link
To ask the Scottish Government what discussions it has had with the United Kingdom Government regarding calls for additional Royal Navy surface fleet assets to be based in Scotland. (S7O-00382)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what discussions it has had with the United Kingdom Government regarding calls for additional Royal Navy surface fleet assets to be based in Scotland. (S7O-00382)
We, of course, engage regularly with the UK Government on the serious and important matter of defence. It feels incredibly important to do so right now, particularly given a report from the UK Parliament’s Defence Select Committee that outlines the existing glaring gaps in the UK’s ability to properly defend itself.
link
Faslane naval base is the operating base for the entire UK submarine fleet. It also operates Sandown-class minehunter vessels and Archer-class fast patrol boats. In addition to that, in Scotland, Royal Air Force Lossiemouth has the Typhoon fast attack response and Poseidon anti-submarine operations.
The Scottish National Party’s claim that Scotland has been left undefended is simply not correct and is dangerous. What specific additional ships is the Scottish Government calling for, and what operational roles does the Government envisage those ships undertaking?
link
I am not sure whether Mr Smith was listening to my initial answer, in which I referred not to SNP remarks but to those made by the UK Parliament Defence Select Committee, which has outlined glaring gaps in the UK’s ability to defend itself, particularly in the high north, where we know there is a threat from Russia.
Perhaps Mr Smith does not want to talk about that because I would have to remind him that, when Mr Putin launched his illegal invasion of Ukraine, Mr Smith’s party leader sought to blame the European Union and NATO for the actions of that tyrant. Shame on him.
link
The Labour UK Government is now investing significantly in defence and in His Majesty’s Naval Base Clyde at Faslane. However, the Scottish Government does not have an industrial strategy to speak of, and certainly not one that focuses on growing the defence sector. As we face increasing global threats, as the cabinet secretary rightly said, will the Scottish Government produce an industrial strategy as a matter of urgency, so that the Scottish economy benefits from the need for better defence?
Again, that question is not quite on the nose, but you can answer it, cabinet secretary, if you want to.
link
I am more than happy to do so. As Jackie Baillie will know, we outlined our intentions on a defence programme in the programme for government, and I intend to take that forward at pace.
I would encourage Ms Baillie, if she can, to engage proactively with our colleagues in the UK Government and show them the Defence Committee report that highlights those glaring gaps. Of course, it was only earlier this year when the UK Government had to rely on Germany to fulfil its NATO commitments because its warships were unavailable.
link
Does the cabinet secretary join me in welcoming the five type 31 frigates that the Royal Navy is building in Rosyth, which is a vote of confidence in Scotland and in the union? However, does he accept that we are not gaining the full economic benefit of that due to ongoing skills shortages in Scotland’s defence industry, with Babcock being forced to hire 300 welders from the Philippines? What is the Scottish Government doing to ensure that we expand access to high-quality apprenticeships in Scotland’s vital defence industry?
link
Of course I welcome and support the incredible work that has been done by employees at Babcock on the type 31 frigates and, indeed, by those at BAE Systems on the Clyde on the type 26 frigates. Indeed, our Scottish workforce is so successful that the small sovereign independent nation of Norway will be buying those frigates. That shows exactly what small independent nations can achieve.
On the skills point, it is helpful that Mr Hoy has asked this question, because it allows me to tell members in the chamber that this Government is working in partnership with the UK Government through a £10 million commitment to ensure that we have those skills coming through colleges. I know from a direct conversation that I had with one of the principals last night just how much the college sector welcomes that investment.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.