As all members in the chamber are aware, September is childhood cancer awareness month. I will start by recognising the progress that has been made on childhood cancers over the years. In 1975, when records began, childhood cancer five-year survival rates in the United Kingdom were below 40 per cent. Today, that number is 87 per cent, and, with optimism about what can be achieved in the future and with political will, improvements can still be made. I hope that there will be more than enough political will expressed in the chamber this evening to do just that.
I commend the work of Young Lives vs Cancer, the Teenage Cancer Trust and many other cancer charities and clinicians in their determination to improve services. I also recognise the contribution that the Government’s strategy, “Collaborative and Compassionate Cancer Care: cancer strategy for children and young people 2021–2026”, has made. The demands of childhood cancers are distinct from those of adult cancers. The strategy recognised the failings at the time and the inequality in care between health boards, leading to an inequality of outcomes. Driving forward a national strategy and national standards meant that everyone in Scotland was able to take advantage of the latest diagnostics and treatments, including specialist treatments offered from London and occasionally further afield in the US. I start, therefore, by congratulating the Government, but I also want to push it on when the next strategy will be published and what it will contain.
The centralisation of service provision has had benefits for outcomes, but it has also had drawbacks. Children and families now need to travel to facilities in Glasgow, Edinburgh and Aberdeen—that puts unwelcome strain on family finances, and cancer in children does not discriminate. For some families, the average travel costs in the UK are £250 per month. Those costs are too much to bear, leading to the alarming statistic that one in 10 families with children receiving cancer treatment have missed appointments because they could not afford the travel costs. That figure is based on a UK average of 350 miles; in Scotland, it is 400 miles, so the cost is even greater.
Those from the least deprived backgrounds are able to ensure that their child has access to the best healthcare in the world, but for families in our most deprived communities, the means to access timely, high-quality care is not always forthcoming, because money may not be readily available.
We are told that one in three families cut back on food; one in five take on debt; and nearly one third fall behind on household bills. We cannot let money be a barrier to young people accessing cancer care. The young patients family fund is a reimbursement benefit—if people do not have the taxi fare to begin with, there is no help for them. All the cancer charities, including the Edinburgh Children’s Hospital Charity, are calling for cash-first options for families to receive young patients family fund support. That would remove barriers to ensure that everyone can access support, regardless of personal circumstances.
In addition, the young patients family fund is currently available only to families of children who are undergoing in-patient care; however, for childhood cancer treatments, chemotherapy and radiotherapy are most often given as out-patient procedures. The fund stops at 16, but the treatments for young people are the same until they are 25. I therefore urge the Minister for Mental Wellbeing, Public Health, Sport, Alcohol and Drugs to expand the fund to cover treatments for out-patients, and to extend the age limit.
Indy McBreen, from Irvine in North Ayrshire, was diagnosed with acute leukaemia in July 2023, when she was aged two. She received treatment at the Royal hospital for children in Glasgow, 40 miles from home. Indy’s dad has recounted their experiences, saying:
“We live around 40 miles from The Glasgow Royal Hospital for Children where Indy’s main treatment centre is and have attended there every week for the past two years, sometimes 3-4 times per week. As for the travel expenses, it’s definitely something that has been a problem, particularly during the early stages of treatment. It was less of an issue when Indy has been an in-patient because we have the Young Patients Family Fund in NHS Scotland which (mostly) covered travel and subsistence expenses while she was in hospital.”
However, when Indy had out-patient appointments on consecutive days, the family had to be supported by Young Lives vs Cancer to stay in Marion’s house, the charity’s accommodation in Glasgow. Most of the time, they were not eligible for support from the fund. The last thing that a parent wants going through their head when they are supporting their child who has cancer is whether or not they can afford a taxi. Parents should not have to ask themselves whether they will need to choose between eating today or getting their child to an appointment, and yet that is the reality for far too many.
The 2021 national strategy for cancer treatment for children did make improvements in cancer care, because it rightly started from a place where it openly and honestly accepted that there were problems. We are told that a new childhood cancer strategy is in the works from the Government. When it appears, it must again recognise existing problems openly and honestly, without pointing to what already exists but is not actually working. It must recognise that inequality of access to high-quality care by postcode is now also inequality by income, and that the existing young patients family fund model does not work for the most deprived households. That is the barrier to delivering world-class cancer diagnostics and treatment to the children who need it.
Of course, the clinical treatment of cancers in children is just one aspect of their care. Where the physical toll of battling cancer takes a front seat, the mental load can often be ignored. A new cancer strategy for children and young people should ensure that there is provision that is flexible enough to meet the complex and varied needs of children who are going through cancer treatment. An advantage of centralised cancer care is that auxiliary care and support can also be co-located. There is no excuse for that not to be delivered effectively, but that is something that families and third sector organisations say is still lacking. I therefore call on the Scottish Government to see that that will also be addressed in the new strategy.
In closing, I look forward to the publication of the new cancer strategy for children and young people—whenever it comes; I would appreciate comment from the minister on that—but it must include removing barriers to access to treatment for families and changing the criteria for accessing the young patients family fund.
18:04