link
To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to the recent report by the independent professional adviser on future school reform on strengthening the education system. (S7O-00439)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to the recent report by the independent professional adviser on future school reform on strengthening the education system. (S7O-00439)
link
I welcome the report from John Wilson, the independent professional adviser, who was appointed by Scottish ministers to provide a school leaders’ perspective on how schools are supported to improve, funded and governed. I am grateful to him and to all those who contributed to its development.
As Joe Fagan will know, the Scottish Government is currently in dialogue with local authorities and others on local governance reform. I have just left a meeting with the First Minister, Deputy First Minister and leaders from the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities on that matter. As part of our work on it, we will consider the recommendations in Mr Wilson’s report.
link
I refer to my entry in the register of interests, as I am a councillor in South Lanarkshire.
I am sure that when the Government publishes its response it will agree that although some of the adviser’s recommendations have merit, others are utterly absurd, not least the one about plans for school authorities that are outside of council control—that is a charter for more, rather than fewer, silos, and for less, rather than more, democracy. That recommendation will appease neither those who believe in a fundamental shift towards school autonomy nor those who believe in the fundamental principle of democratic accountability. It is also divorced from the need to drive excellence and improvement in public service reform.
Will the education secretary act now to protect local democracy, the drive for excellence and the reputation of her own Government with public service leaders and educators? She should not wait, so will she bin those recommendations now?
link
No, we absolutely will not bin the recommendations. They are a very valuable contribution to our discussions with local authorities. Mr Fagan is a South Lanarkshire councillor, and I am a South Lanarkshire MSP, so I hope that we both have an interest in ensuring that the schools in our area and throughout Scotland can pursue excellence alongside equity and the highest standards. I want to see the unwarranted variation in academic outcomes closed. Much of what was contained in Mr Wilson’s report can help us to do that.
John Wilson spoke of inconsistencies in the collection of data and of metrics; we have to question whether doing something 32 different ways across Scotland is the best approach. He also identified a lack of clarity of spend and made recommendations on governance. All of those recommendations are being closely considered as we engage with local authorities and COSLA on the future shape of local government and education, which is a core part of that.
link
In the report, the argument is made that funding for school education is the most powerful way for our country to invest in our future. Does the Government acknowledge that any changes to the structure of the education system need to be met with additional support and funding?
link
Katherine Sangster is right to highlight John Wilson’s point about how funding for education is perhaps the greatest preventative investment that we can make in the future of our nation. I wonder how her acknowledgement of the valuable contribution that was made on that in the report is reconciled with Joe Fagan’s call for the whole thing to be disregarded, which I have said that I will not do. I appreciate that reform and change of any kind requires careful consideration and resource, which the member challenged me on, but maintaining the status quo and doing nothing are also costly.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.