link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the impact of the changes outlined in its proposed neonatal intensive care plan on rural areas. (S7O-00341)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the impact of the changes outlined in its proposed neonatal intensive care plan on rural areas. (S7O-00341)
I want to be clear that the care provided to the vast majority of babies from rural areas will largely not change under the new model of neonatal intensive care. Many of those babies currently receive neonatal intensive care in Aberdeen, Edinburgh or Glasgow. For example, as is currently the practice in the north of Scotland, the Aberdeen neonatal unit will continue to care for babies from the Grampian, Highland and the island health boards.
The change is about saving the lives of the smallest and sickest babies and improving their outcomes. A full equality impact assessment was carried out, covering the implementation of the best start five-year forward plan for maternity and neonatal care in Scotland, and was published on 30 April 2024. That remains a live document as implementation of the best start plan continues. Health boards are also expected to undertake their own impact assessments of any local changes to meet local requirements.
link
The Scotsman has revealed new data showing that the neonatal unit at Raigmore hospital was closed to new admissions for 231 days—more than seven and a half months—between 2023 and 2025. The National Childbirth Trust said that those figures raised serious questions and warned that, when women lose access to their local service, their choice is reduced and their confidence can be undermined. Can the minister reassure my constituents that plans to rebalance investment and deliver on other NHS capital projects will finally result in progress being made on the redesign of our local neonatal unit at Raigmore?
link
I can reassure the member that a certain level of care will continue to be provided by local neonatal units. However, babies from the Highlands and Islands have always had to travel to Aberdeen to access the very specialised care to which the reorganisation and remodelling relate. We are talking about the very sickest and smallest babies. They have always had to travel, and they will continue to do.
link
The Scottish Government’s evidence review that led to the neonatal centralisation plan shows that only two of the 17 peer-reviewed papers even remotely supported the Government’s position. Several papers highlighted serious safety concerns about transporting very pre-term babies in the days after birth. Can the minister point to any changes that have been made to minimise the danger of transporting pre-term babies and to avoid outcomes being poorer for the sickest babies as a result of its neonatal centralisation plans?
link
Jackie Baillie will be aware that the plan is for the very sickest babies. It is recognised that premature labour is a very common risk in such cases. The women are stabilised and transferred to the unit at which their baby would be cared for before they give birth. Many steps have been taken to avoid the situation that Jackie Baillie has described, of tiny, premature babies having to be transferred.
I am happy to write to Jackie Baillie with details if she will allow me to do so. She will know that the system already operates in Fife and Ayrshire, and I can furnish her with details about the number of incidents of the type that she has described that have occurred since 2019. I think that she will find the data reassuring.
link
I appreciate David Green’s question on this important issue. As I have discussed numerous times in the chamber, expectant mothers in Stranraer and Wigtownshire are expected to travel 75 miles or more to access full maternity care.
While we continue to wait for the outcome of the new national review of maternity services, will action be taken to help those expectant mothers, or are rural lives not important enough for this Government to justify efficient care?
link
Senga Beresford will be aware that that is somewhat off topic given that the question was about neonatal care. I refer her to the independent review of maternity services, the details of which are available on the Scottish Government website. The review, which was launched this week, is particularly focused on rural care, which will satisfy her concerns about the care of her constituents.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.