I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests.
Labour’s motion recognises the need for better data. I want to spend a few minutes focusing particularly on additional support for learning in Scotland and improved understanding of the needs of young learners in Scotland.
Last year, Audit Scotland identified that 40 per cent of pupils in publicly funded schools were recorded as receiving additional support for learning, with the proportion in Scotland’s most deprived areas almost double that in the least deprived areas. However, the briefing paper also noted that it was simply
“not possible to determine the scale, complexity and nature of additional support needs across Scotland due to inconsistencies and gaps in data recording.”
The subsequent McManus review, which reported this year, similarly recognised the problem, stating that a
“clearer national picture of children and young people’s needs, support and progress must inform decision-making and improvement.”
It is precisely that clarity that the motion calls for.
Although we all recognise the growth and increasing complexity of need over the past decade, those who have been around additional support for learning for longer will remember the hope that was attached to the Doran review of 2012, the Morgan review of 2020 and other reviews. Those reports highlighted a gap between Scotland’s commitment to inclusive education and the reality that is faced by children, families and teaching staff. Now we have had the McManus review, further recognising the continuing pressures across schools and variation in provision across Scotland. Professionals in the sector could be forgiven for wondering whether the latest review will gain the traction that its predecessors did not.
Armed with better data, the Scottish Government and local authorities could better evaluate how additional support for learning is being planned for, funded and staffed.
In my former role with an autism charity, I was often concerned to hear of neurodivergent young people missing out on their education because they found it hard to cope in mainstream classrooms. That might have been because of sensory overwhelm or the social pressures of the classroom, or it might have been because the young people needed more processing time and communication that met their thinking style. I mention that because, all too often, such absences were not recorded as formal exclusions. However, when a parent is regularly asked to collect their dysregulated child after an hour or so in the classroom, or when a child disconnects from education because they cannot face that level of stress, we are talking about below-the-radar exclusion.
Therefore, I recognise and welcome the cabinet secretary’s commitment to better data recording on absences, as she has set out in previous answers to me in the chamber, and to the staged intervention model, as outlined in the McManus review. That must be actioned effectively if we are to gain a true picture of need and respond appropriately.
We also need to have a nuanced conversation about absences and behaviour that recognises that, in some cases, those are signs of unmet learning needs. At the same time as identifying and addressing the scale of disengagement from education, we need to recognise that inclusive education is not about whether a young person is in the same room as their peers; it is about whether they are in an environment where they can learn effectively and whether they feel that they belong.
Let us be clear: the need for consistent data does not mean that we should move to a one-size-fits-all approach. Although we need national measures of literacy and numeracy, educational attainment—particularly for learners with greater support needs—must be understood, recognised and celebrated on an individual basis, which might require a different pace of learning and a different measure of outcomes. We need to consider carefully how we define and measure outcomes for that group of young people, so that we can more accurately assess whether the support and the learning that are being provided are effective.
Every child has the right to an education and the opportunity to learn, but every child does not learn in the same way or thrive in the same environment. As the McManus review recognises, that needs to be reflected in curriculum design, not just in the staged intervention model that is under development.
No one doubts the commitment or ambition of schools, teachers and classroom practitioners in relation to young people with additional support needs. However, education professionals are being asked to meet increasingly significant and complex needs without the capacity, resources and learning and development opportunities that they require to do so. With robust data to hand and adequate resources to meet identified needs, schools and teachers could more accurately allocate the required resources for additional support for learning, whether it is for well-trained learning support assistants, environmental adjustments, communication aids or other accommodations.
We can develop a deeper understanding of the needs of our young people who require additional support. Fundamentally, we can better determine what is working and where we need to do more. We need shared learning on progress and impacts, as the McManus review called for.
The sector will need greater resourcing. Teachers are under considerable pressure to deliver in classrooms that include learners with diverse and specialist needs, and they require the training, support and staffing resources to meet those needs. This year, the Scottish Government has received more than £0.5 billion as a result of increased spending on special educational needs in England. I hope that the Scottish Government will take the learning from the McManus review and the increased resources at hand to grasp the nettle, so that we have an education system in Scotland that is truly inclusive.
16:08