link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the impact of the recently announced UK Government Budget on public finances in Scotland. (S7O-00500)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the impact of the recently announced UK Government Budget on public finances in Scotland. (S7O-00500)
The Scottish Government’s budget next year will be cut in real terms by around £650 million. That means that our funding for public services and infrastructure will not keep pace with inflation, at a time when costs are increasing. That fact should concern every member of the Parliament, and it means that we face a very challenging Scottish budget for next year.
The UK budget did not go far enough in helping people with the cost of living. At a time when revenues from Scotland’s energy are going to be billions of pounds higher, we have a UK budget that cuts our funding and leaves the people we all represent paying energy bills that are hundreds of pounds higher than the Labour party promised they would be when it came to office. That is the consequence of decisions taken in Westminster. It shows us exactly why we need to take decisions here in Scotland and make our energy wealth work for us.
link
I share the Deputy First Minister’s concern that, at a time when construction inflation has risen faster here than in the UK economy as a whole, the UK’s capital allocation to Scotland will be lower in 2029-30 in real terms than it was under the Tories in 2022-23. Can the Deputy First Minister say a little more about what she thinks that will mean for construction employment and for investment in roads, schools, hospitals, housing and harbours in Scotland?
link
I very much share the concerns that Patricia Gibson has raised. It is absolutely right to point out that the cut to Scotland’s capital budget for 2027-28, for example, is now £100 million lower than we expected at the time of the Scottish spending review; the capital block grant from the UK Government is not sufficient to build and maintain the infrastructure that Scotland needs; and our capital block grant funding is projected to fall by 6.1 per cent in real terms between 2026-27 and 2029-30.
That is going to impact on infrastructure investment with regard to securing economic growth, tackling the climate crisis and—as Patricia Gibson rightly pointed out—investing in our schools and hospitals. The real-terms reduction in funding from the UK Government means that really difficult choices will need to be made as part of the 2027-28 budget to ensure that limited funding is targeted towards our highest priorities.
link
Is it not the case that the UK Labour Government is now making precisely the same mistakes as the Scottish National Party Government? By freezing tax thresholds over the longer term, it is pushing more and more working households into paying ever-higher rates of tax in order to pay a ballooning benefits bill. Does the Scottish Government intend to follow suit, or will it finally see sense, cut tax and cut the benefits bill in Scotland?
link
I have already enjoyed some engagement with Mr Hoy ahead of the budget, and I look forward to more meetings with him to talk about some of those issues.
On taxation, however, I am afraid that we shall have to agree to disagree. The Scottish Government takes a progressive approach to taxation that allows us to raise on average an extra £1.8 billion in Scotland, which we reinvest back in our vitally important public services. If Mr Hoy wants to make the case for tax cuts, he will have to come and engage with me on the areas in which he would like to see cuts in the Scottish Government budget, because that is the reality of tax cuts and what they would deliver in terms of spending in Scotland.
During a cost of living crisis that we all know is affecting our constituents, we should be thinking more about how we can reinvest in our public services, rather than taking money away from the vital front-line services on which our people rely.
link
The Deputy First Minister will know that, outside times of crisis such as the Covid-19 pandemic and the global financial crisis, public spending as a share of UK national income is at its highest level in decades. That is in no small part because of the new fiscal rules that have been adopted by the Labour Government and its tax-and-spend decisions—many of which, I have to say, our SNP colleagues lined up with the Tories to oppose.
The challenge is to maximise the value from public spending and to address the drivers of demand on public services. With the Chancellor of the Exchequer announcing proposals for a budget line for preventative departmental expenditure limits, and debates on preventative spending taking place in Parliament next week, is the Government prepared to seize the moment and secure a decisive shift towards prevention that is both financially sound and socially progressive?
link
Of course we want to take an approach to the budget that reflects our preventative approach to spend, and we will work with the UK Government on some of those issues.
More broadly, however, the UK budget was an opportunity for the new chancellor, on coming into post, to reverse some of the austerity policies, such as the bedroom tax, the benefits cap and the local housing allowance freeze, that are harming our constituents in Scotland. We are spending millions of pounds from our taxpayers in Scotland to mitigate their impact, which means that we have reduced spending power here. However, I very much look forward to engaging with Mr Fagan ahead of the budget on all of those substantive issues.
link
Yesterday, the Finance and Public Administration Committee heard from the Office for Budget Responsibility that an accounting change to how hedge-fund executives pay their tax, from capital gains tax to income tax, will create a £250 million-a-year block grant adjustment to the Scottish budget.
What discussions has the Minister for Public Finance had with the UK Government about the impact of a further £1 billion burden on Scottish taxpayers if that change goes ahead?
link
Mr Brown will appreciate that we are currently engaging with the Scottish Fiscal Commission on a range of issues ahead of the budget, so I will be happy to come back to Parliament in the coming weeks and set out the detail of the budget to answer the member’s substantive point at that time.
Question 7 has not been lodged.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.