This has been a full debate, but, to extend the energy metaphor, it has generated more heat than light.
Before I turn to the cost of energy, let us take a step back. Alex Cole-Hamilton was absolutely correct to mention that economic growth is one of the engines through which we can attack the growing cost of living; however, as I said to the minister earlier, there is one lever at the Government’s disposal that it has not pulled. The Government states in its motion that there are
“severe cost of living pressures”,
but the largest pressure that many households face is their tax bill, and this Government singularly fails to address that.
I suspect that, in its budget, the Scottish Government will yet again freeze thresholds on income tax, falling into a trap that has now been repeated by the Labour Government, which means that many more Scots who are struggling to pay their bills this winter will be writing ever bigger cheques to the Scottish exchequer. As I said to the minister, a young Scot working full time in a pub, after taking into account their tips, will now be paying a higher rate of tax. I do not think that those are the people with the broadest shoulders. They are the people who are struggling to pay their energy bills, and it is frankly ridiculous that the cabinet secretary is taxing them more than they would be taxed in the rest of the UK.
Let us look at the other issues raised in the debate. The cabinet secretary again obsessed about clean heat and net zero, but I would like to remind her of what Tony Cain of the Association of Local Authority Chief Housing Officers said before the Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee recently:
“The problem is that our challenge comes from fuel poverty, not carbon. Carbon emissions from social housing are in the roundings of Scotland’s annual emissions calculations”.
He went on:
“One of the issues with switching to zero-emissions heating systems such as heat pumps is that, given the current structure of energy pricing, that can actually drive fuel poverty.”—[Official Report, Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee, 11 November 2026; c 17.]
That means that the Scottish Government’s own heat and energy in buildings policy is further adding to the problem of fuel poverty.
I agree with Mark Griffin’s contribution where he said that the Scottish Government is blaming someone else. It is very good at doing that, but so, too, is the Labour Government, which brought on board Great British Energy to drive down bills, which is proving toothless in its ability to do that.
Duncan Massey seemed to be obsessed with the old lady who swallowed a fly. Yet again, he came to the chamber and appeared to only swallow his foot, because the binary, simplistic solutions that Reform keeps bringing to the Parliament are undoubtedly its weakness. I do not think that its amendment or its policy has credibility, because there is more nuance to the subject than Reform gives the Parliament credit for.
Holly Bruce was hopelessly simplistic in yet another attack on the profits of large energy firms. It is those profits that, in many cases, drive people’s pensions, and those pensions are helping them to pay their bills this winter.
I agree very much with Morven-May MacCallum about what more the Scottish Government could do to help those who are off grid. It could look at that pot of money that has not yet being allocated, either to ensure that money from it is going out the door to those who qualify already, or to extend the eligibility criteria for it in order to use it for many more people who will face fuel poverty this winter.
Jackie Dunbar saying that another party has turned its back on Scotland’s oil and gas workers is laughable coming from a member of the SNP, which did exactly that throughout the previous parliamentary session.
I close by reflecting on Alex Kerr’s contribution. It was quite clear when I read the SNP motion, as it is in every point that the SNP has made in the debate, that this debate not about driving down bills for ordinary, hard-working Scots, or about energy policy, or about the cost of living. It was about more and more grievance in relation to independence.