link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of any environmental impact of artificial intelligence data centres in other countries. (S7O-00428)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of any environmental impact of artificial intelligence data centres in other countries. (S7O-00428)
link
The Scottish Government has assessed the experience of countries with similar climates and demographics that host data centres, and that has helped to shape the Scottish Government’s approach to ensure that data centre developments in Scotland are sustainable, protect our national resources and deliver tangible benefits for communities and the wider economy. International experience has demonstrated the value of setting clear expectations before development becomes concentrated and aligning the growth of data centres with energy system planning, land use and environment considerations.
On a visit to Brussels during the October recess, I met representatives of the United Nations Environment Programme, European subnational Governments and other partners. We discussed the need to ensure that increasing digital infrastructure demand is managed sustainably, including through energy efficiency, renewable energy use and consideration of wider environmental and social impacts.
link
The cabinet secretary will be aware of the on-going concerns regarding the impact of artificial intelligence data centres in Ireland. Data centres accounted for almost a quarter of Ireland’s energy use last year. The Irish Climate Change Advisory Council has warned that the growth in data centres’ energy demand is threatening Ireland’s ability to meet its climate change commitments. Will the cabinet secretary ensure that climate action is central to any planning or decisions that we make in relation to AI data centres, particularly considering the experience around energy commitments?
link
Carol Mochan mentioned the experience of Ireland. I believe that the Parliament’s Climate Action Committee is taking evidence on data centres at the moment. I know that the convener is sitting behind me, and he told me the other day that he is reaching out to Irish colleagues in order to get exactly those kind of lessons from what they are doing.
On the development of the regulations, I note that Hannah Mary Goodlad, the Minister for Public Finance, is taking that forward. I am of course feeding into that, in my role as cabinet secretary for climate action.
To go back to Carol Mochan’s first question, I am feeding back the experience of other countries that are wrestling with the issue. In Brussels, one particular presentation was given by my counterpart in the Lombardy region of Italy, in which he talked about the regulations that they have put in place. We are all sharing our experiences in the group that we are involved in—the Under2 Coalition—because we are all wrestling with the same challenges.
link
We have been promised by various Government ministers that full planning guidance on data centres will be released by the end of this year. Can the cabinet secretary assure Parliament that MSPs will have time to review that guidance before Parliament closes for winter recess?
link
As I said to the chamber in my last answer to Carol Mochan, Hannah Mary Goodlad, the Minister for Public Finance, is taking forward those regulations. She has given assurances to Parliament that the guidance will be revised and ready by the end of the year. I have nothing more to add, given that it is not my initial responsibility.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.