To ask the Scottish Government what its understanding is of the term “penstock” in class 1(g) of the schedule to the Valuation for Rating (Plant and Machinery) (Scotland) Regulations 2000, including whether that includes the penstock of a hydro-electric scheme, and if so, whether it is exempt from rateability under that provision. (S7O-00381)
Stephen GethinsSNPThe Minister for Europe, External Affairs and Energy · Dundee City East
Mr Leask is right in understanding that penstock is listed in the regulations that he refers to. However, that is subject to litigation, so I hope that he will appreciate that I cannot comment on matters relating to live rating appeals.
The valuation of non-domestic property is a matter for independent Scottish assessors, who follow applicable statutory provisions and case law in making their decisions.
I acknowledge the restrictions placed on the minister due to the legal process that is under way.
More broadly, will the minister agree to meet me to discuss how we can support small-scale and community hydro developments that are facing such challenges, and others?
I thank the member for his understanding. I am really happy to engage with him, particularly given the importance of such projects in his constituency, which I know he is a valuable and determined advocate for.
When rural estates face increasing rates liabilities for hydro schemes, that often leaves them less money for habitat and peatland restoration, woodland creation and other environmental projects. Why is the Scottish Government allowing enlightened landowners to be penalised, and why is it diverting money away from the very environmental improvements that ministers claim to champion?
Mr Baxter will be aware that hydro schemes with a rateable value of not more than £5 million may be eligible for 60 per cent relief. I am very happy to engage with him regarding the specific issues that he raised.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.