I welcome the opportunity to speak about the educational outcomes of white working-class children and the implications of the inquiry that was co-chaired by Sir Hamid Patel and Baroness Estelle Morris. I thank Stephen Kerr for signing the motion and ensuring that we had enough cross-party support for this important debate to be heard in Scotland’s national Parliament.
Why do we need this debate? We need it because the report raises an important question: are we genuinely providing every child with the opportunity to succeed, regardless of their background or family circumstances? For too many working-class families, the answer remains no. Education should be one of the greatest instruments of social mobility. It should allow a child from a disadvantaged background to pursue their ambitions, develop their talents and build a better future. That is what it did for me, as someone from a working-class background, the son of two drug addicts, who grew up in the east end of Glasgow. If my story had been written on paper, it should not have ended with me being in this building. Instead, I should have been just another statistic. If I am honest, I almost became just that, but, thankfully, through education and by being pointed in the right direction by my grandparents, I was saved.
However, my story is still an exception, not the norm. Poverty and disadvantage continue to shape educational outcomes. The inquiry highlights the significant challenges that are faced by white working-class pupils in England, including in relation to attainment, literacy and access to opportunity. Although the findings relate to England, the issues that they raise are directly relevant here in Scotland. We must be prepared to examine those issues, but when I wrote to the Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic over the summer to ask whether she would instruct a similar inquiry in Scotland, she refused. That was disappointing. In fact, she did not even mention white working-class boys in her response, which I think was disrespectful.
Scotland has a proud educational tradition. We have long believed that education should provide a route to a better life. We once had the best education system in the world, but, under the Scottish National Party Government, that is no more. Across Glasgow and the west of Scotland, families work hard, make sacrifices and do everything that they can to give their children a better future. We must ensure that their children are not held back by circumstances beyond their control.
A child who arrives at school struggling with literacy, living in overcrowded housing or facing financial hardship does not necessarily begin from the same position as a child who has enjoyed every advantage. That is a reflection not of their ability, but of the barriers that they face. It is our responsibility to address those barriers.
One of the most important issues that the inquiry raised is that of literacy. Reading is the foundation of education. A child who struggles to read confidently will find it increasingly difficult to access other subjects, participate in lessons and develop confidence in their abilities. That is why early intervention matters. We need to identify difficulties in literacy and numeracy as early as possible, to provide teachers with the resources that they need and to support families in helping their children to learn. We should strengthen links between schools, parents and local libraries and ensure that children have access to books and learning resources regardless of their household income. We must not wait until a child has fallen significantly behind before offering meaningful help, and we must ensure that support that makes a measurable difference is provided.
Another important issue is how we value vocational education. For too long, there has been a tendency to treat university as the ultimate measure of educational success. That does a disservice to many young people whose ambitions lie elsewhere. Scotland needs skilled tradespeople, engineers, electricians, joiners, mechanics and technicians just as much as it needs graduates. A young person who chooses an apprenticeship should never feel that they have been failed. We need stronger links between schools, colleges and employers, as well as better careers advice and accessible routes into skilled employment.
Apprenticeships must be respected, properly supported and available to young people in communities across Scotland, because they can provide a route to financial independence, meaningful work and a better future. That is particularly important in communities where traditional industries have declined and where young people need to be able to see a clear path into employment. We must ensure that where someone is born does not determine the opportunities that are available to them.
What should Scotland do? First, we need to have a clearer understanding of the educational outcomes that are experienced by disadvantaged white working-class pupils in Scotland, including on attainment, attendance, literacy and progression into further education and employment. It is vital that we have an inquiry here in Scotland to look at those issues to ensure that we get that right. Secondly, we must strengthen early intervention, particularly on literacy and numeracy, so that difficulties are addressed before they become entrenched. Thirdly, we must properly support schools that serve disadvantaged communities and recognise the pressures that teachers face and the wider needs of their pupils.
Fourthly, we should strengthen vocational education and apprenticeships, ensuring that young people have access to meaningful careers and a range of respected pathways.
Finally, we must measure whether our policies are actually improving outcomes. It is not good enough to publish strategies or announce initiatives; we need to know whether our children are reading more confidently, whether attainment gaps are narrowing and whether young people are progressing into education, training and secure employment. That is how we should judge whether our education system is delivering on its promise.
I will finish by speaking about the young people at the heart of this debate. A working-class background should never be a barrier to ambition. A family’s income should never determine a child’s potential, and a young person’s postcode should never decide how far they can go in life. Those are principles that we should all be able to agree on, but principles mean very little unless they are backed by action. The inquiry that was chaired by Sir Hamid Patel provides an opportunity for Scotland to reflect on the challenges facing working-class pupils and to consider what more can be done.
We should learn from the evidence, examine our own education system honestly and develop practical solutions that meet the needs of Scottish communities. When a child is denied the opportunity to fulfil their potential, Scotland loses out, too. We lose future skills, future talent and future contributions to our communities. When we give that child the support and opportunity that they need, the benefits extend far beyond the individual. That benefits their family, their community and their country. That is why this issue matters, and it is why Scotland must be prepared to act.
17:21