitably reduce the number of EV charging points that it delivers if the business case does not stack up and if we do not keep up our transition to EVs. It is a chicken-and-egg situation. We need to keep up our ambition towards transitioning towards EVs in order to achieve the delivery of charging points.

Whether the petrol and diesel that we burn comes from the North Sea or is imported from elsewhere, that does not change the fundamental need to reduce the emissions from burning it. The same principle applies to heating, industry and the growing demand for electricity. We must ask difficult questions about how the expansion of energy-intensive industries, including data centres, could affect the electricity that is available to decarbonise transport and heating, and about the investment that we need to deliver a just transition. We should be debating how we reduce demand and not simply focusing on supply.

None of that means that we can ignore the economic consequences of moving away from oil and gas. Workers and communities in the North Sea supply chain have the skills, experience and expertise that Scotland needs. They deserve a credible future and not empty promises that the market will take care of them. That means investing in renewable energy, strengthening domestic supply chains, creating good-quality jobs and ensuring that the benefits of Scotland’s energy wealth support our transition.

Monica Lennon Lab Glasgow
link

David Barratt made a good point a moment ago when he said that we need to keep up the ambition to transition away from fossil fuels. Does he share my concern that approval for Rosebank would only slow that just transition rather than speed it up?

David Barratt SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Yes, I share that concern. However, albeit that it is rare for a politician to say this, I do not know the answer, because I equally hear what Liam Kerr said, which is that the carbon footprint of exporting from the North Sea—from Rosebank in particular—could be lower. I do not know, and I am genuinely listening to everyone’s views in the debate.

Rosebank’s lifetime emissions could amount to 254 million tonnes of carbon dioxide, and, largely, the oil that is produced will enter international markets, in which prices remain exposed to global events. Opening another field will not, by itself, insulate homes in Scotland from volatile fossil fuel prices.

If we are serious about meeting our climate obligations, we must ask not simply where the oil and gas come from but why we still need so much of them, what we are doing to reduce that need and whether every decision that we take genuinely moves us towards a cleaner, more secure and more affordable energy future. That is the challenge that we must confront, and I am not sure that the debate fully addresses it.

15:46

Colm Merrick SNP Glasgow Anniesland
link

I will begin by focusing on something that I believe we can all agree on: that we are facing a climate emergency; that we must uphold our international commitments; that we must transition away from fossil fuels and accelerate the development of a low-carbon economy; and that that transition must be a just one that protects workers, families and communities. Perhaps most important, we should agree that those shared goals can be achieved only by working together, instead of by creating division.

It is important that COP31 is due to conclude on Friday. The draft agreement that was published by its presidency contains some important proposals. It reaffirms the commitment to limiting global warming to 1.5°C, and it calls for accelerated action to phase out fossil fuels, including an immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems. Those are important ambitions, and Scotland must play its part in delivering them.

Paragraphs 111 and 112 of the COP31 draft agreement make some particularly important points. Paragraph 111 calls for transition pathways that strengthen industrial capacity, develop technology supply chains and create decent employment supported by investment finance and technological transfer. Paragraph 112 goes further in recognising that workers’ rights, decent work and quality jobs are central to effective climate action. It stresses that the transition must protect the dignity of workers and their families and address the human and social costs of economic and technological change. That is precisely the approach that we should take in Scotland.

There are legitimate concerns about energy security, employment and the economic future of communities that are dependent on oil and gas. Those concerns cannot simply be dismissed. Equally, though, we cannot use them as an excuse to delay the transition or ignore our international climate commitments. The challenge is to bring these priorities together.

Glasgow City Council recently debated a similar Green Party motion that I think shows how a similar collaborative approach could work. It called for a tax regime for oil and gas companies to fund measures to address the cost of living crisis; investment in a just transition for the energy workforce; greater investment in renewable energy; and a rapid expansion of clean, green heating. Importantly, it called for the devolution of energy policy, including oil and gas licensing.

That brings me to the fundamental problem: the most important decisions about Scotland’s energy future continue to be made at Westminster. Scotland produces more energy than it consumes, yet Scottish households are still struggling with energy costs. A surplus of low-cost energy produced here should mean affordable energy for the people who live here.

We have only to look across the sea to Norway, as has been mentioned, to see what a different approach to managing national energy resources can achieve. Norway retained significant state control over the industry and invested the returns in a sovereign wealth fund, which is now one of the largest such funds in the world. Putting it in context, I would just point out that, last year, the fund generated a profit of £183 billion, or around three times the Scottish Government’s entire budget. That is the scale of the opportunity that Scotland has missed through decades of Westminster mismanagement. The resources that could have been used to modernise our industrial base, diversify our economy and invest in our communities were never made available to Scotland, and we should never forget how that opportunity was wilfully squandered.

Under Thatcherism, oil wealth flowed to the UK Treasury while Scotland’s industrial foundations were dismantled and deliberately destroyed. Shipyards on the Clyde, coal mines and steel making at Ravenscraig were sacrificed, communities were devastated and unemployment soared. Billions of pounds were choried into UK coffers to prop up a failed ideology through tax cuts and to pay for the rising cost of unemployment from deliberate economic vandalism instead of being invested in a dedicated sovereign wealth fund or used to modernise Scottish infrastructure and transition its economy.

With independence, Scotland would have the full range of fiscal and economic powers to determine how our energy wealth was managed and invested. We could put workers, communities and consumers at the heart of our energy strategy instead of having decisions imposed by Governments whose priorities too often lie elsewhere. Ultimately, we have a responsibility to work together to tackle the climate emergency, to deliver a genuinely just transition and to ensure that the wealth generated by Scotland’s energy resources benefits the people of Scotland.

15:51

Paul McLennan SNP East Lothian Coast and Lammermuirs
link

I welcome the debate. The climate emergency is real and urgent. It is already damaging communities across Scotland and far beyond, and we have to take it with the utmost seriousness.

Campaign groups such as Uplift have been clear and consistent in arguing that new oil and gas fields, including Rosebank, are incompatible with the Paris agreement’s 1.5°C goal. They point to the full climate impact of burning the oil and gas—the scope 3 emissions that the courts have rightly said must be assessed—and they warn that approving major new developments risks locking in higher emissions, delaying the transition and leaving workers and communities more exposed in the long run. Uplift’s successful legal challenges forced proper scrutiny of those impacts, and that scrutiny has been right and necessary. The voice of that campaign, and the voices of many climate-affected communities, must be heard in the chamber.

Of course, the global energy landscape remains volatile. Russia’s war in Ukraine and instability in the middle east have shown how quickly supply and prices can be disrupted. We must manage remaining oil and gas production alongside the rapid deployment of the renewables in which Scotland is already world leading, especially offshore wind. In yesterday’s energy debate, we heard about the spatial plan that the UK Government is looking at and how important it is that the UK Government chooses the right pathway for Scotland.

Decisions on North Sea projects must be rigorously evidence led and taken case by case, with climate compatibility and energy security as central tests. I am yet to be convinced of the case for Rosebank—90 per cent of its reserves are oil, the majority of which will be exported. The field’s developer has said that Rosebank’s oil

“will be sold on the open market, and the most likely destination for that oil is the continent of Europe.”

The head of the International Energy Agency has stated that new North Sea fields such as Rosebank

“would not change much for the UK’s energy security, nor would they change the price of oil and gas … They will not lower the bills, the UK will remain a significant importer and price taker on international markets.”

Rosebank’s minimal gas reserves have the potential to reduce UK annual gas import dependency by only 1 per cent on average.

As we have heard, licensing decisions are reserved to Westminster.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

On the export point, presumably the member would concede that, while crude is exported, it is refined products that come back and thus give benefit to the UK—that is the benefit.

Paul McLennan SNP East Lothian Coast and Lammermuirs
link

I am glad that Mr Kerr has raised that point, because it allows me to say a few things. First, we have to balance what we do with our concern for the climate; the carbon emissions that are being talked about in relation to Rosebank are around 250 million tonnes, which is 75 per cent of the UK’s total emissions last year. Further, 80 per cent of the development costs of Rosebank would be funded through tax relief, which we all pay for. Therefore, the question must be considered in a much wider context.

It is absolutely crucial that any economic benefits from further North Sea production are felt in Scotland, not simply channelled to the UK Treasury. Westminster has already squandered Scotland’s oil wealth, which estimates suggest could have been used to create a sovereign wealth fund, just like Norway’s, that would have been worth at least $1 trillion. Every further penny of revenue that is taken by the Treasury from our resources should go into a future generations fund to grow Scotland’s renewables industry, support the communities that have generated hundreds of billions in tax, strengthen the supply chain and create the skilled jobs of the future.

Reckless decisions such as the energy profits levy in its current form have already cost thousands of Scottish energy jobs. Again, that has not been discussed much in this afternoon’s debate. We cannot stand by while the Scottish industry is hollowed out. Protecting workers and communities through a just transition is non-negotiable.

Scotland has shown climate leadership, and it needs to continue to do so. Our greenhouse gas emissions have more than halved since 1990. Strong leadership on climate has never been more important, but the fundamental problem is that the most important levers of energy policy are still controlled by Westminster.

Scotland produces energy in surplus. A surplus of low-cost energy in Scotland should mean low-cost energy for the people of Scotland. Across the sea, Norway’s wealth fund is now worth $2 trillion, and we have missed the opportunity to have something similar due to Westminster mismanagement by Labour and Conservative Governments. Scotland’s energy must be in Scotland’s hands; only then can we deliver a system that truly delivers for the people who live here, accelerating renewables, protecting jobs, funding a fair transition and ensuring that the benefits stay in our communities. Independence is not a distraction from climate change—it is the means to meet the challenge with the full powers and fiscal choices that we need.

The SNP will always use every power at our disposal, but, without the full powers of an independent country, we are fighting with one hand tied behind our back. Scotland’s future as a modern, dynamic nation that leads on climate while delivering for its people lies in independence.

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

We now come to closing speeches. As we are behind time, I must ask speakers to stay within the time limits that have been agreed with their business managers, although extra time will be given for interventions.

15:57

Jamie Langan Reform South Scotland
link

The motion before us today is a perfect example of what I would call a luxury belief. For years, many politicians across this Parliament and beyond felt that they could afford to talk as though energy security did not really matter, to pretend that oil and gas were yesterday’s industries and to assume that somebody somewhere else would always provide the energy we needed. Then, as other speakers have said, geopolitical events exposed just how complacent and naive that way of thinking was. The invasion of Ukraine reminded us just how important energy security is; conflicts in the middle east reminded us that global energy markets remain vulnerable; and, suddenly, energy security was no longer an academic discussion.

That is why I find today’s motion frustrating. Even after everything that has happened in recent years, the Greens remain fully committed to the same world view that left Britain and Europe exposed in the first place. Their answer is still the same: stop Rosebank, oppose new production and further restrict a domestic industry that we know Scotland and the wider United Kingdom will continue to rely upon for decades to come.

The truth is that oil and gas are not going away. Even the most ambitious transition scenarios show continued demand for oil and gas for many years ahead. The real question is not whether we use those resources but where they come from. Do they come from Scotland and the North Sea—supporting Scottish jobs, Scottish supply chains and Scottish tax revenues—or do they come from imports shipped thousands of miles from across the world from countries with zero regard for environmental standards and, often, volatile political systems? That is the choice that is before us today.

It is telling that other parties have started to realise that. The Conservatives now talk much more positively about North Sea production than they did when they were in government and had the agency to support and nurture it.

Labour appears to have an internal argument between those who recognise the economic and security benefits of projects such as Rosebank and those who are still committed to the ideology of shutting the industry down. However, the Labour Government’s so-called Energy Independence Bill shows that, at its heart, Labour is still not facing reality. Banning new exploration in the same North Sea basin that the Norwegians are still exploring shows how in hock the party remains to Ed Miliband’s extremist ideology.

At least we know where the Greens stand. They are at least consistent on the issue—consistently opposed to new production, new investment and new jobs; consistently opposed to wealth creation; and consistently wrong. They are unwilling to acknowledge the consequences that their policies would have for workers, families and communities, particularly in the north-east of Scotland.

Rosebank represents billions of pounds of investment, substantial economic value and hundreds of skilled jobs. It would also provide significant domestic energy production and tax revenues at a time when both are desperately needed. Members can disagree on the pace of the transition, on taxation and on regulation, but surely we should be able to agree on one thing: it makes far more sense to produce energy that we still need at home than it does to offshore both production and jobs to other countries.

The Greens ask us to oppose Rosebank because they believe that doing so will somehow make the demand for oil and gas disappear. Unfortunately for them, energy policy is not a Greenpeace leaflet and has to operate and work in the real world. The Greens are not proposing a transition to an environmental utopia; they are proposing an abdication of our energy security; an abdication of our national security; and an abdication of our sovereignty, industrial capacity and ability to provide well-paid, meaningful and skilled jobs. The simple fact is that the Greens’ position would mean importing oil and gas while losing good Scottish jobs.

Jamie Langan Reform South Scotland
link

I am wrapping up, but I would be happy to take an intervention.

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

The member cannot take an intervention, because he should be concluding his speech.

Jamie Langan Reform South Scotland
link

I apologise.

The Greens’ position would not be an example of environmental stewardship; it would result in economic self-harm. Once again, Scottish workers would be sacrificed on the altar of the Green Party’s luxury beliefs.

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Although we have had an indication of the members who will be making closing speeches, they have not all pressed their request-to-speak button, so they should do so now.

16:01

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Most of us agree that Scotland should become a net zero nation, but we must recognise the reality of where Scotland is today and accept that getting to net zero requires a credible strategy. Without one, jobs, communities, our economy and our energy security will be at risk.

In uncertain and volatile times, we need to transition from oil and gas in a way that protects workers and supply chains, rather than leaving them behind. We must recognise that oil and gas production remains part of Scotland’s energy mix. The sector’s highly skilled workforce makes a huge contribution to our economy, our energy security, and the economic security of working families and communities across Scotland.

David Barratt rightly pointed to the fact that we must consider existing demand. It makes no sense to import hydrocarbons from around the world—potentially, fracked gas from the US and elsewhere—to make us feel better about not approving fuel developments at home.

The communities that I represent know what happens when industrial and energy transitions are not properly managed. Across Lanarkshire, including in Ravenscraig and Gartcosh, there are coal-mining communities that know the effects of deindustrialisation, which can still be seen decades and generations later.

Pauline Stafford SNP Bathgate
link

Workers in my constituency also know that reality. What is Mark Griffin’s position on the fact that, although the Labour Government promised £400 million for Grangemouth and the Acorn project, only 3 per cent of what was promised to Scotland has been delivered?

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scot and Lothians West
link

That commitment still stands. We are waiting for projects to come forward so that the funding can be invested.

A couple of points on the process relating to Rosebank need to be clarified. As the minister said, the decision on whether to grant consent does not rest with this Parliament or with another Parliament. The matter is being considered through a formal quasi-judicial process, with environmental assessments and other evidence being weighted before a final decision is taken by the appropriate authorities. Our role is not to prejudge the outcome but to consider the principles that should guide Scotland’s energy future.

That is the legal position. I understand that there are those who might want to change the law and want the legal position to be different, but I heard no arguments for that today. I saw no lobbying for a change in the law that would change the consenting position. We need to recognise that what I have set out is the factual position today.

Although we will not vote for the Government’s amendment, purely because of pre-emptions, we will vote for the motion if the Government amendment passes. We will do so in recognition of the factual reality surrounding the process.

We also need to be clear that, although demand matters, the transition has not happened fast enough, and nowhere is that failure more obvious than in our homes and buildings. We have been promised transformation in the ways that we heat and retrofit Scotland’s building stock, but progress has consistently fallen short in that department. Too many homes remain cold and poorly insulated, which means that those who live there pay higher energy bills while emissions remain stubbornly high.

If we want to manage the transition from oil and gas, we need to look at the issues with demand that are driving the reliance that still remains. That is why the Scottish Labour amendment speaks about a just transition. We recognise the need to move to meet demand, and we recognise that we cannot leave communities such as those in Lanarkshire and across other parts of the central belt behind.

I hope that members will support our amendment.

16:06

Stephen Gethins SNP Dundee City East
link

I thank colleagues for their contributions. Fundamentally, as a number of members have said, this debate is about how Scotland makes the transition to net zero. The Government is committed to Scotland’s climate legislation and to tackling the climate emergency. Paul McLennan and others were right to highlight that.

We are determined to seize opportunities for Scotland in renewables and the wider low-carbon economy. There are opportunities as we meet our climate responsibilities. However, a credible transition must start from the energy system, economy and workforce. Oil and gas will continue to form a part of our energy mix during the transition, and calling for domestic production to be reduced does not make the demand disappear.

Part of that is what gives us a competitive advantage to move on. Bluntly, what gives us a competitive advantage—so many members have referenced this, including Yi-pei Chou Turvey, Mr Griffin and some of my SNP colleagues—is the skill set that already exists in the north-east and, in fairness, elsewhere across Scotland. It was developed in the oil and gas sector and continues now. We must have a just transition. The North Sea supports skilled jobs, supply chains and communities, and the expertise that was developed in that industry will be essential for the future.

Let me reflect on the decisions. As Mr Griffin said, the decision on Rosebank is for the UK Government and the consenting process is quasi-judicial. On that, I want to correct the record. I have said a number of times that we have now seen the reasoning for Jackdaw. However, in response to Duncan Massey, I mixed up Jackdaw and Rosebank. I said that I have seen the reasoning for the decisions on Rosebank, but I have not seen that yet. I referenced Jackdaw on a number of occasions, but I will make that correction while I am on my feet.

An important aspect is that there is a legal process that follows legal rulings and the subsequent challenge to the original Rosebank consent, including the requirement to assess the environmental impact of downstream emissions. We saw what happened when that process was not respected and, therefore, it must be respected.

However, this is not about one field or one energy sector. One thing that has come across is the huge opportunity that our sector has. I will deal with some of the issues that were raised by colleagues on that.

We can see the skills, expertise and infrastructure that we have in the offshore renewables sector. I am the minister for Europe, and when I speak to colleagues elsewhere in Europe as part of that job, and when I have been in other jobs, one of the key issues that I have heard about in other European capitals is the geopolitical situation, to which a number of colleagues referred. Almost every colleague in every party referred to the geopolitical situation. Therefore, when we talk about energy security, my message to the rest of Europe is that because of the skills, resource and infrastructure that we have, Scotland is part of the solution to the energy security challenge elsewhere in Europe.

We must maintain energy security, skills, investment and industrial capacity. I noted what Pauline Stafford said about getting that right in Grangemouth and elsewhere.

Colm Merrick was right about the investment in renewables. Just last week, I was in Glasgow looking at the jobs and, crucially, the apprenticeships that have been created. However, a number of my colleagues, including Mr Merrick and Mr McLennan, referenced a sovereign wealth fund, which is not something that we have set up. We need to learn from our failures in the past in order to build success for the future.

The choice is not between climate action and economic prosperity. The challenge is to deliver both, and that is why I have been reasonably heartened by the debate that we have had. The Government is ambitious about net zero. We recognise the climate emergency and the science behind it, but we are also realistic about our present energy needs. I am undertaking a lot of work on, for example, the heat in buildings strategy and the expansion of our offshore renewables. Yes, that is hard, but there is also a massive opportunity, which is why we are committed to a just transition.

16:10

Holly Bruce Green Glasgow Southside
link

This will be to Liam Kerr’s dismay, but the scientific consensus is unequivocal that we cannot drill for new oil and gas if we are to have any chance of staying within safe climate limits. I am not sure that all members across the chamber today really understand what that means. Many of us do not really want to think about climate change or about putting our children’s lives in danger, but I do not believe that elected members should have the privilege of turning away from the untold suffering that lies ahead.

The UN secretary general has described continued investment in new fossil fuels as “moral and economic madness”. He also said:

“the truly dangerous radicals are the countries that are increasing the production of fossil fuels.”

That is how serious this is. If we, as the Scottish Parliament, fail to take a stand against new fossil fuel production, we will be complicit in causing immense suffering across the globe.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Surely the member must concede that what has come through from this debate is that the demand is there. Therefore, we either drill for oil here where production emissions are low or we import it from those countries, and from those wells, that have much higher levels of production emissions, much lower standards of regulation and much poorer records on the environment.

Holly Bruce Green Glasgow Southside
link

I am sure that Liam Kerr realises that the basin in the north-east is already depleted. In addition, reserves are being exported, and cutting demand will not boost supply. I refute the point that was made.

We have already glimpsed the use of red alerts in the UK this summer, which were issued when young children were at risk of heat-related deaths. We have had extreme storm after extreme storm, putting emergency workers in danger, destroying homes and taking lives, and we had wildfires that wiped out years of conservation work and led to people being evacuated from their homes.

That is only the tip of the iceberg, and far worse is to come. Extreme weather events are made more frequent, severe and deadly due to climate change. That is a fact.

Many MSPs from all parties have talked about extreme weather affecting their communities and how we need more support, more funding and better-equipped emergency services. I must ask those colleagues today: why are we acting as though climate change has nothing to do with that?

How on earth did we get here? Five years ago, the SNP was the party of COP26, in Glasgow, as my colleague Mark Ruskell pointed out. Scotland was one of the first nations in the world to declare a climate emergency. I remember the sense of ambition and the feeling that Scotland could lead the way in tackling the climate crisis. That legacy has now been unceremoniously shredded and chucked on the scrapheap.

Regrettably, most SNP members now stand alongside Reform and the Conservatives in supporting new oil and gas, and Labour’s position changes as often as the wind. I hope that many members, including in the SNP, can find the courage to agree that the Scottish Government’s position is completely unjustifiable. The climate pollution from Rosebank would be greater than the combined annual COemissions of the 73 lowest-emitting countries. There is no way that such enormous damage could ever be climate compatible.

Beyond the clear climate arguments, I will also highlight that, as Monica Lennon outlined, Rosebank’s co-owner, Ithaca Energy, is majority owned by Delek Group, an Israeli fuel conglomerate that has provided fuel to the Israel Defense Forces during a genocide and which operates in the occupied Palestinian territories.

Rosebank will do nothing to strengthen energy security or lower household energy bills. Ninety per cent of Rosebank’s reserves are oil, which will be loaded on to tankers and sold in the international market to the highest bidder. It will not heat our homes or lower our bills. To argue otherwise is disingenuous. It is not Scotland’s oil.

Rosebank will not stop the decline in North Sea jobs. After decades of extraction, the North Sea is a hypermature basin that is approaching the end of its productive life. That is the geological reality. I say to Stephen Gethins, the minister, that that is the science. Jobs that are supported by the North Sea oil and gas industry have more than halved in number over the past decade, despite new fields being approved in that period. To argue otherwise is disingenuous. The only way to protect workers and communities who currently depend on the oil and gas industry is to invest in the renewable energy system, as David Barratt said.

Holly Bruce Green Glasgow Southside
link

I will not take an intervention.

As many in the chamber know, I am from the north-east of Scotland. When I was growing up, the food on my table was paid for by the oil and gas industry. Recently, I have been accused of betraying my home town and forgetting my roots. Today, I speak directly to you all and to the people who I grew up with. I know that you are scared. I know what is at stake when all that you want is a decent, well-paid, reliable job to provide for your family, and I stand with you on that every day.

However, my position on new oil and gas drilling is not about turning my back on where I came from. It is rooted in science, in the hard facts and in fighting for the region’s survival, because burying our heads in the sand would be a profound betrayal of those oil and gas workers and of the north-east. True loyalty to my home town is not selling false hope; it is being strategic and not short-sighted, by ensuring that families are not left behind when the wells run dry.

This is likely the last opportunity to debate the Rosebank oil field, the decision on which is set to define this parliamentary session, and to debate whether we hold true to the evidence that more drilling in the North Sea, such as through Rosebank, will push us beyond safe planetary boundaries. For some reason, some in this chamber are comfortable with that. It is now time for members to show that they are not. This could be our last opportunity to send the message that our Parliament opposes Rosebank. I hope that, for future generations’ sake, members will join me.

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

That concludes the debate on Rosebank and upholding the Paris climate agreement.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

Votes on these motions that day

  1. 14:00 Deputy First Minister Responsibilities, Finance and Local Government, Parliamentary Business and Veterans Questions · 1
  2. 14:00 “Veterans’ Homelessness Prevention Pathway” Questions · 4
  3. 14:00 Veterans Strategy (Healthcare) Questions · 4
  4. 14:00 Public Services (Funding) Questions · 4
  5. 14:00 Scottish Block Grant 2027-28 Questions · 6
  6. 14:00 Council Tax Reform Questions · 4
  7. 14:00 Marmot Places Questions · 4
  8. 14:00 Homelessness Prevention Funding (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  9. 14:00 Scottish Veterans Commissioner (Progress Report 2026) Questions · 6
  10. 14:00 Local Government Reform (Island Councils) Questions · 11
  11. 14:00 Public Service Reform (Budgetary Provision) Questions · 11
  12. 14:00 Public Service Reform (Use of Artificial Intelligence) Questions · 7
  13. 14:00 European Union Re-entry (Benefits for Scotland) Questions · 13
  14. 14:00 External Affairs and Overseas Aid (Expenditure) Questions · 10
  15. 14:00 Oil and Gas (Exploration) Questions · 8
  16. 14:00 Public Service Reform (Vacancies on Public Bodies) Questions · 10
  17. 14:00 Public Service Reform (Third Sector Organisations) Questions · 4
  18. 14:00 Public Service Reform (Redundancies Policy) Questions · 4
  19. 14:00 Public Service Reform (Multiyear Funding for Third Sector Organisations) Questions · 4
  20. 14:00 Renewable Energy (Workforce Skills) Questions · 9
  21. 15:03 Rosebank Oil and Gas Field Debate · 79
  22. 16:18 Local Government Reform Debate · 87
  23. 17:38 Business Motion Business motions · 2
  24. 17:38 Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 3
  25. 17:39 Decision Time Decision time · 32

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.