link
To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to address the criminal trade in counterfeit cigarettes in local communities, including what support it provides to trading standards departments. (S7O-00221)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to address the criminal trade in counterfeit cigarettes in local communities, including what support it provides to trading standards departments. (S7O-00221)
link
I recently met the Scottish Grocers Federation to discuss the impact on legitimate traders of illicit trade. I fully recognise the harm that is caused to businesses by such illegal activity.
We are committed to doing everything that we can to disrupt that damaging activity. We work with trading standards and law enforcement partners, and we are engaging with a range of stakeholders, as well as with the United Kingdom Government’s high street serious organised crime unit. In addition, we are considering what further action can be taken to tackle high street criminality. That includes reviewing the framework for closure orders and any changes to the law that may be required to strengthen enforcement.
link
I thank the minister for that response and for her prior engagement on the matter. I am aware of one shop in my constituency that has no planning consent that is selling counterfeit cigarettes at a third of the normal retail price, undercutting legitimate businesses. The trading standards department is aware of the situation, but it has told me that it lacks the powers to shut down the shop in question. Will the Scottish Government’s review include giving more powers to local authorities to shut down such shops and take organised crime off our high streets?
link
It is important for the member, trading standards or anyone who has such concerns to report those crimes to Police Scotland. Trading standards officers already have a wide range of enforcement powers available to them. They can seize illicit tobacco, take enforcement action, seek prosecutions and apply for banning orders, working closely with HM Revenue and Customs and Police Scotland to tackle organised crime.
Tackling illicit tobacco remains a priority for the Government and our partners. Through operation CeCe, for example, partners including Police Scotland have seized more than 1.8 million illicit cigarettes and more than 1,100kg of hand-rolling tobacco in Scotland during 2025-26, which demonstrates the significant enforcement activity that is under way.
In addition, the Scottish Government is currently reviewing antisocial behaviour legislation, which includes the framework governing closure orders and whether changes there would strengthen enforcement.
link
I pay tribute to the minister, who has been an advocate on the issue of vapes as well as on counterfeit tobacco.
My colleague Mr Barratt is absolutely right that there is a role for trading standards departments here, but the reality is that trading standards departments have been hollowed out over many years, and we do not have as many staff. I ask the minister to work across Government, particularly with her colleagues in the education department, to ensure that more apprentices are going into regulatory standards so that we can empower trading standards officers to shut down the types of shops that are selling counterfeit tobacco.
link
I am grateful to Mr Linden for his focus on this area. He will know that responsibility for workforce planning rests with individual local authorities and with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, in their role as employers. Nonetheless, it is an important point, and there has been a conversation on progress there. The Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform asked Consumer Scotland to make proposals under section 3 of the Consumer Scotland Act 2020 to help inform the Government’s approach to trading standards services in Scotland. That report has now been received, and we are looking at recommendations in order that we can be as effective as possible in this area.
link
Does the Scottish Government accept that the growth of counterfeit tobacco is a sign that organised crime is gaining a foothold in local communities?
link
Organised crime is of serious concern to the Scottish Government, and it affects communities in Scotland and further afield. That is why the record funding that has been provided to Police Scotland by the Government is so important, given Police Scotland’s ability to make the best operational decisions in order to deal with criminality where it exists. The connection that the member has made between organised crime and the problem of illicit tobacco is a very valid one, and I would assure him that it is a matter of ongoing consideration for the Government.
link
Back in March 2024, Fife Council’s trading standards team made use of detection dogs provided by Consumer Protection Dogs UK. That resulted in the confiscation of nearly 3kg of suspected counterfeit roll-up tobacco in one operation. Can the minister confirm whether the Government has considered providing more detection dogs to all relevant bodies that investigate the manufacture and sale of those dangerous items?
link
I recently visited some of the detection dogs that the member speaks of, and I was very impressed by their effectiveness. I have been given other evidence to indicate that, as one of a range of measures, they provide a helpful tool to help us detect and deal with that particular kind of crime. The actions of local government, trading standards and Police Scotland in their operation are really for them to determine, but the member makes a valid point, highlighting the value of that as one element that we can use.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.