link
To ask the Scottish Government what criteria it uses when assessing proposals for new railway stations. (S7O-00255)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what criteria it uses when assessing proposals for new railway stations. (S7O-00255)
link
Rail proposals are considered by Transport Scotland on the basis of robust business cases that are developed in line with Scottish transport appraisal guidance and Transport Scotland’s guidance on the development of business cases, as well as other Scottish Government priorities, such as our rail investment strategy, and affordability. The Scottish Government remains committed to enhancing Scotland’s rail network, as demonstrated through the delivery of the Levenmouth rail link and the upcoming opening of the Balgray station in East Renfrewshire later this month. Those are both examples of where a robust case has been demonstrated.
link
The minister should know that the proposals for Cove and Newtonhill stations meet all the criteria that have been used in recent projects around Scotland. Given that they have not been signed off yet, which of the criteria that the minister has just listed do the proposals for Cove and Newtonhill stations fail to meet?
link
I know that the member is apprised of those issues, because I wrote back to him on the matter earlier in the summer. He will appreciate that the scoping of the strategic business case is ongoing, with support from officials. He will also appreciate that any future decisions on whether to proceed with proposals will be subject to the strength and robustness of the evidence that is presented through that process, as well as wider Scottish Government priorities. I will endeavour to keep the member up to date as the matter progresses.
link
Railfuture Scotland anticipates minimum annual usage of more than 700,000 journeys at potential new stations across South Scotland including at Beattock, Cumnock, Mauchline, Hurlford, Symington, Thornhill, Eastriggs and Dunragit. What specific criteria will be used to prioritise rail infrastructure investment in rural regions such as South Scotland, where total use might be lower but car kilometres saved would be significantly higher than in urban areas?
link
I will not repeat the points that I made in my answer to Mr Kerr. A range of measures are involved in determining the suitability of any further investment. As well as what is set out in STAG and in Transport Scotland’s guidance on the development of business cases, we have to take into account wider Government priorities and affordability. In doing so, however, we must recognise the differential impact that investment can have in rural and urban areas.
link
Is the minister aware of the excellent work that is done by my constituents in the Beattock Station Action Group? Will he agree to come to my constituency to meet them and see at first hand how transformative a new station at Beattock could be, not just for the community but for the whole of Dumfriesshire?
link
I recognise the member’s interest in that issue. I believe that we had an exchange on it previously. I am more than happy to ensure that his request for a visit from the transport secretary is passed on to him.
link
Do the minister and the Scottish Government support in principle the extension of the Borders railway to Hawick and then on to Carlisle to join up with the west coast main line?
link
I am conscious of the work that is being done on rail improvements as part of the Borderlands growth deal. We recognise the significant improvements to connectivity that can be achieved. As I touched on in my answer to Mr Kerr, we have seen significant investment in the rail network during this Administration’s tenure in office. We are committed to continuing to work constructively with communities, but we have to balance those priorities against the investment criteria and the Government’s wider priorities.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.