link
I appreciate that. You are trying to strike a balance between flexibility and the need for sustainable public service broadcasters in future. Where is the line between citizen and consumer in that?
Official Report · Committee
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
I appreciate that. You are trying to strike a balance between flexibility and the need for sustainable public service broadcasters in future. Where is the line between citizen and consumer in that?
Yes, especially when the competition, as someone on the previous panel was saying, is now big global platforms rather than television companies.
link
Mr McGowan-Lowe, from the previous panel, said that this is a funding crisis. At what point could the decisions lead to it becoming an audience crisis and become self-perpetuating? Is there a worry that, if we do not get that balance right, it will be a funding crisis?
I will go back to the paper that we published 18 months ago, in which we talked about this being a critical time. We said in the paper that we all need to work together—whether that is the Government, platforms, television companies or civil society—because, as I said earlier, the public service broadcasting industry in Scotland and across the United Kingdom underpins a healthy creative economy and all the great programmes that get made here. If it were not for the likes of BBC Scotland or STV, Netflix would not have come here and made programmes such as “Dept Q”. Governments, platforms, companies and the regulator need to play their parts to try to keep the industry going.
link
I have a final question, which will give you a chance to respond to the statement that was made in the first panel that Ofcom is not fit to defend our public service broadcasting industry in Scotland at a time when it needs to be defended. I do not know whether you want to make any comments about the powers that you have at the moment within the regulatory framework and what your limitations are.
Well, we have a very strong team here—there are now about 100 people based in our Edinburgh office. We engage with stakeholders right across Scotland and in all parts of it. We are a converged regulator, which means that other parts of the Ofcom forest regulate online and telecoms, which really helps us.We have made some difficult and unpopular decisions. You do not work at a regulator to be popular among people; you do it to ensure that audiences are served now and in the future. The STV decision was a difficult one. I strongly want STV to thrive, not just survive—I said that earlier—and I thought that the decision that we made was a good compromise in order for it to be able to exist in the future. I cannot comment on this, but you will have noticed that, in her referral of the ITV-Sky takeover, the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport said that she had concerns about STV’s sustainability and that she wanted us to have regard to that.I hope that, by making some difficult decisions, being accountable to you and having close engagement with stakeholders, we have proved that we are here to protect consumers and citizens in Scotland as well as everywhere else.
link
Thank you very much. The committee will continue with this piece of work in the weeks ahead, and we will also return to the issues that you have raised, including Screen Scotland and the charter renewal process. I have no doubt that we will hear from you again.
I will quickly plug a publication, as one does at these things. I have already mentioned our upcoming report on the BBC. Alongside that, we have done some interesting work—I would say that—on the levers that affect trust in the BBC. Trust is an important commodity for the BBC, and it is important for it to continue to have the trust of audiences as well as politicians. In that report, we will look at the importance not just of talking about impartiality but of showing it. Please look out for it, because there might be some interesting points in there that you will want to pick up with the BBC when you meet it in a couple of weeks.
link
I am sure that we will. Thank you for spending time with the committee today.Before we move into private session, I note that I should have said at the start of the meeting that I am an associate member of the National Union of Journalists. That is recorded in the voluntary section of my entry in the register of members’ interests, so there is not a mandatory requirement to declare it, but it would have been good practice to put that on the record at the start of the meeting—I apologise to the committee for not doing so.12:08Meeting continued in private until 12:19.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.