link
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on its rural support plan. (S7O-00266)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on its rural support plan. (S7O-00266)
The rural support plan provides a period of clarity and certainty, delivering direct support for the next five years to provide the industry with reassurance and boosting confidence in long-term investment.
I have to point out that certainty does not mean no change. Agriculture reform will follow an evolving continuous-improvement approach designed and delivered in partnership with our rural communities and valued stakeholders and supported by a monitoring and evaluation framework.
The plan will be amended to reflect that evolving reform journey, and I look forward to discussing it further when providing closing evidence to the Rural Affairs Committee inquiry next month.
link
My apologies, Presiding Officer. I should have declared an interest: I am a small farmer, and I am in receipt of payments under the basic payment scheme.
The minister just said “clarity and certainty”. Let me give him some quotes from the Rural Affairs Committee. We have heard that lots of things are “missing from the plan”, and that
“we are all a bit frustrated by there being no change at all.”—[Official Report, Rural Affairs Committee, 2 September 2026; c 30.]
I even have a quote to say that
“the rural support plan is a manifest failure of policy making.”—[Official Report, Rural Affairs Committee, 16 September 2026; c 3.]
That, according to the Scottish National Party, is “clarity and certainty”. How many times must we remind the Government that farmers need action? Perhaps, for example, it could give the underspend from the less favoured area support scheme—LFASS—back to the farmers who need it. Has the minister actually been listening to what the experts have been saying to the Rural Affairs Committee? What are his real takeaways from that?
link
I have certainly been listening to the takeaways from the Rural Affairs Committee and I will give my full responses when I am in front of it. There is absolutely no doubt that we have given clarity and certainty to the farming community. Between now and 2030, farmers know what they have coming, what their payments will be, and what the system is. I point out to Mr Eagle that his party introduced the sustainable farming investment scheme in England, which ran out in six hours, so thousands of farmers across the country had no chance of getting anywhere near that money. The stability and certainty that the Government has provided is exactly what farmers need. They know that they are getting a good deal.
link
If we have concise supplementaries, we could fit more in, so I ask for succinct questions.
link
I draw attention to my entry in the members’ register of interests, which shows that I run a crofting business.
After introducing the calving interval condition to the suckler beef support scheme, the Scottish Government correctly had to amend the scheme’s rules to make it workable for small herds. What lessons has the Government learned from that experience? How will the rural support plan ensure that future schemes get it right first time for small producers?
link
Donald MacKinnon has just pointed out the absolute beauty of how we are approaching the system. We constantly speak to the stakeholders—
link
You could change it!
link
If we are going to keep hearing chirping from the sidelines, the member will not hear my answer.
link
It is nonsense!
link
Enough, Mr Carson.
link
Mr MacKinnon has just pointed out the flexibility of the scheme that we have brought into play. We are speaking to the people who are directly affected. When we have seen things that we can change to make them better, that is exactly what we have done and will continue to do through the evolution of the rural support plan.
link
The rural economy and its associated industries are some of Scotland’s most important and make up a vast amount of my constituency. Therefore, how will the rural support plan ensure that the SNP Government continues to develop and articulate the future of Scottish agriculture, in close consultation and collaboration with the industry during the period of the plan and beyond?
link
The rural support plan is an iterative process that will continue to evolve and develop. Dawn Black is absolutely correct that the system needs to work with and for the farming community. We have done that and have worked with the agriculture reform implementation oversight board for five years to develop the plan. This parliamentary session is entirely about delivery, which is what I have committed to doing.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.