link
To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to the 2026 programme for international student assessment statistics. (S7O-00217)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to the 2026 programme for international student assessment statistics. (S7O-00217)
link
There are results to welcome in Scotland’s PISA 2025 results, notably that Scotland performs significantly above average in four of the five measured domains and that there is very welcome evidence of a weakening between socioeconomic disadvantage and PISA attainment. I welcome those results, alongside strong indicators of wellbeing, belonging and self-directed learning.
However, I am also very clear-eyed about the need for improvement. Reforms that are already under way include the curriculum improvement cycle and our national approach to ending mobile phones in the learning environment, as well as the unique opportunity offered for improvement by the First Minister’s public sector reform agenda. They will all be taken forward.
link
The facts speak for themselves. Scottish kids remain a year behind their English counterparts in mathematics and science—that is a fact. If the Government spent less time crafting political spin and faced up to the reality that fewer kids can read, maybe we would get somewhere.
The cabinet secretary will be aware that Glasgow City Council has engaged primary school teachers for intensive reading lessons with secondary school pupils who can barely read in their mother tongue. What discussions has the cabinet secretary had with Glasgow City Council about that initiative and with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and other local authorities regarding the possibility of extending that programme to help pupils across the country to read?
link
There are a number of things that I should like to say to Jenny Young about her hyperbolic contribution to these sensitive matters.
First, as she is a former teacher, I might have thought that she would have thought a little bit harder about how the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development instructs us to understand PISA. It states:
“PISA provides an important source of evidence on educational outcomes and experience, but it should not be viewed in isolation.”
I ask Jenny Young to consider what the OECD states in that regard.
In respect of reading, I would also like to point her to the evidence in this year’s PISA statistics that demonstrates that the link between socioeconomic disadvantage and reading attainment against PISA is weaker than it has ever been in any previous cycle. That is evidence that teachers and education professionals across this country, aided by the Government’s support for the Scottish attainment challenge, are weakening the link between poverty and poor attainment throughout Scotland.
link
In a year in which a record number of 18-year-olds have secured a place at university, including a record number of acceptances among the most disadvantaged young people, it is important that we recognise our progress.
During freshers week this month, I was speaking to students at the University of Glasgow who were starting the next chapter of their lives. It was a real reminder of the opportunities that education can open up. I did not have the opportunity to attend university.
This year’s exam results show a narrowing of the poverty-related attainment gap, as well as improvements in areas within PISA. Will the cabinet secretary outline how efforts will be targeted to go even further?
link
I strongly welcome that contribution, because it offers the perspective that the OECD instructs us to take when considering PISA: not to allow it to be the one lens through which we judge the entire education system, but to be clear minded about what it tells us about the state of play across Scotland. We are, therefore, absolutely right to highlight the fact that, according to Universities and Colleges Admissions Service data this year, a record number of young Scots are going on to university and a record number of those come from our most disadvantaged backgrounds. That is equity and excellence in practice, and it is what we will continue to pursue in Scotland’s education system.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.