I thank Adam Harley and the Scottish Liberal Democrats for bringing the debate to the chamber. I also thank the Donaldson Trust, Scottish Autism and the many organisations and individuals who have contacted members ahead of today’s debate.
I speak in the chamber in my role as Reform’s health spokesperson, and I am convener of the Health, Care and Sport Committee, so I am aware that people are desperate for this bill and of how much interest there is in seeing forward movement on it.
On 1 September, the minister informed us all that the bill would not proceed, so I will start with the simplest question: why have a bill at all? The minister has been clear about why she thinks that we should not have one. She thinks that change can come faster through policy reform, service improvement and targeted investment, and she said that legislation would take several years. I understand that argument.
The draft proposals that were published in March were not perfect—few drafts are—but that is not a reason for ditching them; it is a reason for improving them, as other members have said. A bill gives something that a policy paper cannot: accountability. It provides a benchmark—a line in statute that says what people are entitled to expect and against which ministers, health boards and councils can be measured. Without a bill, we are left with good intentions, and Scotland has never been short of those. The road to hell is paved with them.
The commitment to the bill was made in 2021—five years ago. Since then, there have been a consultation, panels, analysis, delay and draft proposals this year. Then, in September, after an election, the bill was dropped. Meanwhile, the Scottish strategy for autism and the keys to life framework came to an end in 2021, and so far nothing has replaced them. For five years, there has been no national strategy and no bill.
I have heard many commitments made in the Parliament to address specific health issues that have simply run into the sand. We do not want that to happen on this issue. The people affected—the ones we are talking about today—have also had that happen before. Other members have mentioned a lack of trust in the Parliament. The people affected can be forgiven for fearing that that is what is going to happen again.
The minister certainly analysed a long list of what is needed. She told us that the Government will still do those things, but it has had a long time to do them—indeed, she has been involved in that. It seems that something was required, and it was identified that a bill was the answer. We welcome a renewed commitment, but how will we know that the changes have happened?
The Government’s amendment is revealing. It concedes that support across the country is
“too varied and inconsistent”
and that a bill should remain an option if
“improvements are not comprehensively made”.
When will the Government make that assessment, and when will it make a decision: will it be in one year or three years?
The minister’s amendment states that
“changes can happen much faster … through policy reform”.
What is the policy reform that the same Government could not have done? What is the difference? That is why having a bill matters.
I turn to the people at the heart of this. The bill was built on lived experience—that of people with learning disabilities, neurodivergent people, autistic people and their families, who gave their time and expertise. Other members have identified how difficult that was. Consultation and engagement are only worth something if they lead to decisions and actions. When that does not happen, those who are consulted are left very upset—often angry—and dispirited, and it can affect their mental health. That is not a small thing in a debate about people’s wellbeing.
I understand from Scottish Autism that the lived experience advisory panel that helped to shape the bill has been wound up, so I ask the minister: what body now carries those voices into the room where decisions are made?
People are reasonable. They understand that not everything brought to the table can be adopted. So long as there appears to be good faith about taking an issue forward, they will accept that. However, if that good faith does not appear to be there, folk get very angry or, indeed, totally disillusioned. The Donaldson Trust has told us:
“Neurodivergent people have been left feeling hurt, angry and disillusioned.”
The Government’s job now is to show good faith, but that is shown by deeds and not statements.
Reform’s amendment recognises that immediate measures can be taken in the meantime, and that introducing legislation is not a barrier to acting in the short term. The minister has framed it as being about a choice between quick action and a slow bill, but it is not a choice. We can both take action and propose a bill, and we should do so.
What might the immediate measures be? The minister’s letter credited the report on ADHD and autism pathways, which was published in January by the committee’s predecessor, with informing the Government’s thinking. I am glad to hear that. The report recommended mandatory neurodevelopmental training for all patient-facing health and social care staff; quarterly national reporting of referrals and waiting times; a road map with clear timelines; and putting third sector funding on a sustainable long-term footing, which is a critical measure. None of that needs a bill; work on it could start now. Will the Government commit to saying when that will happen?
On 7 October 2026, the minister told us that mandatory training could progress through NHS employment contracts. That is a start, but NHS contracts do not extend to teachers, council staff, police officers or court staff. As has been identified, those individuals deal with autistic people and people with learning disabilities every day. Where does mandatory training sit for them?
On pathways, the minister promised that an adult neurodevelopmental route map would be published in the autumn, based on the Royal College of Psychiatrists in Scotland’s four-level approach. It is now the end of October. When will the route map be published?
The model relies on a community tier delivered largely by the third sector, which is too often funded locally and on a year-to-year basis. If the Government means what it says in its amendment that those groups “must be properly resourced”, there should be multiyear funding that is appropriate to the task. The committee has heard from everyone that that is essential.
On data, I make the point to the minister that, on 7 October, her statement gave no estimate of how many people need help. The Government has announced £7.6 million for children’s neurodevelopmental support and other sums besides. However, without knowing the scale of need, how can anyone, including the Government, judge whether that is enough? We need to understand far better the needs of people with the most severe autism and their families, who are too often the least heard of all.
The Government talks a good game, but plans are only good if they are put into practice. Those who gave years of their lives in difficult conditions to help get the bill into place deserve more than another plan. They deserve action now, and they deserve a benchmark against which that action can be measured. That is what a bill can provide, alongside the actions to which the minister has committed.
I move amendment S7M-01739.3, to insert at end:
“; recognises that immediate measures can be taken in the meantime, to improve the lives of people with learning disabilities, autism and neurodiversity, and believes that the process of introducing new legislation is not a barrier to taking action in the short term.”