link
To ask the Scottish Government what work it has carried out following the Parliament's vote to boycott, divest from and sanction Israel. (S7O-00196)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what work it has carried out following the Parliament's vote to boycott, divest from and sanction Israel. (S7O-00196)
link
I acknowledge yesterday’s announcement by the Foreign Secretary, which was welcome, but I am sure that we both agree that it was long overdue. I have asked officials to engage with their counterparts in the United Kingdom Government to explore what the changes will mean in practice and how they might impact the Scottish Government’s ongoing work.
We both agree that we need to go further. The Scottish Government has repeatedly called on the UK Government to end all licensed arms exports to Israel. As Ms Mackay will be aware, in September 2025, the Scottish Government announced an immediate pause on new awards of public money to defence companies whose products or services are provided to countries where there is plausible evidence of genocide being committed by that country.
link
The movement from the UK Government is absolutely welcome, and I am pleased that the Scottish Government is engaging with it. However, as the cabinet secretary will be aware, the announcement covers only goods, and only those from the occupied West Bank, so we need the Scottish Government to go further on affected services and other economic drivers. When will we see a plan to meaningfully implement the vote of the Parliament, which the Government supported?
link
As Gillian Mackay knows, the announcement was made yesterday, and I have asked colleagues to engage on the issue. We can come back and discuss the matter once we have engaged with the UK Government to figure out what the announcement means for the Scottish Government. I acknowledge the Foreign Secretary’s personal commitment to the matter, but we can all agree, especially those of us who believe in the international rules-based system and the need to protect it, that the announcement was long overdue and that we need to go much further.
link
Does the cabinet secretary agree that the escalation of extreme physical brutality and violent raids by illegal settlers in the West Bank and by the Israel Defense Forces represents Palestinian ethnic cleansing—a deliberate erasing of the Palestinian state? I am glad that he welcomes the Foreign Secretary’s announcement yesterday, but will he also acknowledge that the policy is backed by the new Prime Minister? It represents action, not just words. It is perhaps the bare minimum, but the UK Government took a big step yesterday. I hope that the Scottish Government will work alongside the UK Government in good faith, so that we can be clear with the international community that this is where we all stand.
link
I have acknowledged the work of the Foreign Secretary, who is obviously backed by the Prime Minister. Moreover, as I mentioned to Gillian Mackay, I have asked officials to engage with their counterparts in the Foreign Office on the matter. Pauline McNeill will understand that we are not even 24 hours out from the announcement, so I think it only appropriate that we give them time to work through matters.
In reply to Pauline McNeill’s other point, I would note that, earlier this week, Ratko Mladić was given state honours when he returned to Belgrade and that the worst humanitarian crisis on earth is going on in Sudan. She is right to raise issues about the West Bank, and I am glad that the UK Government has acted, but those events underline the fact that the international rules-based system is under attack as never before, and it is incumbent on us all to react.
link
I am glad that the UK Government has belatedly taken this action, but I would point out that Britain Owes Palestine, a cross-party campaign, is calling on that Government to formally acknowledge and apologise for its actions during the British occupation of Palestine. In September 2025, the campaign submitted a petition to the UK Government on behalf of 14 Palestinians, documenting systematic breaches of international law during the mandate period. A year on, however, the petition has received no response. Does the minister agree that the UK Government should issue that apology?
link
Jenni Minto has raised another important issue. I am a great fan of learning about history, and we cannot seek to understand the current situation in the Middle East—or anywhere else, for that matter—without such an understanding.
The Scottish Government’s concern about the situation in Palestine is well documented, and I pursued it when I was at Westminster, as well as in the Scottish Parliament. Our focus has been on the necessary steps towards peace and humanitarian—
link
On a point of order, Presiding Officer.
link
I am sorry to interrupt, minister. We have a point of order from Mark Simpson.
link
Why are we are wasting time discussing issues in the chamber that, per schedule 5 of the Scotland Act 1998, we have no power or influence over?
link
That is not a point of order.
link
As a member of an internationally outward-looking Parliament, I am pleased that colleagues in my own party and others are raising such issues, and for an important reason—it tells us who we are. Based on that—and based on the good question that was raised by Gillian Mackay, and which was followed by Pauline McNeill and pursued by Jenni Minto—I say that the Scottish Government will continue to do all that we can within our devolved powers to support those suffering in Gaza and the West Bank.
A two-state solution is the only way in which the Palestinians and Israelis can live side by side in peace, prosperity and security. Regardless of what the member from Reform has said, I am going to continue to talk about that.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.