Absolutely. Where we see successes in the pub trade and communities coming together, they should be rightly celebrated by members across the chamber. That is an example from the member’s constituency of somewhere where the pub is a vital cornerstone of the community and we should absolutely be congratulating those involved.
That brings me on to my next point, which is crucial: it is not only about the economic value. The moment a pub goes, Scotland loses another piece of its social and cultural fabric. There has been debate about whether some of the issue is down to changing lifestyles and consumer habits; and there may be an element of truth in that but I do not believe that it explains the full picture. The fundamental problem is that pub owners have spent decades facing rising costs, rising taxes, rising regulations and growing bureaucracy from government at every level. They have found themselves on the sharp edge of almost every political decision affecting hospitality in the past 25 years.
I appreciate that, as other members have raised already, a lot of those pressures originate at Westminster. Alcohol duty remains a major burden and VAT continues to weigh heavily on hospitality businesses. National insurance increases have added significant costs for employers and, in many cases in recent years, have been the straw that has broken the camel’s back.
A lot of those issues are reserved matters, but there is a lot more that we can do in this Parliament. Business rates remain one of the biggest concerns raised by publicans across Scotland. We repeatedly hear from publicans who feel that they are carrying a disproportionate burden while fighting tooth and nail to keep their doors open. If we genuinely value pubs as community assets, we must ensure that they are not being taxed out of existence.
We must also strengthen planning protections. Many people are surprised to learn that a free-standing pub in Scotland can be demolished without planning permission. If a community is at risk of losing one of its most important social assets, local people should have a meaningful say before the bulldozers arrive. Often, once a pub is gone, it is gone for ever.
There is also a wider cultural question that we need to confront honestly. Too often, discussions around pubs have been filtered purely through a public health lens. Let me be clear: alcohol abuse exists and it can cause real harm. I do not think that anyone across the chamber would disagree with that. However, there is a fundamental difference between tackling harmful drinking and treating responsible social drinking as a problem that needs to be managed. The overwhelming majority of people who enjoy a drink in their local do so responsibly. While doing so, they are supporting local businesses, meeting friends, raising money for charity, supporting local sports teams and strengthening their communities. Social drinking is not something that has to be apologised for. It is a normal and valued part of Scottish life, and the nanny state needs to give it a wee bit of breathing room.
Scotland’s pubs are not a relic of the past. They are not—as I believe that one Labour MP down south said—some right-wing “nostalgic vision” of a country that “never really existed”. They are living institutions. They are woven into the story of our nation. They employ people, attract visitors, strengthen communities and preserve traditions that have endured for generations. That is why it was disappointing to hear recent claims in this chamber that pubs are somehow exclusionary places. Anyone who has spent more than five minutes in a pub in this country will know just how absurd that suggestion is.
For too long, Governments of all colours have looked at pubs and seen a problem to regulate rather than an institution to protect. They have piled on taxes, costs, regulations and bureaucracy and they now act surprised when another pub closes its doors. We cannot regulate our way to vibrant communities, we cannot tax our way to thriving high streets and we cannot lecture people on what they should be doing in their free time. If we want strong communities, we need strong community institutions, and the local pub is arguably the most important of those institutions.
We should stop treating social drinking as a problem. We should start recognising pubs as the community assets that they are. We must reform business rates so that pubs are not taxed to oblivion, and we must strengthen planning protections.
I would argue that people here should be speaking to their colleagues in Westminster as well, because a lot of what we have talked about is very much done on a Westminster basis.
Finally, I will make one simple request. If we value our local pub, we should use it, support it, take our friends there, have a meal there and hold our events there. If we do not support these institutions while they are still here, we may soon find ourselves talking about them in the past tense.
A country that values community should value its pubs, so let us start acting like it. Cheers to Scotland's boozers.
18:01