I flew to Canada last month to watch my son Tom compete for Scotland in the Commonwealth powerlifting championships. I mention that partly to get Tom’s achievement into the Parliament’s Official Report, for which I am sure I will pay a price when he finds out, but also to make the point that the £700 it cost to take a return flight between Edinburgh and Toronto was the same as the cost of my return flight between Kirkwall and Edinburgh immediately after the election in May. Similar comparisons are regularly made by my constituents and by those who visit the islands that I represent, whether for work, on holiday or to see family and friends.
I know that there are reasons why the costs can be so high. I appreciate that Loganair, like all airlines and the aviation sector more generally, is facing enormous challenges at present and I recognise that it is not in the interests of island communities for Loganair to be financially unviable. However, I note that whereas Loganair showed a willingness in the past to cross-subsidise between routes or between busier and less busy periods of the year, that is no longer the case, which makes today’s debate all the more timely and urgent.
Aviation plays a unique role in our island communities. For people living in Orkney, Shetland or the Western Isles, reliable, affordable and accessible air services are not only about having the freedom to travel for leisure or work. Those services mean that patients can travel to Aberdeen, Inverness or further south for vital health treatment. They make the difference between someone who lives on North Ronaldsay being able to attend routine appointments, which can allow healthcare needs to be identified and addressed early, or becoming increasingly isolated, unwell and reliant on costly emergency transfers. They determine whether specialists can travel to our islands to see those with complex health needs.
For island communities, those flights are truly lifeline services and, as such, should reflect the needs of those communities. However, over recent years and across the Highlands and Islands, that has increasingly not been the case. We have seen a decline in service levels and a gradual consolidation of routes that has been described by the Highlands and Islands Transport Partnership as a “narrowing by commercial attrition”.
Loganair makes the fair point that it is a commercial business and the financial pressure of maintaining some routes is becoming more and more unsustainable, but it feels as if there is a process of managed decline, with service levels dropping, ticket prices rising and islanders being priced out of travelling on those routes, despite air discount support.
Over the summer, cuts to services between Inverness and our islands exposed the fragility of the Highlands and Islands network and the urgent need to find a more sustainable model. The funding that the Scottish Government provided through Highlands and Islands Airports Ltd to allow Inverness routes to be reinstated was welcome, but it was very much a short-term response to a longer-term problem. As Loganair has made crystal clear, the risk is that, come next March, without a further injection of subsidy, those routes will be pulled again.
Therefore, I welcome the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport’s willingness to respond positively to the calls that I and others have made for a strategic review of how the network operates. Such a review is overdue, but I am glad that work is now under way, with a meeting having taken place earlier this week. However, I make it clear that that process will require strong and sustained leadership from the Government and the cabinet secretary to ensure that reform happens, and that it happens at pace. The review must not be another that produces recommendations without delivering meaningful change.
I pay tribute to those who were involved in this week’s initial meeting. In particular, I pay tribute to HITRANS for the power of work that it, alongside other stakeholders, has put into developing potential options, drawing on experience in other parts of the world. There is the regional public service obligation network in Norway, to which I know that the Minister for Public Finance is very attracted. In Greece, we see how bundling routes can help to deliver a resilient air service network, while, in Corsica, maximum fares for island residents who access key airports on the French mainland appear to work well.
However, it must not be a case of lift and shift. Whatever model is applied in Scotland and the Highlands and Islands must reflect our specific needs and circumstances, but we should take encouragement from the fact that other countries are operating successful, sustainable models. We are not starting with a blank canvas. As I said, HITRANS and others deserve credit for the work that they have already carried out in this area.
Notwithstanding all that, the process—which will include engagement with the UK Government—will take time. I look forward to joining cross-party colleagues in a meeting with the cabinet secretary later this month to discuss next steps.
In the meantime, we must not have a repeat of what we saw earlier this summer, when routes were removed or reduced with no prior consultation with affected communities. I suspect that Donald MacKinnon will detail the havoc that that created for the national health service patients who are reliant on the Stornoway to Inverness route. In Orkney, I heard from members of the visually impaired people’s group about the impact on those who attend the national ophthalmology treatment centre in Inverness, who were forced to take detours via Aberdeen, which increased journey times, accommodation costs and stress levels.
Only this week, Loganair notified us of its winter timetable. Once again, routes from Orkney and Shetland to and from Edinburgh are being consolidated, and there is an overall service reduction of between 10 and 15 per cent. That follows a familiar pattern of merging services, combined with not overnighting aircraft in the islands, that has reduced or removed entirely the ability of people in the islands to make a day-return journey between the northern isles and the central belt. Those routes are vital for access to essential services, but they are also economically significant. Routinely merging flights limits the economic growth potential of our islands, makes regional investment more costly and reduces resilience, competitivity and opportunity.
My final point is on the physical—as opposed to the financial—accessibility of the services. In Orkney and elsewhere, Loganair’s Islander aircraft is a familiar, popular and durable mainstay of the lifeline interisle service, but, for all its virtues, it is an aircraft that presents accessibility challenges, even for passengers without mobility issues, to which I can testify. For those with mobility issues, however, it involves contortions too far and is often a no-go. To put it bluntly, it is not a lifeline service if you cannot get on and off the plane. As I said earlier, for residents of islands such as North Ronaldsay, which has no roll-on, roll-off ferry, the consequences can be dire.
On a more positive note, HITRANS and others have been working hard to find solutions—solutions the implementation of which former health secretary Neil Gray was very keen on when he attended a meeting that I organised on the issue in Orkney two years ago. Since then, HITRANS has confirmed that a suitable lifting device has been developed, and I hope that Mr Flynn will take up the invitation to visit Orkney to see the prototype in action and discuss how it might now be put to good use.
The Highlands and Islands deserves an air service and wider transport network that supports access to healthcare and other essential services, that underpins local economies and that is shaped by the needs of the communities that it serves. I welcome the strong cross-party consensus that now exists on this increasingly pressing issue. I thank those who supported the motion to allow the debate to take place, and I look forward to hearing contributions from colleagues.
17:24