Ahead of the UK budget, I rise in a spirit of helpfulness to the cabinet secretary. The problems that she faces are serious, and it would be politically easy to say to the Government that it has made its own bed, but that would not serve Scottish taxpayers, because it is taxpayers, ultimately, who will pay for the failures of a number of finance secretaries who have sat in the cabinet secretary’s seat, and for any missteps that appear in Andy Burnham’s first budget.
In evidence to the Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee, commissioner Eleanor Ryan of the Scottish Fiscal Commission identified the core problem when she said that tax rises or public service cuts would be necessary to plug the gap in the nation’s finances. Although ministers yesterday partially ruled out an income tax rise, we have heard that before, and I do not believe that we can necessarily take them at their word.
The chancellor and the cabinet secretary face interconnected and, in some respects, similar problems. Put bluntly, there simply is not enough money to continue on the present trend of social security spending. The projected gap between the adult disability payment and the block grant adjustment might have narrowed and might be less than was initially estimated, but, to be blunt, neither Government can afford current benefit levels, let alone the projections that are now baked into the system. The truth, for both Governments, is that unless the benefits bill is cut, the budget will be bust.
The solution cannot be to pile yet more pressure on hard-working Scottish households and businesses. Nor can the SNP use Westminster as an excuse—as I think it was partly doing today—to distract from its own economic failures. Those are plain to see, and their consequences will hit our budgets now and into the future: high taxes, weak earnings and employment growth, stifled economic growth and activity, and unsustainable levels of unproductive public spending, most notably to pay the soaring welfare bill.
Ahead of the Westminster and Holyrood budgets, our appeal is simple: there should be no new taxes and no tax increases. In fact, there should be quite the reverse: we must cut tax, control spending and remove the barriers to economic growth. Support for our oil and gas sector is an area of urgent concern in the forthcoming UK budget. The anti-oil and gas stance of Labour and the SNP is exacerbating and accelerating Scotland’s industrial decline, and it is therefore no surprise that domestic oil and gas production has fallen by 40 per cent in five years. UK Labour made a serious error by increasing and extending the energy profits levy, and John Healey must rule out any further increase in, or extension to, it in the budget later this month.
I agree with ministers that the effects of inflation are causing difficulties for households. Eye-watering petrol and diesel prices are why the UK Government must shelve plans to raise fuel duty by 3p per litre at the turn of the year and then again by 2p in March. That would punish motorists and businesses who are already struggling with higher taxes, higher grocery bills and higher energy costs.
Households are not alone in facing those headwinds. Mounting costs are squeezing businesses large and small. Scotch whisky exports fell by nearly 2 per cent in 2025, and input costs are rising significantly. That has led the chief executive of the Scotch Whisky Association, Mark Kent, to warn of dwindling business confidence. Equally, Scotland’s hospitality operators are struggling, with three quarters having faced a year-on-year fall in profitability in the past 12 months. Farmers, the lifeblood of the rural economy, are facing soaring costs and falling prices, and they are threatened by the SNP’s proposal for supermarket price caps and Labour’s partially withdrawn, but still cruel, family farm tax.
Cumulatively, those factors will constrain growth, increase unemployment and reduce tax receipts, but the Scottish Government cannot use a difficult UK budget and a difficult UK fiscal position as a smokescreen to avoid tackling its own challenges. As we identified yesterday, ministers must recognise that their tax experiment has failed. Yes, changes to Scottish income tax mean that we are forecast, as Mr Greer said, to raise up to £1.8 billion more in 2026-27 than equivalent UK rates and thresholds will, but the negative tax base performance gap—in other words, the impact of higher taxes—has widened to nearly £900 million. That is why Stephen Boyle, the Auditor General for Scotland, is right when he says:
“Devolved taxes are growing Holyrood’s budget, but their impact is weakened by Scotland’s lower earnings and employment growth”.
Is it any wonder that HMRC estimates that there are 9,000 fewer payrolled employees in Scotland today than there were last year? The picture is clear: in Scotland, on tax, we are at breaking point, and any upward movement in income tax, particularly in the higher rates, is likely to further undermine the tax take.
I want to stress to the minister, who recently gave us a private briefing to this effect, just how bleak and fragile the public finances are. The £5 billion black hole is real. All eyes appear to be on Ivan McKee. The eggs are all in one large basket of public sector and public service reform. Out of, I suspect, self-preservation, Jenny Gilruth is quietly painting a very big target on Ivan McKee’s back, but I very much doubt that the Government will achieve the £563 million of savings that it needs to this year.
Yesterday, the cabinet secretary announced that the Government was off track to reduce the overall size of the civil service. These must be very real concerns to the minister. In overall terms, I wish Mr McKee and the cabinet secretary well, but, when it comes to public service reform, which is where the big vulnerability is—in addition to social security—I suspect that the mission is doomed to fail, unless the Government takes on the unions, dramatically changes the culture of the civil service and persuades vested interests in its own Government, including the cabinet secretary with responsibility for social security, that things must change. If things do not change, it will be taxpayers who pay the price for this SNP Government’s economic failure.
I move amendment S7M-01395.5, to leave out from “welcomes” to end and insert:
“believes that the UK Budget should prioritise economic growth by avoiding further tax rises, keeping fuel costs down and supporting investment in Scotland; calls on the Scottish Government to control unsustainable welfare spending and deliver meaningful public service reform, and calls on both governments to reduce the burden on workers and businesses, and to support economic growth.”
15:24