link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the first phase of the independent inquiry into white working class educational outcomes, including whether there are any comparable themes in Scotland. (S7O-00508)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the first phase of the independent inquiry into white working class educational outcomes, including whether there are any comparable themes in Scotland. (S7O-00508)
link
As I wrote on 24 July in response to Mr Kerr’s very similar written question, we do not measure attainment or educational outcomes by class in Scotland. However, we measure them by deprivation using the Scottish index of multiple deprivation, and we use several key policies, not least the Scottish attainment challenge, to mitigate the impact of poverty on educational outcomes. Those policies have collectively resulted in important progress being made in closing the poverty-related attainment gap. Notably, that includes reducing the gap for young people who leave school and go on to a positive initial destination by almost two thirds since 2009-10.
link
Today’s long-awaited Milburn report, which shows that almost 1 million 16 to 24-year-olds across Britain are being left behind, will make for a sobering read for countless Labour, Tory and Scottish National Party politicians. We already know that Scotland’s attainment gap is wider than it was before the pandemic, and the cabinet secretary must surely recognise that there is a systemic problem with educational outcomes for white children from working-class backgrounds. Will the Scottish Government therefore commit to a dedicated inquiry to specifically examine the educational attainment of white working-class pupils in order to understand why they continue to be left behind, or will the cabinet secretary continue to leave a generation of young Scots on the dole with no hope, aspiration or opportunity?
link
I care about white children as much as I care about working-class children and every young person and child in this country regardless of their social or demographic background and regardless of their race or ethnicity. Alan Milburn’s report is extensive, and the Government will take our time to consider its recommendations as they pertain to education and skills and social security.
For my part, which is in the education portfolio, I can see that a great deal of what Mr Milburn is recommending for England is aligned with what the SNP has been pursuing in Scotland for many years. We have pursued a strong mix of vocational and academic qualifications and pathways from school, a broad general education in the early years and close alignment between schools and colleges, and it now looks as though recommendations are being made for England to follow suit. Young people have been waiting an awful long time for a UK Government to realise that such action is required.
link
The independent inquiry highlighted the importance of early identification of literacy difficulties. In light of those findings, will the Scottish Government consider introducing a statutory national phonics screening check for all primary school children in Scotland, similar to the phonics screening check that is used in England, to identify children who might be falling behind at an early stage and ensure that they receive the right support at the right time, in keeping with the principles of getting it right for every child?
link
I welcome Amanda Bland’s reference to and endorsement of getting it right for every child. It goes to the heart of what I said to Mr Kerr, because it is about every child and not only those that he would pick and choose to care about from one moment to the next.
Amanda Bland knows, because we have had exchanges on this before, that our curriculum is undergoing the biggest update since the inception of curriculum for excellence, and that includes literacy, including in the earliest years, and consideration of phonics. That work is under way. Education Scotland has just published the first extensive draft of the new framework, and I encourage Amanda Bland to engage with that process.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.