I open with the words of one of my constituents:
“I thought my husband had been swept away. I didn’t think I was going to see him alive again.”
I heard those words from her two weeks after storm Amy. I was sitting in a village hall, listening to the stories of people whose lives had been turned upside down as a result of that catastrophic weather event. Questions were asked and, through them, we heard anger, tears and frustration, but positive sparks were also there because of how community members had pulled together to support one another. There was a need to find things that they could do to ensure that if—or when—it happens again, they know what to do.
When catastrophic events occur, it is also a time when communities and organisations come together but, sadly, we tend to revert to our normal way of life afterwards, with little change being made. We can no longer do that. United Nations Secretary General António Guterres used his speech yesterday to warn us of that, when he said:
“The climate crisis went from distant warning to daily reality.”
How well Scotland adapts to such realities will be central to our future prosperity and, if I might make a local reference, how well Argyll and Bute adapts to them will be central to its own future.
The Scottish Government’s flood resilience strategy and framework are welcome and will help to build a safer, more resilient Scotland, by targeting support to where it is needed most. The £15 million fund to improve the resilience of communities is also very helpful, but, as Willie Rennie has said, that money could be spent solely in Argyll and Bute, if my inbox is anything to go by. For example, businesses in the Lochavullin industrial estate in Oban are flooded regularly. In Islay and Bute, and in many other places, the foundations of roads are undermined by extreme weather, because much of Argyll’s road network hugs the coastline. In Dunoon, a lack of clarity about whose responsibility it is to clear culverts and maintain drains has resulted in damaged roads and flooded properties.
What can be done? As Donald MacKinnon referenced, Audit Scotland’s report, “Flooding in communities” provides some solutions, such as ensuring that people, communities, councils and others have all the information that they need, by setting out clear roles and responsibilities. It suggests that we need clear timelines for the delivery of the national flood resilience strategy to ensure that flooding services are delivered by councils and the Scottish Government effectively and efficiently. The Scottish Government needs to provide clarity and certainty about how much funding is available for major flood schemes, which I hope would be multiyear. As my colleague David Barratt highlighted, we need to ensure that there are enough people with the right skills and experience to support tackling flooding.
I can relate those solutions to conversations I have had and work that I have been doing to support communities across Argyll and Bute, where there is an engaged community around Loch Awe. I have convened round-table meetings that have brought together stakeholders including the community, power companies, developers, Argyll and Bute Council, SEPA and the Scottish Government. We have made some progress but, to be honest, with so many competing stakeholders and given the effects of commercial confidentiality, progress has been slow. I am grateful to everyone who has engaged but, at some point, there needs to be recognition that people are living there and that things cannot just be done to them. For example, perhaps loch levels that worked when they were originally set are no longer fit for purpose. I suggest that there is a lack of clarity about who is responsible for decision making, and I believe that tackling that should be directly connected with our public service reform aims.
A phrase that the First Minister used in discussing the programme for government describes, in my opinion, the situation that we have with flood protection:
“too small to be strategic and … too big to be local.”—[Official Report, 1 September 2027; c 32.]
I agree with the points that Willie Rennie and Mark Ruskell made about smaller communities, and I hope that Public Health Scotland’s work will involve meaningful dialogue with the smaller communities that I represent.
As the Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Rural Affairs mentioned, the Isle of Luing is vulnerable to coastal erosion and storm damage. The coastline is built up in part by disused slate, which is susceptible to rapid erosion. The community has had big ideas about reinforcing that barrier, but it also wants to restart the island’s slate-mining industry, providing new jobs, stimulating the local economy and reducing depopulation. I am pleased that, as the cabinet secretary referenced, the community secured £2.1 million from the Scottish Government’s regeneration capital grant fund. That is hugely positive and it is a brilliant example of local people finding local creative solutions and partnering with national bodies to achieve change.
I agree with what the Green amendment says about nature-based solutions. As species champion for the Celtic rainforest, I note that investment in it could become the sponge that Mark Ruskell mentioned.