To ask the Scottish Government how it will include the experiences of LGBTQ+ families in its review of national health service in vitro fertilisation access criteria, in order to meet the review’s aims of broadening eligibility, improving access to fertility preservation and reducing waiting times. (S7O-00254)
Maree ToddSNPThe Minister for Mental Wellbeing, Public Health, Sport, Alcohol and Drugs · Highlands and Islands
Those experiences are an important reason why we committed to doing a review. I am aware of the experiences that have been shared with me by LGBTQ+ families who have faced long waits to get treatment due to the availability of donor eggs and sperm. There is clear variation across Scotland, which is why the review will look specifically at patient experience on the issue.
We have asked the national fertility group to lead the NHS IVF access criteria review, and the group will make costed and demand-modelled recommendations to ministers on the next steps. The reduction of waiting times for those who require donor gametes will also be included. The review of NHS fertility preservation guidance will also be taken forward separately by the national fertility group.
My constituents Rochelle and Charlie will be fantastic parents, but the criteria for accessing IVF have put huge barriers in their way. Their chosen sperm donor, who will be present in the family member’s life, is being precluded due to his diagnosis of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, taking pre-exposure prophylaxis and his relationship status. Does the minister agree that none of those characteristics have anything to do with parent suitability, and does she share my concern that the IVF care protocols may be exposing LGBTQ+ families to discrimination?
I recognise that there are clinical criteria for all couples who are accessing IVF. I will certainly take on board the comments that Holly Bruce has made, and I will go back and look at whether clinical criteria are being applied to people who wish to donate gametes that might be precluding them from donating. I will take that on board and will go back and discuss the matter with officials.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.