link
To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to reported concerns from groups representing retail, farming and food manufacturing bodies calling for its proposed statutory food price cap policy to be withdrawn. (S7O-00322)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to reported concerns from groups representing retail, farming and food manufacturing bodies calling for its proposed statutory food price cap policy to be withdrawn. (S7O-00322)
link
I welcome engagement with the Government’s proposal to improve the affordability of essential food items during a severe cost of living crisis. We are currently holding a public consultation that will inform our next steps.
We cannot ignore the fact that food prices have risen significantly in recent years and they continue to place pressure on household budgets, particularly for those on lower incomes. We believe that the Government has a responsibility to act where there is a clear public interest in doing so. As I said, we are gathering evidence and engaging with stakeholders across the food system to ensure that all views are carefully considered.
link
I wonder whether the minister has noted that former Scottish National Party minister Fergus Ewing has added his voice to the growing consensus that the scheme needs to be scrapped, calling the food price cap a “dud”, “madcap” and “possibly illegal”, and adding that the Scottish Government seems to have learned no lessons from past policy disasters such as the deposit return scheme. Will the Scottish Government now recognise those criticisms and cancel the scheme before real harm is done to consumers, retailers, manufacturers and farmers?
link
There is no scheme in place. We are consulting.
link
In six years in this Parliament, I have seen some humdingers of SNP policies, but this one hums and dings more than any before. Is it not clear that the policy would have huge unintended consequences, including more pressure on producers and more farmers going to the wall, a big increase in the cost of non-essential items as the profit margin shifted from one product to another, and less Scottish produce and more cheap foreign imports on our shelves? Is it not time that the Government simply ditched this madcap triple whammy of damage that could be unleashed on Scotland’s retailers and consumers?
link
I welcome the member’s engagement on the issue. He obviously has strong views on the matter, and I am sure that he will take the opportunity to respond to the consultation and to engage in that process. I assure him that all responses will be considered.
I will continue, as I did this morning, to engage with a range of stakeholders the length and breadth of the food system in Scotland. At the conclusion of the process of consultation and engagement, the Government and ministers will be in a position to determine what next steps, if any, should be taken. I thank the member for his sustained interest in the matter and I look forward to his continued thoughtful engagement on it.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.