Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Environmental Impacts of Hyperscale Data Centres

Thursday 5 November 2026 Climate Action Committee About 09:15 Evidence session 240 contributions · 12 speakers

This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

240 contributions · showing 201–240
Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

I cannot give figures, because I have not looked into that, but it is clear that the noise is proportional to the size of the data centre. It will mostly be cooling fans that create the noise, so the bigger the data centre, the more need there will be for cooling infrastructure. Another issue is that evaporative cooling is quieter than closed-loop cooling, because, with the latter, you are operating the equivalent of a fridge, so you have more than just the fans—you have compressors and so on—so the infrastructure is noisier. I cannot put decibel-milliwatt values on that, but, if you imagine the noise from the cooling infrastructure of, say, a supermarket and then multiply that by many, many times, that is the noise that you will get.

Alejandro Gallego Schmid University of Manchester
link

To build on what the other witnesses have said, the cooling is crucial in relation to noise. If, in Scotland, less cooling is needed, that will have an influence and will lead to less noise.The back-up systems are quite noisy. Those are not continuous, but they need to be tested every once in a while. Obviously, that is not a continuous noise such as the one associated with cooling, but it is quite noisy when those systems have to be tested.Obviously, there are options to isolate the noise so that it does not affect the nearby area, including biodiversity there, which is another important issue to consider. We tend to think about the issue in urban areas, but, if data centres are in more isolated areas that are close to biodiversity hotspots, it is important to consider how the noise can affect biodiversity as well.

Sanne Dijkstra-Downie LD Edinburgh Northern
link

Good afternoon, everyone. I have questions on e-waste. Alejandro Gallego Schmid mentioned the embodied carbon related to the production of hardware. Clearly, the equipment has a limited lifespan, which means that there is potential for a rise in electronic waste resulting from data centres. How concerned are you about the impacts of that?

Alejandro Gallego Schmid University of Manchester
link

I am concerned, for different reasons. Hardware for the new types of data centres that are associated with artificial intelligence has a much shorter lifespan than that for normal data centres. That is not because the hardware does not last as long but because there are continual updates and some of the hardware will be updated quite quickly. Potentially, that will increase the e-waste that is associated with those data centres. Studies show that the hardware for normal data centres can last for six, seven or eight years, whereas that for artificial intelligence-related data centres lasts for about two or three years.That has many implications. A percentage of e-waste is hazardous. In the global south, the implications go beyond the environmental impact; there are also social impacts. In those countries, hazardous waste cannot be treated with the same safety requirements as it is in the UK.There are potential solutions. We have to try to apply circular economy strategies in data centres and see how we can expand the life of the hardware in a modular way. For example, if we had a new, more modern and up-to-date GPU, we would not have to change the whole system; we could simply change the GPU. That relates to the design. If new hardware becomes available, it does not mean that the existing hardware cannot be used in other places, such as universities or small and medium-sized companies. We can repair, refurbish, or remanufacture components and, once we have used the hardware as much as possible, the components can be safely recycled at the end of their life.

Sanne Dijkstra-Downie LD Edinburgh Northern
link

That is helpful. Thomas Morstyn, I saw you nodding. Do you want to add anything?

Thomas Morstyn University of Oxford
link

I do not have much to add. At the moment, at least, the prices for the older GPU hardware for two generations ago are staying the same, or even increasing, because there is strong demand and there is a significant reuse market for those things. One of the benefits of data centres being centralised is that it creates economies of scale around reuse for other applications. The GPU servers are becoming increasingly expensive and power dense. They have sophisticated components, so there is huge value relative to the raw materials if we consider the price compared with the material that is in them, which might also help.

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

I have a slightly different perspective on that. I would estimate that the amount of computing that we do in Scotland is about 500MW—tops. If we are going to have servers for 1GW data centres that will typically reach the ends of their lives after two or three years, there is simply not enough scope for reuse. There are too many computers; we could reuse only a fraction of them. Effectively, the rest would become waste.The picture is not limited to Scotland; the growth in data centres is repeated globally. That means that we would end up with an enormous number of computers that were no longer usable by anyone, because we have too many computers.The other part is that things such as data centre inference servers can be used to do AI inference but their use case is extremely specific. You could use them to do scientific computing, but we already have supercomputers that do that. So, again, there is not really much use for these things once they reach the ends of their lives. Therefore, I am afraid that, if we do not have more limited growth in data centres, we will end up with a huge amount of e-waste—many times more than we have at the moment.People are working on the issue, trying to repurpose and refurbish computers and so on, but, if the scale is too large, all that you can do is reclaim the materials that are inside the equipment, and we do not have an ability to do that effectively at scale yet—that is an extremely energy-intensive process at the moment.

Sanne Dijkstra-Downie LD Edinburgh Northern
link

If I hear you correctly, you are saying that, in theory, the computers could be reused, but there would be an oversupply. I appreciate that this might be difficult, but can you quantify that oversupply?

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

That is what I was trying to do. I will explain the simple calculation that I did. There are 5 million people in Scotland. If they all have a laptop or a desktop computer that uses 50W, then we will have 500MW of compute. That is a huge overestimate, although, of course, we would have to include all the enterprise computers as well, but that is an indication of the level that could be reused. If you had 500MW of data centre capacity, and if it were like for like—that is, if those servers could be given to people—that is the maximum that you could ever reuse. However, it would not be like for like, because we have very specialised servers that can be used only for very similar purposes. That means that the percentage that could be reused would be much lower—less than a fraction of what you would produce.

Sanne Dijkstra-Downie LD Edinburgh Northern
link

Thank you. That is helpful.I want to turn to the issue of heat networks, which we discussed with the previous witnesses. Thomas Morstyn, a lot of heat that is produced is wasted if it is not reused. How feasible do you think it is for that heat waste to be used in heat networks?

Thomas Morstyn University of Oxford
link

Using the waste heat from data centres is technically feasible. It is not necessarily the best source of waste heat, but, on the other hand, if you are building very large data centres, that is definitely a resource that is available to be tapped. There are challenges, however, such as having to have the data centre in a location that makes it convenient to use the waste heat. There is also the question of how you think about building a heat network, particularly if you already have buildings that are not connected to heat networks. There are challenges around planning in relation to building new developments versus connecting to older buildings.I have been involved with research that looked at various sites where there were existing data centres. In the case of Google data centres around Europe, we estimated that it might be possible to use around 25 per cent of their waste heat. That is the figure that sort of makes sense, but it is very specific to the particular development.The key point is that, when you are thinking about responsibly developing a data centre site, heat reuse should definitely be considered in the planning process, as there can be environmental benefits.

Sanne Dijkstra-Downie LD Edinburgh Northern
link

Wim Vanderbauwhede, you say in your submission that, from the perspective of optimising heat reuse, building smaller data centres located close to population centres is a better choice. Can you explain why that is the case?

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

If you build a hyperscale data centre, you end up with an enormously large amount of waste heat. If you want to distribute that heat to where it can be used to heat homes, you will have to build considerable infrastructure that does not currently exist. That will take time, and there is also the question of who will pay for that infrastructure. The challenge is a lot less with smaller data centres that are close to population centres. First, the fact that they are smaller means that the amount of heat that has to be transported is a lot less. Secondly, the distances are shorter, so the infrastructure costs will be lower. Therefore, from the perspective of heat reuse, it makes sense to have smaller data centres closer to population centres.12:30The data centre does not necessarily have to be hyperscale in order to be useful. There are companies that, for example, offer products that you can use to heat a swimming pool. Those are container-sized data centres and they have almost no infrastructure. Those solutions are under development. There is a whole spectrum of possibilities.With a hyperscale data centre, the amount of waste heat is extremely large, so you would have to build a dedicated network to transport all of that heat to where it could be used.Another problem is that you can use that heat only during cold times of the year. You will not use that waste heat in summer, because there is nothing that needs to be heated. You could argue that some sites need heating all year round, but I have tried to estimate that, and it represents a very small amount of our total heating needs.

Sanne Dijkstra-Downie LD Edinburgh Northern
link

Alejandro Gallego Schmid, what size of data centre would you consider to be optimal for supplying waste heat to heat networks?

Alejandro Gallego Schmid University of Manchester
link

I agree with the points that have been made about the proposal being more feasible in relation to small data centres. As Thomas Morstyn said, it is not so much a technological problem as one associated with the necessary infrastructure. We have the technology to do what is proposed, but the difficulty is the need to build the associated infrastructure.That is also related to planning. The question of whether there is already a heat network nearby that could be connected to the data centre could be one of the criteria that is considered.One of the points that I was going to make has been mentioned by Wim Vanderbauwhede. We have to consider the fact that the data centres will still be producing heat in the summer, when it is less needed. That means that the percentage of heat recovery will be much less than 100 per cent.In line with that, it is interesting that Germany, for example, already requires some percentage of heat reuse from data centres. The requirements are being phased in. At the moment, 10 per cent of the heat must be reused, but that will rise to 15 per cent next year and 20 per cent the year after that. However, there is a caveat: the requirement applies only where reuse is technically and economically feasible. In other words, necessary conditions must be met in order for the data centres to achieve those percentages.

Stuart McMillan SNP The Convener · Inverclyde
link

David Barratt has a brief supplementary question.

David Barratt SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I just want to clarify something. When we talk about small-scale data centres, could we be talking about multiple facilities across urban areas? Are we talking about facilities with less than 1MW of capacity? It would be useful to get an idea of the capacity that is involved.

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

The one that I mentioned that can heat a swimming pool is in the kilowatt range—probably 100kW; perhaps a little more. Heating a home requires close to 10kW.

Stuart McMillan SNP The Convener · Inverclyde
link

Before we conclude, I have two brief questions. Are there any examples of regulation or proposed regulation that the Scottish Government should consider? For example, Lombardy has introduced a new law this year; Australia is proposing that new large-scale data centres should underwrite their power supplies, limit their water use and pay for any additional water infrastructure; and Ireland will require data centre developers to support the development of new renewable energy projects.

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

I wrote in my submission that I do not know much about that. However, I had a look and noticed that Spain is working on legislation to impose stricter limits on the amount of data centre capacity that can be installed in certain areas. Regulation is not my strong point, so I cannot add to what you have just listed. That said, I note that Ireland has introduced a moratorium on additional capacity, but I do not know whether it falls under formal regulation, because it is an ad hoc measure.

Thomas Morstyn University of Oxford
link

In Texas, there is legislation requiring data centres to provide flexibility during emergency grid conditions. That was brought in quite early, so it is perhaps a bit of a blunt instrument. There are probably more nuanced ways to do that. There are options to make sure that data centres are linked to the grid operators’ needs in terms of system stability and effects on congestion, so there is definitely room for regulation.

Alejandro Gallego Schmid University of Manchester
link

There are several interesting pieces of legislation. For example, the European Union requires quite a lot of data on data centres. That is important. Transparency is crucial, because we cannot tackle what we cannot measure. Steps in that direction are really interesting.Several moratoriums are in place to enable research to be carried out. For example, in the state of New York there is a one-year moratorium on approving any data centre in order to better understand their capacity requirements. The approach is very interesting in Singapore, where they have a cap, which I think is 300MW. They accept petitions for a share of that capacity and select projects that are, for example, more sustainable or beneficial. In the Netherlands, a moratorium is in place across the country regarding the development of hyperscale data centres, except in two specific areas. Those are quite different examples and approaches.I would definitely encourage the Polish approach of having greater access to data and a much better understanding of the electricity consumption and heat generation of different potential future data centres.

Stuart McMillan SNP The Convener · Inverclyde
link

The use of vegetable oil for back-up generation has come up only once this morning. How realistic is it that that could be used for hyperscale data centres? The Scottish Government is considering hyperscale data centres that exceed 50MW.

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

I do not know how easy it would be to scale up the infrastructure for creating biodiesel, which is the type of fuel that would be used. However, with regard to local nuisance, let us say, or pollution, that would not help, as it would still create the same kind of NOemissions and so on. The amount of pollution is considerable. I calculated it for a 500MW data centre, but we can simply scale it down. If all the diesel back-up generators for a 50MW data centre are switched on, that is like 2,000 lorries idling at the same time, releasing, in effect, a huge cloud of toxic air. Whether the back-up generators use biofuel or not has an effect on COemissions but not on local pollution.I think that that is probably the most significant factor, because the assumption is that the back-up generators will not be needed most of the time. Therefore, the total amount of emissions that they produce should be very small—otherwise, there would be a big problem for the grid. Assuming that we cap the total capacity, it might be possible to produce enough biofuel for the back-up generators, but, when they were on, they would cause a lot of pollution locally for a data centre of that size. That problem does not go away.

Thomas Morstyn University of Oxford
link

No. I have not looked into that issue in detail.

Alejandro Gallego Schmid University of Manchester
link

Building on what Wim said, the problem is that we do not have the capacity. It is important to consider that. Nowadays, all the biofuels that are produced in the UK go to transport although there are other sectors that would want to use that biofuel, such as the flooding prevention sector. There is a capacity problem that relates to the availability of biofuel for such purposes. That does not mean that we cannot increase the capacity, but the current capacity has already been allocated for a different purpose, so there will be no room to use biofuel instead of diesel for back-up generators. I agree with Wim that the use of biofuel for back-up generators would solve a small part of the issue of carbon emissions but would not address the local air pollution associated with, for example, NO.

Stuart McMillan SNP The Convener · Inverclyde
link

I have one more question, after which I will bring in Ariane Burgess for a final question. It is a question that I asked the previous panel. As has been mentioned, domestic energy is extremely expensive in the UK. If we decide to proceed with data centres, whether hyperscale or otherwise, should domestic customers be expected to pay higher bills as a consequence?

Alejandro Gallego Schmid University of Manchester
link

I am not an expert on cost, but I can see what is happening in other countries. There are already providers of data centres that are assuming the extra cost of electricity bills for local communities. Some states in the United States have started to make that mandatory. In such cases, the cost of electricity for local communities would not be affected. I think that it makes sense for the people who will benefit economically from the development of data centres to assume the extra electricity costs associated with that, but that is a personal opinion.

Thomas Morstyn University of Oxford
link

That is definitely an important issue. Given that data centre developers are very enthusiastic about building data centres, because of the economic upsides that doing so allows them to access, it does not seem to make a lot of sense for end consumers to end up paying more in their bills. However, there is the potential for that to happen, because, although it is possible to put in place arrangements to ensure that direct grid upgrades are paid for by data centre developers, there are still risks as a result of the way in which balancing the power grid is thought about in the UK. Because the balancing costs and some of the fixed network costs associated with congestion, reserve requirements and so on end up being spread across the bills of all consumers, there is the potential for such indirect effects on system costs to end up flowing through to end customers. Therefore, it is definitely important to think carefully about such issues.On the other hand, there is also an opportunity for the development of data centres to help in that regard, because one factor that has contributed to energy bills being higher in the UK is the fact that overall energy demand has been relatively flat or even reducing while the fixed network costs and balancing costs have been increasing. Those costs then have to be spread out across a smaller number of kilowatt hours, which increases the price of each kilowatt hour. Indeed, if you have these large sources of demand, you might, with appropriate arrangements, be able to ensure that the full cost of the system—or even slightly above that—is included, which would have the potential of reducing the per unit energy cost faced by other consumers. Even though more energy was being produced and distributed and more money was being spent on energy overall, a lot of that would come from these data centres.

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

I do not have much to add to what Thomas has just said. I definitely think that, to the degree that it is possible, the consumer should not have to pay for the costs arising from large data centres being built, because it is not clear that the consumer benefits from their construction in the first place, particularly if they are AI data centres. After all, most of the use of AI inference resources is very concentrated and not evenly distributed. Given that a few big players use most of those resources and drive their growth, most people do not benefit at all from them and certainly should not end up having to pay the bills.

Ariane Burgess Green Highlands and Islands
link

My question is directed to Wim Vanderbauwhede, who talked earlier about having smaller and more dispersed data centres that would have less environmental impact. Can you clarify what would happen in those data centres? Public sector reform is going on in Scotland at the moment, and in those discussions, certainly with local government, academia and so on, people are expressing great hope that certain aspects of AI will be able to help with the toil of things—to use a term that was used last week. Is that the kind of thing that would happen in these smaller, more environmentally dispersed data centres, or could things such as ChatGPT run in them, too?

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

It is all a matter of scale, isn’t it? Even a 100KW data centre could, if you wanted, run several large AI inference computers, which would service quite a lot of requests. Therefore, it could do that ChatGPT and Copilot-style work.It is not so clear from the studies that I have read from the UK Government that there will be that much relief from toil; it seems to be more about displacing what work you do rather than an overall increase in productivity, but that is probably a separate discussion. The fact is that the workload of a data centre depends mostly on what kind of service you choose to put into it. If you put in, say, a GPU server, you are very much saying that it will be an AI data centre, and it effectively cannot be used for much else. From that perspective, there will need to be careful consideration of the dominant work that you want these data centres to do.

Ariane Burgess Green Highlands and Islands
link

I am going to have to follow up on that, because I am still not quite clear. What I am trying to get at is this: if the recommendation was to have smaller, more dispersed data centres, would we still be able to support the country, local government and all the rest of it? I take your point about toil, but would we be able to support that goal and take it forward with smaller data centres that are better for the environment?

Wim Vanderbauwhede University of Glasgow
link

Oh, yes—definitely. A huge amount of resources is not needed to support that particular purpose.There is quite a bit of a misconception with regard to how much compute you need to do certain things. For example, when you try to detect, say, bowel cancer in X-rays, you use what people call AI—or machine learning, as I would call it—and it uses 100,000 times less energy than sending a query to ChatGPT. You are not going to fill a data centre with all the resources that the NHS needs for that kind of work—well, you might fill maybe a very small one.It really depends on the specific work that you want to do. With transcription and so on, you use very specialised types of AI, and you do not need a lot of energy in relative terms. Even if we were to cap capacity at what is already 10 times more than what we have now, we would still have plenty of leeway to do all of that work.

Stuart McMillan SNP The Convener · Inverclyde
link

Thank you very much. That concludes our business in public, and I would like to thank the three panel members for their evidence both this morning and this afternoon, as it now is. It genuinely has been very helpful.As agreed earlier, we now move into private session to consider the remaining item on our agenda.12:49Meeting continued in private until 13:03.

  1. 09:15 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:15 Environmental Impacts of Hyperscale Data Centres Evidence session · 240

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.