Child maintenance is a reserved matter, but its impact is anything but reserved. It is felt in homes and communities across Scotland, and ultimately it is children who feel the consequences when the system fails. When the system gets it wrong, the consequences are real. Incorrect calculations can leave families with less money to live on. Prolonged disputes can erode already fragile relationships between separated parents and put strain on new relationships and family life. These are not simply administrative failures—they affect people’s finances, their wellbeing and their trust in the United Kingdom system.
I begin with the experience of one of my constituents, who is with us in the public gallery. Gerry’s dealings with the child maintenance service date back to 2007. Since then, he has spent years just trying to establish what has happened in his case, which raises extraordinary concerns for us all. A child who did not exist was recorded on his claim. How is that even possible? Manual adjustments were then made to his financial records, liabilities were presumed and years were spent in trying to get answers.
I ask colleagues to imagine the impact of suddenly being told, while they are in a new relationship, that they need to pay for another child who they have no knowledge of. The financial implications are obvious, but so too are the implications for building trust in the new relationship with a new partner. Government malpractice on that scale destroys lives and relationships, yet nobody is held accountable.
In Gerry’s case, all of that was followed by years of disputes and attempts to establish what exactly had happened. The potential impact on an individual and on a family is enormous. Even obtaining his own records became a struggle for Gerry, with redactions, parts missing and manual manipulation of his file. That all came to light through a fuller disclosure that was provided only after he complained to the Information Commissioner’s Office.
Ultimately, my constituent was left having to investigate the CMS’s own records to establish what had gone wrong in his case. That should concern us all because, whatever the circumstances of an individual case, people should be able to have confidence that a public service is keeping accurate records, explaining its decisions transparently and providing a meaningful route by which to challenge mistakes when they occur.
My constituent’s experience does not exist in isolation. Organisers working with separated families have raised concerns over many years about administration and malpractice in the child maintenance system. That includes correspondence being lost, different advice being given by different call handlers, and difficulties around the calculation of liabilities and overnight stays, which can mean that a parent may be financially better off by spending less time with their child.
The recent BBC “Panorama” investigation has brought wider concerns about the operations of the child maintenance service into sharp public focus. I recognise that individual cases must be considered on their own evidence—I completely agree with that sentiment. However, when individual casework sits alongside wider concerns about administration, communication, enforcement and redress, it is right that we ask whether the system is working as it should.
I have tried to get answers on my constituent’s behalf. On 18 August, I wrote to ask the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions for a senior-level intervention in Gerry’s case after he featured in the “Panorama” documentary. I also wrote to the director of the child maintenance service. I asked for a senior review of the case, including the financial records, payments, manual adjustments and handling of Gerry’s subject access request. Given the history of the case, I made it clear that simply sending my constituent back through the same processes that he had already navigated was not acceptable. It is now more than a month since those letters were sent, and I am still waiting for responses from both parties. That raises a wider question about accountability. When a Scottish constituent is dealing with a UK Government service, where does accountability ultimately sit when things go drastically wrong?
That brings me to the wider question that I wish to put on the record. Scotland has developed a significant framework of support for children and families within the powers that are available to the Parliament. We have the Scottish child payment, the best start grant and the best start foods payment, and we have the disability payment for children and other forms of devolved social security. We have 1,140 hours of funded early learning and childcare for all three and four-year-olds and eligible two-year-olds.
Those policies are different in purpose and design, but they recognise something important, which is that supporting children is about not simply one payment or service but all the circumstances in which children grow up, the needs that they have and the support that is available to their families. However, child maintenance sits outside that framework. A Scottish family can interact with Social Security Scotland, Scottish education, Scottish courts and family law and Scottish childcare services, which are all designed to support our children, while the important source of financial support following family separation is being dealt with through a failing UK Government system. When the system fails, the consequences do not stay in Westminster; they arrive at kitchen tables in Scotland.
I was struck by the submission that was made to the Smith commission in 2014 by Families Need Fathers Scotland, which is now known as Shared Parenting Scotland. It proposed that
“child support … should be devolved to Holyrood.”
The organisation argued
“that family policy, legislation and administration should be”
brought closer together to create a more “coherent” and less fragmented approach to supporting families and children. It went on to argue that it was
“fundamentally wrong that child support and family law should”
operate
“on separate, effectively divergent, tracks.”
That submission was made 12 years ago. Considering the problems that families are still facing today, it is now reasonable to ask whether the position deserves to be revisited.
Devolution of the CMS system would not be without challenges, of course. That submission recognised questions around cost and difficulties that could arise when parents live in different parts of the United Kingdom. However, families do not experience issues as separate constitutional issues; they experience them as their family life.
Gerry’s experience should not be the experience of any family trying to navigate child maintenance. No parent should have to spend time investigating a system to find out what has happened in their own case, and no child should bear the financial and emotional consequence when that system fails. That is why I have secured the debate, that is why these issues matter and that is why I hope colleagues will support the motion.
17:50