link
Agenda item 2 is our second week of evidence sessions as part of the committee’s inquiry into the environmental impacts of hyperscale data centres. As I did last week, I will say a few words about our inquiry before I introduce our witnesses.The committee agreed its approach to the inquiry on 17 September and 1 October. Our aim is to find out about the environmental impacts of the operation and construction of hyperscale data centres in Scotland. We will consider aspects such as water consumption, air quality, noise pollution and energy use, including back-up generation. We are also interested in the impact of growth in the sector on Scotland’s ability to meet its carbon budgets and on the climate change plan. We specifically want to know what systems should be in place to mitigate any negative impacts on the environment and what Scotland can learn from other countries.We are gathering information in three ways. First, the committee is collaborating with the Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee in running a call for views. I encourage people to share their views on the issue with us. Details can be found on the committee’s website.Secondly, committee members recently visited a data centre in North Lanarkshire. The visit to the DV1 site, which is run by DataVita, allowed members to see how a data centre operates.Thirdly, we are taking evidence from experts over three meetings. Last week, we heard evidence from witnesses with an environmental background and then from witnesses with experience of data centre development in Ireland. Today, we will take evidence from a panel of witnesses from the technology sector and then take evidence from a panel of experts on sustainability and greenhouse gas emissions. Next week, we will finish the first part of our evidence taking on data centres by speaking to witnesses on issues relating to water and waste heat. The committee has agreed to consider a second phase of work following the conclusion of those evidence sessions.I re-emphasise that the committee is not engaging in scrutiny of individual planning applications, which are matters for local authorities. At this stage, we are gathering information that will be shared with the Scottish Government in advance of its production of national planning guidance.I welcome our first witnesses: Craig Melson, associate director of techUK, and Andrew Weir, chief executive officer of ScotlandIS. I look forward to hearing your evidence.I will ask some opening questions before I bring in my colleagues. Mr Weir, in the written evidence that you submitted, you touch on opportunities, competing demands, financially robust contracts and identifying delivery partners. Much of the evidence and communication that we have received so far has centred around the fact that there are at least 23 applications for data centres in Scotland. It is clear that, for some of the applications, end users are already in situ, whereas others are speculative applications. Given that, would it actually help not only this committee and its work, but the Scottish Government, too, as it considers the upcoming guidance and guidelines that it is going to produce, to have something that is a bit sharper? In other words, instead of looking at everything to do with the 23 applications, at least, for data centres, I wonder whether, if there are applications with an end user already lined up and a contract potentially signed, it would be better to take a more focused approach that allows those with an end user to progress to the next stage of consideration and those that are speculative not to be considered.





