link
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will assess the potential economic impact on Scotland’s labour market of recent updates to the UK register of licensed sponsors. (S7O-00213)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will assess the potential economic impact on Scotland’s labour market of recent updates to the UK register of licensed sponsors. (S7O-00213)
link
Scotland’s demographic challenges reinforce the need for migration policies that meet our distinct workforce needs, and I have renewed our offer of engagement with the United Kingdom Government on tailored Scottish migration routes. The UK register of licensed sponsors, which is the Home Office list of organisations that are approved to sponsor overseas workers, is updated regularly to reflect changes affecting sponsors or the immigration rules.
We continue to assess the impact of the UK immigration system on Scotland’s economy. Scottish employers that are interested in sponsoring overseas workers to fill gaps can contact Scotland’s Migration Service for advice.
link
Recently, I looked through the Fife entries in the updated list of sponsors. I was shocked that many businesses across Fife are bringing in workers to cover entry-level roles in shops, restaurants and food delivery services. Can the minister clarify whether the Government thinks that it is fair for so many entry level and starter jobs to be taken up by migrant workers when those roles are desperately needed by many young, struggling Scots?
link
As I set out in my original answer, I remind the member that those operational matters are reserved and are within the purview of the Home Office. Therefore, it is not something that I or any other Scottish Government minister has direct authority over. On the general point, I hope that the member has had the opportunity to engage with businesses and would recognise some of the challenges that exist in many parts of Scotland.
We seek to do all that we can to support young people in Scotland into work, and a lot of engagement is taking place between me, the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport, and the new Minister for Innovation, Technology and Tertiary Education, Alyn Smith, on that particular area. I hear from employers across hospitality, the food sector and social care about the absolutely vital contribution that migrant workers make.
Given that our population growth is entirely dependent on inward migration, it speaks to the need to have an immigration system that is tailored to Scotland’s needs. If the UK Government is not willing to devolve those powers to the Scottish Parliament, it should engage with Scottish ministers constructively. The matter is of vital economic interest to us all.
link
The minister has partly answered my question. Does he agree that the UK Government’s hostile visa system fails to reflect Scotland’s workforce needs and that, due to its fear of Reform UK in England, the Labour Government is openly undermining our efforts to recruit doctors, nurses, care workers and support staff?
link
David Barratt makes an important point. It comes back to the fundamental issue that the UK’s migration system is, ultimately, based on UK averages and does not recognise the specific challenges that we face in Scotland. I reiterate that the Scottish Government’s position is that all powers should be with this Parliament and that, even in the context of devolution, Scotland should have powers over migration. If the UK Government is not willing to consider that, it should at least work with us to allow for tailored routes into Scotland. That is not novel in an international context; we see it in other jurisdictions and it would respond to the acute labour shortages that we face.
We will continue to do all that we can, through our education and skills system, to ensure that there is a pipeline of labour to support Scottish industry, but we cannot escape the demographic challenges that we face. That is why it is an economic imperative that we have a migration system that responds to the needs of Scottish businesses.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.