Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

NHS Grampian (Healthcare Improvement Scotland Report)

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 12 November 2026 Meeting of the Parliament About 14:00 First Minister’s Questions 7 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Michael Marra Lab North East Scotland
link

Parents of sick children will be horrified by the inspection report on NHS Grampian that was published today. All parents will be shocked. At Dr Gray’s hospital, operations for sick children continued despite the fact that they were known to be unsafe. How many of those operations on children were carried out?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

The contents of the report from Healthcare Improvement Scotland that was commissioned by NHS Grampian are appalling reading, and I echo the concerns that Mr Marra has expressed about how the report will leave parents feeling.

It is crystal clear that the requirement to end the surgery in question for children at Dr Gray’s was not followed by NHS Grampian, which is reprehensible. I understand from my reading, assessment and interrogation of the report that there have been no negative consequences of that process, but, regardless of that, it is unacceptable that arrangements that should have been stopped for proper patient safety reasons were not stopped—hence the findings of Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s report and the dramatic changes that the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care and I expect to take place at NHS Grampian to address the legitimate concerns that Mr Marra puts to me about patient safety, which will be of acute concern to parents in the Grampian area today.

Michael Marra Lab North East Scotland
link

The First Minister is right to condemn what has happened in the strongest possible terms. Children were put at risk. The board also failed to investigate properly why a patient died on the operating table. I see absolutely no reason why the board of NHS Grampian should remain in place. The First Minister should call for it to go now.

The Government might be taking limited action today, but, crucially, issues at NHS Grampian have been known about for years. Repeated reports in 2014, 2016 and 2023 all raised the alarm, and the health board has lurched from crisis to crisis. None of it should be news to the Government. When John Swinney was Deputy First Minister in 2014, the Scottish National Party said that it was

“confident that NHS Grampian can turn the situation round”.—[Official Report, 3 December 2014; c 22.]

Well, that did not happen.

I will say this again. The First Minister has acknowledged that operations were carried out on children in unsafe conditions, despite the fact that the Government has known about issues at NHS Grampian for well over a decade. How on earth has the Government let things get to this point?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

There have been various stages at which the Government has intervened to require improvements to be made at NHS Grampian. There has been a long history, and improvements have been made over time at different stages.

The most recent issues are of a much greater and escalated level of severity. The Government started its most recent engagement of concern about NHS Grampian in May 2025, when we escalated the board to level 4 for finance, leadership and governance concerns. An external assurance board was put in to support the NHS Grampian board. It was clear that some of the requirements that the assurance board asked to be taken forward were not being implemented, which is why Healthcare Improvement Scotland—the independent inspectorate—has undertaken the work that it has carried out.

The health secretary will set out to the Parliament, in a statement that the Government will make on Tuesday, the full range of actions that require to be taken in this case. However, I note that there have already been changes to the leadership of NHS Grampian. There is a new chair of the board, John Connaghan, who is an experienced healthcare professional who held a very senior role in the Scottish Government on healthcare issues. There is a new chief executive in place, who initiated the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report. A large proportion of the board has been replaced and, today, changes have been made to the senior leadership of NHS Grampian that, in my view, are necessary as a consequence of the report.

I hope that that assures Mr Marra that the Government is taking incredibly seriously the contents of the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report. Changes have been made immediately in relation to the leadership of the board, and we will leave no stone unturned to ensure that services and the safety of patients in NHS Grampian are at the centre of the steps that the Government takes to strengthen the position in the Grampian area.

Michael Marra Lab North East Scotland
link

The First Minister recognises that there have been problems in recent years, but he does not recognise the fact that the reports go back as far as 2014 and 2016. There has been a long-term challenge over the governance and operation of NHS Grampian that the Government has failed to get on top of, despite repeated challenges from outside bodies and from parliamentarians in that period of time.

There is a broader culture problem at the top of our health service that is not confined to one region of Scotland. It should not take an independent, judge-led inquiry to get justice for the families of those who were made sick and who died because of failings at the Queen Elizabeth university hospital in Glasgow. It should not take an independent, judge-led inquiry to get justice for the hundreds of victims of Eljamel in Tayside. Labour members have been saying for years that those cultural issues have been widespread.

At the top of too many of our health boards are managers who are not accountable to citizens, who act with impunity and who are too often concerned about headlines rather than delivering care. Does the First Minister agree?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

I begin by reiterating a point that I made in my earlier answer. Mr Marra is correct to say that there have been a number of examples of issues in NHS Grampian, but the Government has intervened at different stages and the position has improved. However, we now have a report that raises the most serious issues, which I am certain will have a detrimental effect on staff and patient morale and on confidence in NHS Grampian.

As First Minister, I must be careful to ensure that there continues to be public confidence in the services provided by NHS Grampian. I believe that there is that confidence, and I want the public to hear loud and clear from their First Minister that dramatic action has been taken to provide an assurance on that.

Mr Marra raises a wider point about culture in our public services. He and I are in agreement on that, because I believe in what he has put to me—the importance of members of the public having confidence in our public services, those leading our public services being accountable for them, and our being transparent about the weaknesses that are there.

Today, I am being absolutely transparent about the weaknesses in NHS Grampian. I am not trying to defend a thing. A lot must change at NHS Grampian in order to address the legitimate issues that have been raised. Public attitudes and public confidence are at the heart of all of this. I assure Mr Marra of the Government’s determination to lead a culture whereby that is the case.

Kenneth Gibson The Presiding Officer · Cunninghame North
link

Malcolm Offord has seven minutes for questions and answers.

  1. 13:30 General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. 13:30 Education (Use of Artificial Intelligence) Questions · 4
  3. 13:30 Scottish Emergency Heating Oil Scheme Questions · 16
  4. 13:30 Victoria Quay Questions · 8
  5. 13:30 Tick-borne Illnesses Questions · 4
  6. 13:30 Public Finances (United Kingdom Budget) Questions · 11
  7. 13:30 Public Service Reform (Trade Union Meetings) Questions · 10
  8. 13:30 General Practice (Edinburgh and Lothians East) Questions · 6
  9. 13:30 Strategic Spatial Energy Plan Questions · 9
  10. 14:00 Party Leaders First Minister’s Questions · 2
  11. 14:00 NHS Grampian (Healthcare Improvement Scotland Report) First Minister’s Questions · 7
  12. 14:00 United Kingdom-India Trade Deal First Minister’s Questions · 9
  13. 14:00 Oil and Gas First Minister’s Questions · 7
  14. 14:00 Members of the Scottish Parliament (Eligibility) First Minister’s Questions · 13
  15. 14:00 Accident and Emergency Waiting Times First Minister’s Questions · 9
  16. 14:37 Point of Order Procedure · 3
  17. 14:37 Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Commonwealth Citizens) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 127
  18. 16:03 Armed Forces Community (Remembrance) Debate · 33
  19. 17:25 Motion without Notice Business motions · 2
  20. 17:26 Decision Time Decision time · 8
  21. 17:32 Marine Energy (Economic Potential) Members’ business · 26

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.