link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the cumulative impact of hyperscale AI data centres’ energy consumption on its commitment to meet its net zero by 2045 target.(S7O-00262)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the cumulative impact of hyperscale AI data centres’ energy consumption on its commitment to meet its net zero by 2045 target.(S7O-00262)
link
The Scottish Government is working with industry, regulators and partner agencies to understand the cumulative environmental impacts of data centre developments and to ensure that the growth of the sector is consistent with Scotland’s net zero ambitions. The Minister for Public Finance has issued a new direction that requires planning authorities to notify Scottish ministers of new data centre applications and mandates environmental impact assessments for all applications that exceed a power capacity of 50MW. Those measures will strengthen our oversight of the development pipeline and ensure that potentially significant environmental effects are considered from the outset.
link
Campaigners in Edinburgh in my region have highlighted that the proposed South Gyle data centre would consume enough electricity to power a quarter of a million homes—more than double the number of households in the city. How is the Scottish Government ensuring that the cumulative impact of such proposals is taken into account in its national climate action plans to reduce emissions from our homes and public buildings?
link
It is important that I do not focus my remarks on a particular application. There are several aspects to that question, and Hannah Mary Goodlad, the Minister for Public Finance, has set out some of the environmental impacts that are associated with live and future planning applications.
One thing that has exercised me over the past few years is that the United Kingdom Government is paying renewable electricity generators to switch off their generation when they cannot get capacity in the grid or when there is reduced demand. We need to consider whether there are off-takers for that electricity—I am not talking only about data centres—so that it can be diverted elsewhere. There was a lot in that question, but I hope that my answer gives Dr Manivannan an indication of my thinking on the matter.
I will not ask the cabinet secretary about matters that are for the planning minister, but will she advise the Parliament whether the Government will consider what impact the potential hyperscale data centres could have on the commitments in the climate change plan?
link
The climate change plan was set out in March, before the dissolution of the Parliament. However, I have said throughout the whole process that the climate change plan is an agile document. When there are particular developments, such as technological developments, or sectors that are booming, there will always be consideration of whether the climate change plan is fit for purpose. There will also be an update of the climate change plan in five years’ time. However, the point was well made about the capacity that we have for particular burgeoning sectors and the stress that they might put on our natural resources. The climate change plan is not a static document for a moment in time that is to be adhered to; it must be agile.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.