It is almost as if the member could read the notes that I have here, as I was coming on to make a point—and she makes a strong point—about the apprenticeship levy. I want to expand provision massively, and we also need to have an honest conversation about what an apprenticeship actually is. Some apprenticeships are pretty clunky and difficult to access, and they serve a particular set of industries, which means that many people are missing out on them.
We have also called—as I do not doubt that the member is aware—for the devolution of the skills and employability functions of the Department for Work and Pensions and the apprenticeship levy, which is currently a bin fire of an opaque tax. It is a tax on jobs—it is administered by the UK Treasury, which top slices it, and it then comes back as general spend to the Scottish exchequer and we put it into the general run of funds. The net effect, therefore, is that there is less money in the skills budget than I would like to see.
I am perfectly happy to take that criticism from the member on the nose, because I hope that there is a consensus in this place that, if there is a cluttered landscape, we should design the system in Scotland to make it work better for our citizens, who are not currently being served as well as they need to be. That should include workplace learning, earn while you learn, breaking down the barriers between schools, colleges and universities, with much more joint working and joint qualifications. It should also include a focus on lifelong learning, because the system is not just about young people, although they are key to much of it.
We are going to need to retrain a lot of people throughout their life journey, because the world of work is changing before our eyes at a rate of knots. Too much of our educational establishment is still based on the idea of a young person who goes through education or training and gets a piece of paper that sits in a file for 40 years and then retires. That model has gone now—we need to augment, reskill and upskill all our workers, and we need to make that easy. That is a challenge to our educational institutions, but they are up for it. I have been working the length and breadth of Scotland, speaking to colleges and universities that are operating in exactly that space—I am excited about what we can be doing with that work, and apprenticeships are very much key to that.
In the time available, I will pick up on a number of points that members have made. Daniel Johnson made a point about shifting responsibility for apprenticeships into the SFC. That was before my time in post, although I strongly agree with it. The object of that exercise is to have responsibility for colleges, universities and apprenticeships in one place on a national level, moving to a regionally delivered structure within the national skills framework.
I very much take Daniel Johnson’s point about the SFC, and the matter is live on my desk right now. I want the approach to be business led, and I want the proper incentives for institutions on the supply side, and for employers on the demand side, to make it easier to take people on. The system needs to be more flexible and better incentivised—I have made that challenge to the SFC, which is working on it right now.
Angela Ross made the point that university should not be the default destination—I strongly agree with that, and I think that we have a consensus there. I remember a previous conversation in the chamber with Stephen Kerr, in which he said that there might be more than one route, but one could be forgiven for thinking that we are all encouraged to go down one route. I strongly agree with him on that.
Iris Duane made a point about support for students. I strongly agree with that, but I think that earn while you learn should be the norm, rather than the exception. Having people learn and gain skills closer to the workplace should help with budgets as well, and I think that it would go a long way towards dealing with the costs.
Rachael Hamilton mentioned the apprenticeship levy; I have said where I am on that. Liam McArthur made a number of sensible points, and the Government will be accepting the Lib Dem amendment, because it contains a number of good points about health issues, and in particular about how rural and island folks access the system.
We heard a very strong speech from Karen Adam, who highlighted the impact—she was the only member to refer to it—of Covid and lockdown on young folks. We are still dealing with a lot of the consequences of that, and people’s confidence is not where it needs to be. We see people who, having been checked out, are struggling to get back into the system, and we need a much more flexible way to encourage them in that.
Pauline McNeill made a point about honest data. That issue is very much live with me, and I hope that my earlier comments demonstrate that I am curious about the data, because I do not think that we are doing as well as we need to be. Equally, I do not think that it is a disaster, and there is a lot of good work going on in that space, so I want to build up that good work and knock down the things that are not functioning as well as they need to be. I am here not to justify how things are but to make things better.
Jack Middleton made a strong speech about petrochemical skills. As a child of oil and gas myself, I strongly agree with what he said in particular about the great work at NESCol, RGU and the University of Aberdeen—see, I can get them in as well. A number of other strong points were made. Laura Mitchell mentioned DYW Moray, which is doing some fantastic work in this space.
In my final few seconds, let us think about next steps. If we all agree that there is something that we need to do better on, I am game for that, and I am game for change. I am not here to defend institutions, academic or otherwise, nor to defend the state of their programmes if they are not delivering as well as they could be.
The future, for me, looks like Developing the Young Workforce—a cracking organisation that is doing great work. It is business led and operates on a regional basis. It also operates on a shoestring, I have to say, but it is delivering great work in the real world by getting people closer to work and into work.
Apprenticeships are very much my focus, because they will break down the barriers between the various institutions and the providers, including colleges and the private sector. However, we need an honest discussion about what an apprenticeship is, and about what adds value and what does not. Again, I want businesses to step up and tell us what that is. Apprenticeships are too difficult to get into right now and the silos need to be broken down.
We all agree that we are not doing as well as we need to do. I will work with anybody in the chamber with good ideas to get the system working better, because I believe that citizen-centred skills learning is the key to getting people into work. That is what we need to be focused on as a Parliament, and the Government will work with anybody to that end.