link
To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to reports that the BBC Scotland television channel is to be closed. (S7O-00379)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to reports that the BBC Scotland television channel is to be closed. (S7O-00379)
link
The proposal to close the BBC Scotland television channel is wholly unacceptable, and the Scottish Government opposes it in the strongest possible terms. It represents a significant blow to Scotland’s media landscape and raises serious questions about the BBC’s commitment to Scottish audiences and its obligation to serve all parts of the United Kingdom fairly and equitably.
It is worth noting that the decision comes against a backdrop of wider funding inequalities, with BBC expenditure in Scotland being well below that which is raised from the licence fee in Scotland. Separately, there is an entirely unjustifiable gap in funding from both the UK Government and the BBC for Welsh-language and Gaelic-language broadcasting. I have raised my concerns directly with the BBC Scotland director and with Ofcom.
link
Let us be clear: the BBC’s decision is a disgrace, particularly for those who rely most on traditional television for news and information, such as the elderly and the digitally excluded. At a time when Scotland’s constitutional future is once again a pressing issue, the need for balanced and informed debate and distinctly Scottish broadcasting has never been greater. Therefore, does the cabinet secretary agree that the BBC’s decision strengthens the case for devolving broadcasting powers to the Scottish Parliament? Given the Prime Minister’s oft-repeated promises of further devolution, will the Scottish Government press for broadcasting powers to be included in any such discussions, so that decisions about Scotland’s broadcasting future are made here, in Scotland, and are not imposed from Westminster?
link
The Scottish Government is firmly of the view that responsibility for broadcasting ought to be devolved to the Scottish Parliament, and we will continue to make that case. Recently, as part of our engagement on the BBC charter review, I set out directly to the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport our view on the need for devolution, as well as for essential developments in greater accountability, stronger representation of Scotland’s interests and, as Mr Merrick said, decision making closer to Scottish audiences.
Since becoming culture secretary, I have had cause on more than one occasion to reiterate to the BBC and Ofcom that Scotland is a nation—not a region—whose people should be able, when they turn on their radios and televisions, to see their lives authentically reflected back at them, so the BBC’s decision presents another blow.
link
Local journalism is vital to the health of local democracy. The BBC’s announcement, which follows the axing of STV North last year, is part of a growing trend of cuts in national and regional media. Many of our local papers in the south of Scotland are already hanging by a thread. It is those papers that inform the public and hold us, as politicians, to account when we do not deliver. What is the Scottish Government doing to support local journalism in rural areas such as the south of Scotland?
That question was slightly off the topic, but I call the cabinet secretary.
link
I am happy to answer that question. I am in firm agreement on the point about the value of public service broadcasting and journalism, including local journalism. We have been working to develop local journalism through the establishment of a group. I will be pleased to write to Mr Dunlop to further update him on that. Progress of late has involved formulating the group, for which the Scottish Government provides a secretariat. I understand the call for support, and the Government intends to keep providing it in the way that we can.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.