Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28

Wednesday 28 October 2026 Transport Committee About 09:15 Evidence session 236 contributions · 19 speakers

This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

236 contributions · showing 201–236
Allison Cosgrove
link

I will reference something that is in your back yard, convener, which is the railway station in Leven that reopened two years ago. I was there on the first day that it reopened, which was lovely, and I went back in the summer to see how things were going in Leven itself—a town that had really been on its uppers. I went round the shops, asking people, “Have you seen more trade? Have you seen more visitors?” and so on. Everyone, without exception, answered yes to those questions. People were really enthusiastic in saying that visitors were coming, especially on Sundays, because Leven has a lovely swimming pool and lovely beaches. I heard that the putting greens were being reopened and that the sea defences were being strengthened. It was wonderful to see that little town begin to blossom again.I am a resident of East Linton, which Tom Thorburn mentioned, and our station opened nearly three years ago. I cannot tell you the difference that it has made to the village. We have new housing, which has brought in young families, and our shops are much more sustainable. When I come to Edinburgh now, I do not take my car on the city bypass and add to the chaos; I get on a TransPennine Express train at half-past eight, which is wonderful.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Stop rubbing it in to Jordan Jack.

Allison Cosgrove
link

That will also happen for you in due course, Jordan. It did take us 20 years to reach that stage with East Linton, but it made such a difference to the whole village. We are connected with the rest of the world.I was very involved with the Borders railway and have seen what has happened there and the huge benefit that it has brought. To cite one benefit that you might not think about, on the first day that I was down there I met a young Queen Margaret University student who told me that she was able to live at home while studying. The Borders suffers greatly from depopulation, so that is one real benefit for towns that are a bit further away.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

There is an argument that we should fix what we have already developed rather than building shiny new things. What do you think about that, Allison?

Allison Cosgrove
link

If a community is looking to develop a station that was in its area previously, or to develop a new station, as has happened in some areas, we should look closely at its case. As Nigel Mullan said, we should listen to what local groups and local people are saying. If they are going along to their MSP’s office and saying, “We’d like a station because it will stop all the congestion on the motorways and I will not need to use my car,” we should pay attention to that. The two bits of Government—the pro-rail bit and the bit that says, “Do not use your car”—do not seem to be joined up at all, which puzzles everybody.

Jordan Jack Campaign for North East Rail
link

I want to respond to the question about repair versus new. We need to keep up the railway because, otherwise, the bill will get bigger and bigger, and, all of a sudden, all that we will be able to afford is maintaining what we already have. However, we dinna need to replace like with like.Aberdeen station used to have six through lines and many platforms for both directions. It now has only two through lines and three buffer-end platforms that face the south. Platforms 8 and 9 are still there, but they have no rails; they are just empty platforms. When we go to spend millions on renewing all that track at Aberdeen station, perhaps we should say, “Well, we are spending all this money, so could we spend just a little bit more and add those two lines in and give us all that extra capacity.” Also, when it comes to things such as renewing signalling, we can add extra capacity by decreasing the gaps between trains and by modernising and updating old Victorian designs, so that we can run larger and longer trains and create more space for rail freight in particular.There is also a question of targeting. To come back to the point about local knowledge, I will give two examples from my corner of the country. On the Aberdeen to Inverness line, it currently takes between two hours and 20 minutes and two and a half hours to go between those cities. The line is mostly single track, with some double-track sections. There are sections that are double track and then it goes to single track and back to double track. When we are renewing that single track, we could look at the sections between the double-track sections—for example, between Inverurie and Insch—and double just that section, and suddenly the line would be doubled all the way to Insch, as most of it has been done already.My key point is that if we were to do that—I am nae saying that that alone would do it—and take the two hours and 20 minutes down to one hour and 59 minutes, suddenly train drivers and conductors could do two trips to Inverness and back in a day, rather than the one trip they currently do. The furthest that they can go in a day is to Huntly, back to Aberdeen and then to Inverness and back, because of the working time regulations. If they could do two trips in a day, we could suddenly operate that line with half the staff—or, on a more positive note, we could double the number of trains on that line with the existing staff, or anything in between.That is a targeted investment that could be paired with the repair budget. I am making the point that when we are repairing things, we should be looking at the opportunities that we have. We can think, “If we’re doing a bit of work here, is there anything nearby that we could upgrade for a little bit extra along the line?”I will quickly give a second example. I mentioned the empty platforms at Aberdeen station. Because we have only two through lines in Aberdeen and they are both intercity lines, train drivers spend more than 50 hours a week shunting trains out of the way of other trains to free up those through lines. That is 50 hours on a train driver’s salary—whatever that is now—times however many drivers it takes. If we were to put those two lines in, there would be a steep up-front cost, but we wouldna be spending that each way, and those staff could be redeployed to build resilience into other services.All that said, however, we could spend all the money in the world, or in the Government, on upgrades to the railway, but in certain places it is nae gonna help. People in Fraserburgh, Peterhead and Ellon are nae going to be bothered about a train journey between Aberdeen and Inverness being under two hours, because they still need to spend an hour driving to Aberdeen in the first place. It very much depends on the area. As I said, we need to look at joined-up thinking as much as possible.

Nigel Mullan Newburgh Train Campaign
link

To follow on from the exact points that have been made by my campaigner colleague, there is, in the control period, a spend earmarked by Network Rail for the line that passes through Newburgh between the junctions of Ladybank and Hilton, which is single track. It has earmarked in its maintenance work schedule a passing place. It could put that passing place right in the middle of that stretch of line, where Newburgh lies, and—following on from that logic, which is the sensible logic of previous campaigners’ arguments—it could put in a couple of platform lengths at the same time.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Excellent—I like your nice and simple solutions, Nigel.

Tom Thorburn Rail Action Group East of Scotland
link

I will take up the point that Allison Cosgrove made about investment in Victorian structures. First, we all have to do better, do we not, for our young people. Young people came to us and said, “Please do something for us in the Scottish Borders”—on the eastern side, which is quite a distance from the Borders railway—“such that we can get to university and come back home again.” Not only has Reston station enabled that to happen; those youngsters have stayed with us in the Borders, whereas before there was an exodus.The next thing that I want to speak about is the infrastructure. When the east coast main line was electrified the Calton tunnels were reduced to single line only, and that has caused huge problems for east coast main line traffic, such that we supposedly cannot get any more trains on to the line, because there are no more paths.12:00We want to see the same thing that happened in the Winchburgh tunnel, with electrification put back into the north Calton tunnel, such that it is retwinned and the paths are available. Almost every train has to sit outside Waverley station at Abbeyhill junction, waiting to get into the station. It is mainly the LNER trains that get preference to get into the station. We want to see the line retwinned, which would take away the congestion and allow more trains to run. That, in turn, would allow us to get more services for ourselves, down towards Berwick-upon-Tweed and on to Newcastle. We should be doing our best for our young people.

John Hamilton Winchburgh Developments Ltd
link

I wanted to mention the Winchburgh tunnel, which is possibly another case study in how we really have to improve our transport planning. The Winchburgh tunnel was lowered by 2 feet in 2015 as part of the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme—the line electrification. We made an approach to Network Rail about whether it would be possible for us to do some of the railway station work at that time.This is not down to Network Rail, but it could not be done, because the planning for the station had not been done in conjunction with electrifying the Glasgow rail line. For us, that could have been an opportunity to integrate things, but it could not be done, because the electrification of the Glasgow to Edinburgh line had priority. Nothing else was going to get in the way of that. Another new station was not going to be allowed to slow down electrification of the timetable. We did the timetable work that identified that the Dunblane and Stirling to Waverley timetable could be used with the new electrified service without any detriment. My question would be why that transport planning was not done in advance, so that that was already known.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

I want to discuss community benefits. When Transport Scotland and any of the big contractors start to carry out work that is subcontracted out, there are community benefits such as graduate schemes. I will use the example of East Kilbride, which is my constituency. Luckily, we have just received two new train stations along with the electrification of the line. I would be keen to hear more about any experience of community benefits for constituents.John, you have been talking about the housing at Winchburgh and about the developers and the further contribution that could be made to the town, so I will bring you in first.

John Hamilton Winchburgh Developments Ltd
link

I agree with other opinions that have been expressed. Rail investment can be transformational for an area, whether or not that refers to small towns that are on their uppers, as has been mentioned. It can change people’s lives. Our overall public transport strategy relies on buses as well, but buses do not work for everyone. Buses very often need subsidy; they do not turn up very often. On the integration of bus services with rail transport, locating transport hubs or nodes can generate growth for an area. It has been proved that creating those nodes boosts economic growth in any major city or town, and that helps people’s lives. It helps them to move around and get jobs, and it creates better communities. We see that almost daily.The support for the railway station in Winchburgh has never faltered. People want to see it getting done. However, the challenges are huge. As I said, a better way of planning such things and communicating that to people, so that they can have greater certainty on where they want to live, would be a big help.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

Thanks very much.Allison Cosgrove, you have covered quite a few projects.

Allison Cosgrove
link

When the station was proposed in East Linton, the field near the station immediately went up for sale, so we knew that we would get new houses. However, we are not a very big village, and we thought that new houses would be good. We have had about 80 of them. We have had lots of young families. You cannot have a village full of old grannies like me. You need young families . That keeps the school, the shops and the church open, and the cubs, scouts and guides—all the things that a village depends on. They are the life-blood of a village. We can sit at the back, getting older.People sometimes decry having a lot of housing. For example, housing has changed Dunbar enormously. It has made Dunbar, which was a very small village, into a very large town, and there have been huge improvements in its rail service because of that.To digress south of the border for a moment, Ashington was a bit like Leven—very neglected ex-mining communities. The railway line opened two years ago and all that can be seen along the line now is house building.

Collette Stevenson SNP East Kilbride
link

I will just say that we still need all our grannies. Thanks, Allison.

Tom Thorburn Rail Action Group East of Scotland
link

I will reiterate that the Scottish Borders has the biggest proportion of senior citizens in Scotland. That is for two reasons. One of the main reasons was that our youngsters were leaving. However, since the station reopened, that flow of youngsters out from the eastern Borders has been stemmed, because they are staying at home.The other thing is that, just now, a huge development is taking place off Eyemouth: the Berwick Bank wind farm. We are working with the harbour master at Eyemouth. The harbour is to be extended to about three times its size, to cater for all the vessels that will go out to support that wind farm. The harbour master has said that he does not want a construction village there; he wants all those people to come in by train.We have set up a meeting on 12 November with the managing director and senior staff of our provider, TransPennine Express, such that we can bring in integrated bus services. We will bring the harbour master to that meeting. We in Scotland—in Britain—are very poor at integrated transport. We want to showcase it, because the harbour master is willing to put up money, as the council will have to do. Currently, six vessels work out of Eyemouth for the Neart na Gaoithe site, and Berwick Bank is going to be 10 times the size of that. Those people will need transport, and they will need it to be integrated. We hear that people are travelling from Newcastle in taxis because there is no connectivity. The harbour master wants that to be stemmed and he wants us to help him achieve that objective.

Nigel Mullan Newburgh Train Campaign
link

I will jump in very quickly about the Levenmouth project. We were talking about the involvement of the community and community benefit. There was a very good project along the River Leven that used youngsters and voluntary groups to regenerate and restore it. There was work on conservation, footpaths, plantings and all the rest of it, so that when the trains were arriving along the riverway, it had also already been transformed. They did a very good black and white animation of that project, which is on YouTube, and which captures beautifully the kind of thing that you are after, because it introduced a lot of new skills to people, and it introduced youngsters to filmmaking, animation, script writing and all that stuff.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

You will be aware of the commentary, particularly after the election, about public service reform and the opportunities that the Government sees to improve efficiency of public spending and to increase the pace of delivery.We had Transport Scotland in front of us a few weeks ago and we were talking about the length of time that it takes to deliver rail projects. I was hoping to start with you, Allison, given your experience of multiple projects. When it comes to bringing Transport Scotland back in-house, are the issues solely structural, or is there also a cultural issue? What practical steps would you like to see to speed up delivery of future rail projects?

Allison Cosgrove
link

There might be some who think that it is a cultural ethos; perhaps it is simply that things do not get done in a hurry. However, when you are campaigning for a station for 20 years, it does seem like an awful long time.How do we bring about change? Others will have different viewpoints, but perhaps it is about more frequent dialogue, a feeling that people are not in silos, a feeling of being listened to, and people being able to make valid points that are taken on board. If people are saying, “Look, thousands of people are driving from this town to work every day because the station is not open,” that should not simply be disregarded; it should be acted on. That is the kind of thing that I mean.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

Nigel, you said earlier that you wanted to get the rail experts in. Are there any other practical steps that you would like to see come out of public service reform?

Nigel Mullan Newburgh Train Campaign
link

It all seems to be a bit up in the air, this plan to reform. I mean, how many times over the years have we been reforming Government, local government, regions and all the rest of it? I think that we need these national bodies and that they should maybe be a bit more accountable to bodies such as this committee and the Parliament. We also have to strengthen regional transport partnerships and local authorities.This is perhaps a broader issue, but there has also been a lot of talk about place—about developing place, transforming place and having pride in place and even having growth in every postcode. However, we have to look down the telescope both ways. Local communities also need support in developing projects. We could talk about community development workers. All of that costs money, to be sure. However, within regions and local authorities, and perhaps even within Transport Scotland, maybe there should be teams of people or a person who could engage more directly with local communities to help them get on with community development, which is broad brush.Transport will not change everything; there is a multitude of other issues. Newburgh started looking at that through its sustainable Newburgh project, which examined what people thought and what they felt they needed. The railway station emerged at the top of the list, and it was pursued helter-skelter thereafter.12:15

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

Is it your view, then, that the answer is not only engagement but deeper community engagement at those levels?

Nigel Mullan Newburgh Train Campaign
link

Absolutely.

Tom Thorburn Rail Action Group East of Scotland
link

Yes. I formed a group in 1996 and, from then on, the aim was to reopen East Linton and Reston stations, and East Lothian Council asked us to take on Haddington as well. In that period, the committee and I had very little dialogue with Transport Scotland; all our dialogue was with the transport minister. To be honest, I felt at the time that the Government was dictating that we should not engage with Transport Scotland. Therefore, I stepped away from that and all my dialogue was with the minister and the MSPs who were on board with us.East Linton station opened on 13 December 2023, so we are now a wee bit on from that and ready to build up again and put our case forward for Haddington station. However, that is how it was for us: all the dialogue was done via the transport minister.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

The Government is talking about fundamentally changing how Transport Scotland functions by bringing it back in-house. Is that an opportunity to make positive changes?

Tom Thorburn Rail Action Group East of Scotland
link

I would like what we have all said to the committee today to be taken on board, so that we can have more engagement with Transport Scotland. It is a two-way thing: it is not only about Transport Scotland speaking to us; it is about us speaking to Transport Scotland.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

Thanks for that, Tom. Government officials watch this committee very closely, so I am sure that that will be taken on board.I will come to you next, John. What are your reflections on public service reform?

John Hamilton Winchburgh Developments Ltd
link

Whether Transport Scotland is in-house or not, getting the people who need to develop programmes and discuss agendas together in one room, whether it is a meeting room, a workspace or an office, needs to happen in a much more integrated way. Way back, we found it difficult to have conversations with Transport Scotland officers—things later improved for us—and have separate conversations with Network Rail, and we could tell that the bodies were not speaking to each other.We were ultimately able to present our project as one in which we had planning obligations to meet in terms of other forms of public transport, and we had an obligation to develop an integrated transport strategy and look at a business case for rail. I am not a rail or transport expert, but we were left to do that, and we had to find the right people to get into the room. For that reason, and for the other reasons that I mentioned earlier, achieving that took quite a few years. Once we did so, we found that the level of collaboration was very good. Getting people aligned on the same agenda through meetings and working arrangements improved dramatically. That speaks to the need to review the culture of having silos for different parts of transport delivery in Scotland.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

Thanks, John. It is also an opportunity to improve accountability and get it to the right place.Jordan, when I mentioned culture earlier, I saw you nodding enthusiastically.

Jordan Jack Campaign for North East Rail
link

I would not go as far as saying that the culture at Transport Scotland is anti-rail, but it is certainly abrasive at times. I disagree with some of the other witnesses about whether Transport Scotland itself needs reform. We saw the announcement to take the agency in-house as positive because of the opportunity that it provides.Local knowledge is key. Even having such an agency based in the central belt makes it difficult for places such as ours, because every time Transport Scotland officials have come up to visit or attend an event that we have held, sometimes alongside the transport minister or our local MSPs, our time has been cut short because they had to get back home again. It is literally that simple for us. We are always rushing to get out the door. We can never say enough to them, and they can never say enough to us.We talk about reducing the need to travel in our transport policy. We certainly need centralised transport policies and strategies, but we already have transport partnerships in our council areas. Nestrans, SEStran and many others have local knowledge and ties to their communities and they regularly engage with councillors. Therefore, I see this as an opportunity to distribute Transport Scotland’s power to our local authorities or similar bodies.

Lloyd Melville SNP Angus South
link

I will come in there, because the Government has published its first goal as part of its local government reform programme, and there are questions about the future of regional transport partnerships and whether they should be brought into the new regional council model that the Government is looking at. Do you have a particular view on that balance of power?

Jordan Jack Campaign for North East Rail
link

Having regional transport partnerships is very useful. Nestrans, which comprises politicians, people in the community and people in the industry, has been an enormous help to us, even just by having the expertise to help us navigate the system.To put a head on this, when we have engaged with MSPs and MPs during our campaigns, we have found it easy to lobby them and have positive engagement. However, a lot of councillors have fed back to us that they feel like it is nae their job. They feel that, because we are campaigning for such a large project, it is a national Government thing and nae really for them. What else can they dae apart from publicly giving us their support?If transport decisions were taken closer to the transport partnerships in the localities, they widna feel that way. They would feel like they had the power to help transport projects come through in their communities.

Willie Rennie LD The Convener · Fife North East
link

Witnesses, you have been excellent. Thank you very much for your expert evidence and advice. The dysfunction of the process, the need for expertise in the process and the need for speed are all factors that have come across very clearly from you all. You have had a range of experiences: some of you have delivered projects and some of you are perhaps a little bit further away from achieving them. The session has been incredibly valuable and will feed into the pre-budget report that we will submit to the Parliament and that the Government will therefore read, so thank you very much for your evidence. Do follow our proceedings. If you wish to provide any other advice or evidence in future, do not hesitate to contact the clerks.This is the last meeting at which we will have Pauline McIntyre as our clerk. I was going to say that she is going off to do lesser things, but they are bigger and better things. We wish her well. She has been excellent at getting the committee up to speed from a standing start and, on behalf of us all, I thank Pauline for her excellent advice and support over the past few months. We wish her well for what comes next.Greg Black is stepping up to fill Pauline’s shoes. We have already got to know him through our proceedings behind the scenes, and we look forward to working with him more closely over the next period.12:25Meeting continued in private until 12:46.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.