link
To ask the Scottish Government what support is available to communities seeking to take ownership of vacant or underused assets, including how it is working with local authorities to facilitate such projects. (S7O-00355)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what support is available to communities seeking to take ownership of vacant or underused assets, including how it is working with local authorities to facilitate such projects. (S7O-00355)
link
I recognise that vacant and underused assets can blight communities, harm wellbeing and limit opportunities. That is why we are continually working closely with local authorities and other partners to support community-led regeneration across the country, with investment of up to £52 million in the previous financial year. That includes funding for the community ownership support service, which provides advice and support to communities seeking to acquire assets. That is complemented by the Scottish land fund, which offers grants of up to £1 million.
link
In my constituency, the Gartcosh Development Trust is pursuing the community asset transfer of Gartcosh public hall and Gartcosh primary school, but it is facing roadblocks.
What support can the Scottish Government provide to help resolve historical title and registration issues that affect community asset transfers? What discussions has it had with North Lanarkshire Council and Registers of Scotland to ensure that such issues do not unnecessarily prevent communities from taking ownership of assets that have long been in public use?
link
Mr MacGregor is a local champion for community asset transfer, and I thank him for raising that specific issue. The Scottish Government is not directly involved with specific community asset transfers unless an appeal is made, so I encourage those who are involved to work closely together to address those issues, including by engaging with Registers of Scotland.
The Scottish Government funds the community ownership support service, which gives community groups and relevant public bodies advice and guidance on all aspects of the community ownership and asset transfer process.
link
The minister might be aware of a similar issue in Finnieston in Glasgow, where the local community has very creative plans for the use of the currently derelict Corunna bowling club. However, as a result of the Scottish Government’s decision not to call in the planning application, the land is now massively overvalued compared with what it was previously valued at. The community has a right of first refusal, but exercising that right is unfeasible in the face of such a massive increase in the price tag, to more than 10 times the previous value, purely as a result of the planning permission.
Does the minister accept that that aspect of how the planning system works serves as a massive barrier to communities that look to take disused land into community ownership and only serves to benefit very wealthy land speculators and developers? What more can the Government do to ensure that that barrier is removed so that communities are able to exercise their rights?
link
I thank Mr Harvie for bringing that specific project to my attention. I was not aware of it and would be happy to write to him and engage on it further.
Planning is being reviewed at the moment, with a view to implementing changes in 2027. Additionally, purchase orders and selling orders on community purchase will be looked at in the round. I am happy to engage on the specific project that Mr Harvie has raised.
link
I refer to my entry in the register of members’ interests: I am a councillor in Fife Council.
The minister will be aware that many communities want to take an active role in bringing vacant properties back into use but are prevented from doing so by owners who have no intention of developing, selling or investing in those assets. Will the Scottish Government therefore consider giving local authorities stronger powers, such as introducing a compulsory sales order, to ensure that persistently vacant and underused properties can be brought back into productive ownership and use in cases in which the owners have failed to act?
link
That segues from Mr Harvie’s question. Local authorities have wide-ranging compulsory purchase powers to help bring vacant and derelict properties back into use. However, we are determined to modernise Scotland’s compulsory purchase system, including planning, and we will legislate to reform the system in this parliamentary session.
Following last year’s consultation, questions were raised about whether compulsory sale powers would offer any additional benefits beyond a reformed compulsory purchase order system. We will continue to engage on that issue with stakeholders across the board.
link
I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests. I am a councillor in Aberdeenshire Council and chair of Kincardine and Mearns Youth Clubs charity.
Having participated in a community asset transfer for the charity, as well as having made decisions on other CATs as a councillor, I can attest that, in some instances, local authorities are not embracing the spirit of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015. Rather than helping to facilitate genuinely good projects, there is a tendency to condescend and to place barriers in the way. Can the minister intervene to ensure that councils follow the act’s principle of presumption in order to help CATs move forward?
link
I stress that the presumption to grant must be upheld, and that is something that the Government encourages. As I mentioned in a previous answer, the Scottish Government is not directly involved with specific community asset transfers, unless appeals are made. However, I strongly encourage all relevant authorities that are involved in community asset transfers to allow the letter and, indeed, the spirit of the 2015 act to be followed.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.