To ask the Scottish Government whether the commitment in the programme for government “to ensure that, by the end of 2031, no one waits more than 26 weeks for treatment” applies to all forms of healthcare, including gender identity services. (S7O-00236)
Maree ToddSNPThe Minister for Mental Wellbeing, Public Health, Sport, Alcohol and Drugs · Highlands and Islands
It is important to recognise that waiting times for accessing gender identity services remain unacceptably long, and I am fully aware of the impact that that can have on people who are waiting and on their loved ones.
The 26-week target that is set out in the programme for government relates specifically to elective in-patient and new out-patient waits. It covers about 40 specialty pathways that patients follow in accessing acute surgical and medical specialist services on a scheduled basis, including orthopaedics, ophthalmology and cardiology. To support that work, we have announced a further £90 million of funding to help patients who are waiting the longest for elective treatment.
We continue to support specialist gender identity services. Since December 2022, we have invested almost £8.5 million, including more than £7.2 million that has been provided directly to health boards that deliver those services in order to improve service delivery and reduce waiting times.
Many of my constituents who have been waiting years will be deeply disappointed if an apparently clear statement in the programme for government simply does not apply to them. As the minister will know, in Glasgow, waiting times even for a first appointment can be more than five years and waiting times for treatment are measured in the decades. It is simply unrealistic to imagine that we can go on in this way. Does the minister accept that nothing less than transformational change is necessary and that that must include the decentralisation of those services?
I recognise the situation that Patrick Harvie has described, and I agree that we need to think about a different way of delivering care. We recognise that performance is not yet at the level that we all want at certain gender identity clinics, particularly those run by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde.
Over the summer, I had the privilege of visiting NHS Highland gender identity clinic, which is functioning really well. I was delighted to hear about the reconvening of the managed clinical network, which will provide an opportunity for areas to share expertise and good practice in order to improve performance across the country.
Katy ClarkLabThe Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
Can the minister speak about the specific staff recruitment challenges with gender identity clinics? Does she agree that, as parliamentarians, we should all be mindful of the language that we use so that people who access those services feel supported?
Gary Bouse is absolutely right. Gender identity healthcare services are specialised, and clinics across the United Kingdom have reported challenges in workforce recruitment and retention. As I said, since December 2022, we have provided more than £7.2 million of investment directly to health boards that deliver such services in order to address those challenges.
In the background, such services have been the subject of highly polarised discourse, at the centre of which are real patients and the hard-working staff who support them. The clinics have cited toxic media discourse as a factor in recruitment difficulties, and I profoundly agree that all politicians here should be mindful of that when speaking about the matter.
Given the continued pressures on the national health service, can the minister confirm that reducing waiting times for patients with life-threatening and clinically urgent conditions will remain the first priority in meeting the 26-week target?
It is not a case of either/or. We know that, relative to the wider population, trans people continue to suffer poorer outcomes in mental and physical health. We are committed to promoting, protecting and realising the right to health of everyone in Scotland, including trans people. In my answer to Patrick Harvie, I gave details on who is included in the waiting time target and where the funding is going.
Katy ClarkLabThe Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.