I am glad to speak in this debate. Like the First Minister, I agree that men need to show leadership in the Parliament and across Scotland. Violence against women and girls infects every corner of our society, and the fault lies with adults—with men. Tackling violence against women and girls in our schools means changing the attitudes of boys and young men. That is what I will focus on first.
I have mentioned before in parliamentary debates the report that Zero Tolerance produced in 2023. It was shocking but not really surprising, because it found that almost seven in 10 pupils in our schools had experienced sexual harassment in the three months before that survey was conducted. They were overwhelmingly but not exclusively girls and young women. A third had experienced unwanted sexual touching. That means that a third of young people in our schools had been sexually assaulted in the three months immediately prior to that survey, and, in over 70 per of those cases, the pupils did not report that sexual harassment even when it was severe, even when it included unwanted sexual touching.
We are not just talking about a few bad apples. We need to accept the huge scale of the problem. According to the large-scale survey that the University of Glasgow did not long ago, a significant minority of boys and young men in our country hold views about women that can only be described as outright dangerous. This is a pandemic of violence against women and girls, and there is no silver bullet. There is no one solution, but there are obvious changes that we can make, and there are obvious changes that we have been making.
I think back to when I was first elected here, in 2016. The Education and Skills Committee conducted an inquiry into the state of personal and social education in our schools. At that point, Jenny Gilruth and Gillian Martin were also on that committee. We found that the guidance that teachers were being provided with to teach about sex and relationships, which at that point was basically brand new—it was from 2014—had no section on consent. We were teaching boys and young men about sex and not teaching them about the importance of consent.
That parliamentary inquiry led to a report, and the Government accepted its recommendations. That led to an Education Scotland review and a report whose recommendations the Government accepted, and then there were around half a dozen other steps. It is only now, earlier this year, that we finally finished the revision to that guidance that teachers are provided with.
I pay credit to Jenny Gilruth and, before her, Shirley-Anne Somerville in their roles as education secretary for making sure that that work was done, but we should reflect on the fact that it took us 10 years to change a single document to make sure that young men in our schools learn about the importance of consent when they are being taught about sex and relationships.
Earlier this month, the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children was outside our Parliament, continuing to campaign on the issue, because it is one thing to produce a new document that is better than the one that came before it but it is another thing entirely to make sure that it is being implemented in our schools. There is a role there not just for national Government but for local government.
We now have teaching resources on relationships, sexual health and parenthood education that start with that substantial section on the importance of consent and respect in relationships. We need to make sure that every school and every classroom in our country is using that resource, because even the inadequate resource from 2014 that we revised was not being consistently used by teachers in our schools. If we want to change these attitudes, we need to make sure that that education is consistently of a high quality.
To go back to the other part of the Zero Tolerance report, the low level of reporting also needs to concern us, because there are young people across our country who are not confident that, if they report to their school, they will be taken seriously. Schools need to give their pupils confidence. They need to find out why pupils are not confident reporting in the first place.
Young men need positive role models. As the First Minister and Russell Findlay said, the algorithms on all our social media platforms reward toxic misogyny. If only this Parliament had more powers to regulate social media. However, although this Parliament’s powers are limited, there are things that we can do. Men in public life in Scotland need to contest the online space—we cannot cede it. Any void that we leave online is being filled by toxic and violent misogyny. We need to contest that space and provide positive role models, not only to change the attitude of boys but to change the attitudes of men of all ages, backgrounds and positions in our society.
We have men in positions of power not believing women, which directly puts their lives at risk. We have men who let their mates away with jokes about violence against women and girls, putting their lives at risk, exactly as Willie Rennie described. One in four teenage boys in Scotland believe that it is not sexual harassment if it is meant as a joke, and one in three believe that girls wearing revealing clothing are asking for trouble. That is all learned behaviour; it is not naturally occurring. It is a result of the environment in which they have been brought up and something that we can change. To normalise that behaviour and to fail to challenge it convinces abusers that they have impunity. We have a responsibility to challenge misogyny, including when it happens in the Parliament.
There is so much more that Parliament and Government can do. We can change attitudes, but we can also change the law. We all know that it is easier for us to change the law than it is to change attitudes in our society. We have systems, which have been built up over decades and centuries, that make violence against women possible and perpetuate it.
I will give one brief example, which is that of council tax arrears in this country. Right now, in Scotland, there are women who are paying off the council tax debts of the abusers they have escaped. Other women are unable to escape violent households because of such situations. I pay tribute to Shirley-Anne Somerville for the work that she did with me, which will be published next month, on the Housing (Scotland) Bill. It will chart a way forward for us to resolve that particular scandal and to ensure that no women who have survived and escaped domestic abuse are forced to pay off the perpetrators’ debts. However, we could do so much more, such as dropping means testing for legal aid for survivors of domestic abuse and tackling the wider problem of legal aid deserts.
I welcome the Government’s announcement that it will introduce a misogyny bill, because this Parliament, especially the men, need to do more. We need to challenge behaviours and attitudes, lead by example and take seriously the legislative and policy issues that have allowed this pandemic of violence to continue.