This is the first members’ business debate that I have secured in this parliamentary session and I cannot think of a more fitting reason for one, because this is an amazing city. It is a fantastic place to live, work and grow up in, and one of the things that makes this city amazing is its fantastic bus service.
Steve Jobs once said that advanced technology becomes so advanced that it becomes indistinguishable from magic. I worry that, as wonderful as Lothian Buses is, it is so good that sometimes people here maybe take it for granted. So, when I saw that this October would be the 40th anniversary of the creation of Lothian Region Transport in 1986—interestingly, it is also the 100th anniversary of the opening of Annandale bus depot—I recognised the need to mark that, because Lothian Buses is a critical part of this city. It is a fantastic example of what buses can do in providing a public service. Critically, looking at that anniversary, we see that it was not necessarily destined to be so; instead, it had to be decided on, fought for and secured.
I want to make remarks about the past of Lothian Buses because it is important to understand where it has come from. However, I also want to remark on the present—on where we are with regard to bus services and the lessons that Lothian Buses might have for services across the country—and on the future, because that is critical.
The year 1986 was one of privatisation and deregulation, with the drive by the Thatcher Government to try to bring about competition because it would deliver for all. Instead of selling off the assets, which happened in many places across the country, the Labour administration in Lothian Regional Council decided—because the Transport Act 1985 forced it to divest direct control of bus services—to create an arm’s-length body that would be wholly owned by the council. That was a bold and brave decision.
It was not only in 1986 that that decision had to be taken; in 1992, the Conservative Government made a further attempt to force what was left of the publicly owned bus services to be further privatised. I feel sorry for Miles Briggs at this point, as he is the only Conservative member present, but I do not hold him personally responsible for those decisions. There was an attempt to create management bias, and that was when we saw the big surge in the creation of now private companies such as Stagecoach and First Bus, which were once United Kingdom companies but are now in ownership in various parts of the world.
The councillors in Edinburgh resisted that attempt at privatisation, which was controversial even in the Labour group. People such as David Begg and Donald Anderson argued that perhaps we should go down that route, but Eric Milligan and Keith Geddes stood firm. That is notable. I think that Donald has written a couple of very good columns about that history, in which he acknowledged that he was wrong—I think that it is one of few issues that he was wrong about. He is somebody who I think has a lot to say about buses.
That decision allowed Lothian Buses to go from strength to strength, from its rebranding into Lothian Buses at the point when it was embarking on the bus wars—when private bus companies sought to undercut it and drive it out of business, which it resisted—to the creation of the trams in 2014 and their integration into the wider bus service in 2025.
Lothian Buses is a great success story: 36 per cent of all bus journeys in Scotland are with Lothian Buses, and people undertake more journeys with Lothian Buses than with ScotRail. I am pleased that so many representatives from Lothian Buses are present in the public gallery, from the employee director to union representatives from Unite, as well as apprentices, drivers and engineers. I take this opportunity to thank them for the work that they do in running the service on which so many people in the city rely.
The public ownership model is critical. It has allowed £43 million of capital investment and the reinvestment of profits in the system that keeps the city moving, including a £4.5 million social dividend, with services delivered according to social need. There is a self-sustaining bus service, run in the public interest, where profits are returned to grow public assets for that selfsame public who uses the service. Buses are critical public services and national infrastructure and are central to productivity—study after study shows that poor public transport holds productivity back.
It is quite simple: if someone does not have the means to travel to alternative employment for better job prospects or better wages, that is not just damaging for the individual; it is damaging for the whole economy. That is why public control is important and why it is on the agendas of both the UK Government and, I am glad to hear, the Scottish Government.
However, we need to move further, because the bus services picture is not as rosy across the whole country. Since 2007-08, when bus use was at its peak, we have seen a 31 per cent fall in the number of bus journeys in Scotland. At the same time, Lothian Buses bus journeys are 30 per cent higher. Since 2019-20, we have seen a 15 per cent decline in the bus fleet and we have 10 per cent fewer people working in the bus sector. At the same time, the revenue going to private bus companies is 9 per cent higher than it was five years ago and the public subsidy is 24 per cent higher. Quite simply, we are getting less but paying more for it.
That is why we must move forward with bus franchising. Let us be clear that bus franchising has been very positive for Manchester. There has been a 40 per cent increase in passenger numbers, a 7 per cent increase in—sorry, I cannot read my own handwriting here—and the cost is 33 per cent lower per mile than in the deregulated system. That shows that public sector control—and, critically, control of the fare box—is important.
I also want to be clear that franchising is a means to an end, not an end in itself. We must take care, and I appreciate Stephen Flynn’s comment during last week’s bus debate that whatever moves are made to advance franchising, the Lothian Buses model will be protected. In my view, although franchising is an improvement, the end is municipal, publicly owned bus services. Lothian Buses is a great model. We must celebrate it, but we must also protect it. Bus services are critical national infrastructure.
I will close with this: we might wait months or maybe even years for a bus debate, but we are blessed in the Parliament, last week and this week, to have had two come along at once. I look forward to a great debate that celebrates Lothian Buses and bus services as a whole.
17:47